Battlezone challenge: Khan vs. Darth Vader

Started by Sadako of Girth20 pages

Originally posted by focus4chumps
i'll site an interview where he says it is canon.

http://www.scifinow.co.uk/interviews/17871/george-lucas-and-dave-filoni-talk-star-wars-the-clone-wars-2/

/spite thread

cry quanchi

LOL

Best get building an Ark, gather the animals, cancel all deliveries and prepare for the flood of clown tears, cause this will get biblical.

Was pretty crazy to claim its not canon to Lucas who created the damn show and all the big plots came directly from him.

Or to claim TCW movie is not canon to the films when it is officially listed as a SW film.

Originally posted by Lestov16
The Rob-Quan banter is going to be epic

I see no reason why. Quancho was simply wrong with his 'George Lucas said it's not canon' claim and he knows that now; should be the end of the issue, imo.

Quan is probably going to take an extended break away from the forums to gather himself now lol.

he'll be back soon enough to say the last few pages of his clownpiss never happened.

Originally posted by dadudemon
Nope: not how it works. Same character, same franchise, it's a movie. etc. etc. etc. Just deal with it and move on. Surely there are other arguments to be made other than "Vader cannot block the blast with his saber"?

You could argue that since the CW Film covered Anakin and not Vader that technically, it doesn't count. However, that would be asinine and bad form, imo. As we saw when Obi-Wan cut up a pre-suit Vader, he has the same powers and abilities: it was just a name change similar to Abhram changing his name to Abraham when he become a servant of God: Anakin just become a servant of Sidious. ;D

However, The Clone Wars is T-Canon.

According to the series creators, continuity with the other Expanded Universe works is being taken very seriously by the series' creators, with Dave Filoni being well-versed in the Expanded Universe. However, Dave Filoni has defended any differences in continuity: "But theres never an implicit connection between the micro-series that Cartoon Network did previously and the series that were doing now. I personally as a fan never think of it as discrediting any of the other material, its just that other material is from a different point of view, a different look at the war and take on the war. Its an ever-Expanding Universe in a lot of ways."

Different point of view in a toon sense. T canon isn't the highest form of canon. It isn't canon to the love action films and is directly contradictory to those portrayals of the characters.

you cant override george lucas with your google-chimping. stupid tourist.

Originally posted by Robtard
I knew he was using Wookieepedia, a 2 second search of part of his copy/paste linked it.

I'm just asking him to link to his "George Lucas says it isn't canon" claim, cos I'm pretty sure Lucas hasn't made that claim in regards to the 2008 movie, as he's involved and I want to see how long he'll dodge.

PS, saw that you took up his BZ challenge and he backed down.

Already been accepted. I'm not agreeing to his silly rules. Not how battlezones are done with dqs anyways.

Originally posted by Robtard
So no link to your "George Lucas said it's not canon" claim, bandwagon-boi.

A "you mad" to hide that you know you're the one that won't be able to handle if the Mod rules against you. No wonder you duck out of your own BZ challenges when people finally take up your offers.

Linking your valid source seems to allude you.

Holocron and creator say otherwise. Different viewpoint and style in a toon sense. These characters aren't capable of this kind of stuff in live action films. 🙂

Darth power already accepted, kiddo.

Try and focus here.

Originally posted by focus4chumps
you cant override george lucas with your google-chimping. stupid tourist.
Series creator and tbh Licas sold the rights. Lol.

Originally posted by Lestov16
So Anakin has no live-action feats of blocking a blast of Khan's weapon's yield? I give Anakin a 6/10 chance to rip the gun out of Khan's hand, with Khan, who is admittedly fast, having a 4/10 to aim and fire, which will kill Anakin with such a powerful ship-destroying blast.

I'm not bringing his animated feats into this.

Never been done before therefore inapplicable. Khan shoots him and he dies. Simple.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Fast reactions or not, the indicators that would be the warning sign to Khan to resist are not there.

By the time he'd realise the gun was being snatched (or simply being moved enough to disrupt aim) it'd already have happened.

Back your claim.

Even if they agreed with you Quanchi about the clone wars issue, I think they are right, Anakin would still kill Khan pretty easily.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Series creator and tbh Licas sold the rights. Lol.

doesnt matter. he wrote the story. moving forward he has no say, and while disney is now free to contradict his allowance of CW into canon, they have not.

therefore you are ONCE AGAIN factually incorrect and flailing about like an emotionally compromised google-chimp tourist because you were proven wrong.

get madder.

Originally posted by Lestov16
Funeral will be held on Monday.
For Vader because there is no one to save him this time.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Yeah 'cause Quan wants it all but he can't have it.
Its in his face but he can't grab it.

YouTube video

It isn't considered highest form of canon nor are the characters portrayed at all close to film portrayals. Series creator said its a different viewpoint aka in a toon sense. Different. Not canon. Like I said.

Originally posted by Newjak
Even if they agreed with you Quanchi about the clone wars issue, I think they are right, Anakin would still kill Khan pretty easily.
Based on ?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Based on ?
Feats.

Anakin is more dangerous and more powerful. He will carve Khan up. And yes I've seen all the movies for them.

Originally posted by focus4chumps
doesnt matter. he wrote the story. moving forward he has no say, and while disney is now free to contradict his allowance of CW into canon, they have not.

therefore you are ONCE AGAIN factually incorrect and flailing about like an emotionally compromised google-chimp tourist because you were proven wrong.

get madder.

I quoted the guy who wrote this story. Different take in a toon sense.

Continuity buff hired for all Star Wars agrees. T canon. 😂

Series creator I quoted with regards to this movie. As always I'm right and your wrong.

Tears of joy and vindication.

Originally posted by Newjak
Feats.

Anakin is more dangerous and more powerful. He will carve Khan up. And yes I've seen all the movies for them.

Cant block the über gun. Simple. His feats aren't enough and we've seen greater Jedi have to block blaster fire against Jango Fett.