The Official "Argue with Quan about Zelda" Thread

Originally posted by The Scenario
95% good, 4% mean, 1% actual selfish behavior.

Unless you have some other evidence that might change this percentage. I mean, yeah, Midna didn't want to save the Light World originally. That's true. However, she was always trying to save the Twilight Realm. That's true, too.

Hey, quan, is Midna trying to rescue the Twili a selfish action?

Yes, and no other actions were taken to put her back on the path of selfishness. No one "cooled" her down.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
...linkXilia...

So what exactly is Quan arguing?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Yes, and no other actions were taken to put her back on the path of selfishness. No one "cooled" her down.

Yes but she is no longer an "ice" princess. Though she started out as a "cool" character, by the end of the game she was pretty "hot".

She was hot all right

Originally posted by Zack Fair
So what exactly is Quan arguing?

Quanchi believes that Midna is evil, or at least neutral. Or the "both" cop out he's going for recently.For some reason, he cannot stand the idea that Midna is on the side of good, or might be a good person.

I'm not sure why, since the argument requires a hefty amount of blindness to change and character development.

Quan, why are you so adamant on midna's "temperature" ?

not sure what the temperature is supposed to mean, but Midna did make a turn for good in a surprisingly good character development by Nintendo standards.

I made a metaphor earlier, and I will stick with it till it stops being "evil".

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Ok, imagine midna is like ice. She's all cold and stiff, but after the warmth of friendship and sacrifice she became water or steam. Now she still has the potential to be ice, but we would need something to change the temperature. Since nothing happened to cool her back to ice, she's still water or steam. Does that make sense?

This ^

The temperature is a metaphor for Midna's character. Or her "temperament," so to speak. If cold is evil, and warm is good, then what temperature is Midna?

Quan still says both.

mmm

Midna gets ALL the links.... why is saria there?

Midna is making sure no childhood sweethearts get in the way. Thats how she rolls.

Doesn't matter if its her Link or not. she gotta have them all.

But saria is an eternal 9year-old. All she would have to do is wait two years...

Midna takes no prisoners...and there are benefits to thousand years old midgets like Saria.

Not going to elaborate on those.

🙁

You guys think we might ever get a TP sequel?

Can't get enough of the duo =[

Kinda defeats the sacrifice she makes at the end, wouldn't it?