Star Trek reboot vs. Star Trek original

Started by Silent Master23 pages

stardestroyer.net isn't a canon source. therefore isn't valid proof for a debate.

Its also a non movie source.

Originally posted by Silent Master
stardestroyer.net isn't a canon source. therefore isn't valid proof for a debate.
It supports my viewpoints unlike their viewpoints. Lol.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Its also a non movie source.
It isn't even needed as you used a no limits fallacy.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Stick to your own rules quan. Nobody said anything about no limits.
You acted like their shields can't be brought down. They can. The Borg aren't some unbeatable enemy despite your implications.

The MVF Golden Rule:
What is seen on screen is canon in these forums. If your character you wish to use has feats/actions/handicaps that contradict what that character did on screen (movie canon), then it is a violation and is illegal. MOVIE FEATS ONLY!.

Stop using non-movie sources.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Stop using non-movie sources.
What have I said which contradicts the movies ?

Originally posted by quanchi112
It isn't even needed as you used a no limits fallacy.

Where?

Originally posted by quanchi112
You acted like their shields can't be brought down. They can. The Borg aren't some unbeatable enemy despite your implications.

I never said nor claimed any such thing.

Originally posted by quanchi112
What have I said which contradicts the movies ?
The MVF Golden Rule:
What is seen on screen is canon in these forums. If your character you wish to use has feats/actions/handicaps that contradict what that character did on screen (movie canon), then it is a violation and is illegal. MOVIE FEATS ONLY!.

Stop using non-movie sources.

LOL at Stardestroyer.net . That site has about as much credibility as CBR. Its filled with nothing but fanboys.

Originally posted by playa1258
LOL at Stardestroyer.net . That site has about as much credibility as CBR. Its filled with nothing but fanboys.

The best part is, even after it's been pointed out to be a 1)Non movie source 2) Non-canon and 3) Against board rules... quan is still trying to use it.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I have seen the film. It was awful. You twist things. Ships avoids black hole. See it doesn't work. Ship escapes genesis device. They barely got away and were lucky conveniently omitting it won't benefit your side either. Lol.

Reboot wins despite the Borg adapt and can't be beaten fanboy ism.

Another example of me explaining something about the movie and then you acting like I didn't just explain it and you new all along 🙂

Yeah, you've not seen First Contact either 🙂

Originally posted by Silent Master
He actually just copy and pasted from http://stardestroyer.net/mrwong/wiki/index.php/Borg_adaptation

LoL, plagiarizing and from a non canon source. 😂

What a sad, sad, sad clown.

Anyhow bandwagon-boy, see a Borg cube take on many 24th century ships and destroy from a canon movie feat source:

YouTube video

I expect little flips due to ignorance cos of the end 🙂

That battle lasted hours too, and featured at least thirty ships against one cube, each one of those ships (for those who don't know) being the far superior of the JJ-prise.

Indeed. Then you'd have the Scimitar plus 2 Valdor class warbirds which along with the D'deridex class are the most powerful ships in the Romulan fleet. They actually power their ships by harnessing black holes.

Regardless. Quantum torpedoes on the enterprise E and defiant would 1 shot any ship in the reboot films. They are massively more powerful than the torpedoes on the narada which are the most powerful actual weapons in the reboot. Why red matter is even considered a factor given that it can't be deployed rapidly or even targeted as a weapon at ships. Unlike the genesis device which is actually a torpedo. The fact that the vengeance can fire at warp is a novelty in the reboot. It's standard in the next gen era. All in all. It's a bitchstomp. Quan's entire argument is based on the fact that the action in the reboot is more actiony. Totally ignores the fact that ships and weapons get more powerful over time and the original run of films has 150 years over the reboot timeline. It's like arguing that muskets are more powerful than nukes.

Originally posted by jaden101
Why red matter is even considered a factor given that it can't be deployed rapidly or even targeted as a weapon at ships.

quan has never cared about facts. he just picks which side he likes best and then lowballs or ignores any feats listed by the other side, while making borderline retarded arguments for his.

He then tries to get the last word, because he thinks that is how you win a debate.

In other words he's a troll and should be permabanned.

Originally posted by jaden101
In other words he's a troll and should be permabanned.

Yep, that is also why he avoids the comic vs forum; he knows that pr has no problem with banning him for trolling.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Where?

I never said nor claimed any such thing.

Then concession accepted.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Stop using non-movie sources.
No.