The Official "Argue with Quan about Zelda" Thread

Started by quanchi11287 pages

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Show her doing something selfish or demonstrating a lack of empathy, or being even a little bit evil, once, through out the entire game. You cannot. Let alone at any point after she has begun her character development. Also it's funny how angry Link makes you.
Not angry at all I know it bothers you.

She already was selfish. My point is proven. I win.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
So she was good for the second half of the game?
She has both inside her depending on the situation and actions of others.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Not angry at all I know it bothers you.

She already was selfish. My point is proven. I win.


Yes, chuckling at your immaturity bothers me. 😛

Unless your point is that you can't grasp simple concepts, no, you've proven nothing.

What is one selfish act Midna commited?

If midna admited she changed before the first mirror shard ten ganondorf reconfirmed it whe we see him, can we assume she stayed changed for that duration of time?

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Yes, chuckling at your immaturity bothers me. 😛

Unless your point is that you can't grasp simple concepts, no, you've proven nothing.

What is one selfish act Midna commited?

I have proven she has committed both selfish acts and selfless acts thus backing my claim she is capable of both.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
If midna admited she changed before the first mirror shard ten ganondorf reconfirmed it whe we see him, can we assume she stayed changed for that duration of time?
We assume she was moved and was selfless due to their actions. She was selfish prior to and her future behavior is dependent on circumstances and the actions of others.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I have proven she has committed both selfish acts and selfless acts thus backing my claim she is capable of both.

No, you've said she at one point didn't care about the light world so long as she saved the Twilight Realm. Boohoo. Before even the mid game she's willing to die to protect the light world.

IE, the only selfishness you've ever even claimed doesn't exist in Midna. She is good.

But for the second half of the game, she was good?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
But for the second half of the game, she was good?
She has displayed both.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
No, you've said she at one point didn't care about the light world so long as she saved the Twilight Realm. Boohoo. Before even the mid game she's willing to die to protect the light world.

IE, the only selfishness you've ever even claimed doesn't exist in Midna. She is good.

yes, it was shown. Both were shown. Point proven.

Originally posted by quanchi112
She has displayed both.

Not during the second half between the two quotes. Is she good for that duration of time?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Not during the second half between the two quotes. Is she good for that duration of time?
This is picking and choosing aka cherry picking. Biased posters do this hence why I laugh at you.

Originally posted by quanchi112
yes, it was shown. Both were shown. Point proven.

Again, all this proves is that Midna is not selfish.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Again, all this proves is that Midna is not selfish.
It proves she has been selfish and has been selfless. You want to ignore one since you are biased.

I'm not cherry picking, just wondering if you agree she was good from light spirit death to ganondorf fight. Anything after is fair game. Is she good for that period of time?

Originally posted by quanchi112
It proves she has been selfish and has been selfless. You want to ignore one since you are biased.

Midna is not Selfish. Do you disagree with that statement? If so, why?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
I'm not cherry picking, just wondering if you agree she was good from light spirit death to ganondorf fight. Anything after is fair game. Is she good for that period of time?
She is both selfish and selfless. Can't ignore that.

But during that specific period of time, was she good?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
But during that specific period of time, was she good?
She has been good and bad before.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Midna [b]is not Selfish. Do you disagree with that statement? If so, why? [/B]