Originally posted by Silent Master
He's using wiki again
I knew he was using Wookieepedia, a 2 second search of part of his copy/paste linked it.
I'm just asking him to link to his "George Lucas says it isn't canon" claim, cos I'm pretty sure Lucas hasn't made that claim in regards to the 2008 movie, as he's involved and I want to see how long he'll dodge.
PS, saw that you took up his BZ challenge and he backed down.
Originally posted by Robtard
Animated characters from movies are allowed in the MVF, there are active threads with them now and it's the character form the same continuity. PM Impediment if you have to; he'll tell you the same, just stop crying over it, bandwagon-boiLove how I just killed your last "Anakin can't block!" fail-stand. Burst that bubble. *POP*
So Anakin has no live-action feats of blocking a blast of Khan's weapon's yield? I give Anakin a 6/10 chance to rip the gun out of Khan's hand, with Khan, who is admittedly fast, having a 4/10 to aim and fire, which will kill Anakin with such a powerful ship-destroying blast.
I'm not bringing his animated feats into this.
Read the rules, guys. It's crystal clear:
If it happened on screen then it is canon, live action or animated.
No specific version of Darth Vader was given for this BZ thread, therefore we can assume that all versions canonical to the SW Universe are being debated. The rules state that if the thread is not firmly cemented after the first few posts or first page, then it is not acceptable to randomly change feats or versions.
That is my ruling.
Yeah 'cause Quan wants it all but he can't have it.
Its in his face but he can't grab it.
Originally posted by Lestov16
Anakin is fast and agile in movement, and has wide-ranged telekinesis, but has he ever disarmed somebody pre-firing? Anakin is fast, but not fast and precise enough to prevent Khan from pulling the trigger, which need only happen once.That's a good showing for Luke, but he's not in this.
It was Padawan Luke. Who is clearly weaker than Anakin who had been Knighted for 3+years.
It's like if Superboy moves a planet then by default Superman can.
AOTC Kenobi has also disarmed before being fired on: Goto 9:10
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IdSUKIFnYc8
So it'd be silly saying all these Jedi who are clearly inferior to ROTS Anakin/Vader can/will do it, but Anakin can't/won't.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Incorrect. Not canon to the films which is G canon.Does anyone else have a clue save me ? Rhetorical don't answer that please. Khan wins and its getting even better you all are citing a tv canon source not canon to the movie series.
Star Wars movie list:
Yes TCW movie is included as a Star Wars movie. The fact that it's created and executive produced by George Lucas himself leaves no room for denying that. Not to mention the Mods ruling.
Originally posted by DARTH POWER
It was Padawan Luke. Who is clearly weaker than Anakin who had been Knighted for 3+years.It's like if Superboy moves a planet then by default Superman can.
AOTC Kenobi has also disarmed before being fired on: Goto 9:10
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IdSUKIFnYc8
So it'd be silly saying all these Jedi who are clearly inferior to ROTS Anakin/Vader can/will do it, but Anakin can't/won't.
I concede here. I'll say Anakin 8/10, because there's still the chance he'll want to pull out the saber. Bloodlusted or not, it's his fighting style.
Originally posted by Robtard
Cite a valid source with George Lucas saying the Animated 2008 film isn't canon. Cos iirc, he produced Star Wars: The Clone Wars and film. Also, PM Imp already. His rule is final.
i'll site an interview where he says it is canon.
"I haven’t limited myself with what stories I’ve wanted to tell; This is Star Wars, and I don’t make a distinction between [Clone Wars] and the films,"
/spite thread
cry quanchi