Superman vs A Planet

Originally posted by abhilegend
You didn't say that the planet was totally shattered despite there being no shattered planet? Yes or no.

Originally posted by abhilegend

Which means what? We aren't in a grammar class.

I didn't deny anything which was outright said once, yet you're discarding world shattered told to us six times and making wild guesses threads after threads which is the definition of butthurt. Post proofs to your theories or drop this. Also how hypocritical of you to use a backhanded remark after posting this

Anyways, I'll get back to u.

Has superman ever destroyed a planet in 1,2,3,4 or 5 hits? NO. He has not. You cannot say that a character that has been around for 50 plus years, who has NEVER been shown to punch a planet to destruction, can do it. It has to be done for it to count. That goes for any high strength character.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Wut are u talkin bout? Worlds were shattered end of story. Move on.

Nothing backhanded about what I said. I'm tell u straight up.

Anyways, I'll get back to u.

So you admit that you were bashing me?

Get that interview's link while you're at it.

Originally posted by JBL
Has superman ever destroyed a planet in 1,2,3,4 or 5 hits? NO. He has not. You cannot say that a character that has been around for 50 plus years, who has NEVER been shown to punch a planet to destruction, can do it. It has to be done for it to count. That goes for any high strength character.

This is the fight as seen in IC #5. Throughout the fight, we see them "shattering worlds" and experiencing each other's lives with each blow (as seen in tie-ins like Superman #226, Action Comics#836, Adventures of Superman #649).

Even attacks that include heat vision "shattered worlds" and swapped memories 😕... All the while earth 2 is in flux due to Alexander Luthor's meddling. And still u want everyone to believe it's a standard run o' the mill planet busting feat??? Are u nutz?

In terms of actual physical collateral damage, all u have to look at is Infinite Crisis #5.. They never really destroyed worlds in the literal sense. In reality their fight never really went past a few city blocks.

1 Punch to get to the earth's core and one more punch to explode it.

They didnt destroy world because they were hitting each other

Originally posted by xJLxKing
They didnt destroy world because they were hitting each other

yes, five shots is more than enough.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
This is the fight as seen in IC #5. Throughout the fight, we see them "shattering worlds" and experiencing each other's lives with each blow (as seen in tie-ins like Superman #226, Action Comics#836, Adventures of Superman #649).

Even attacks that include heat vision "shattered worlds" and swapped memories 😕... All the while earth 2 is in flux due to Alexander Luthor's meddling. And still u want everyone to believe it's a standard run o' the mill planet busting feat??? Are u nutz?

In terms of actual physical collateral damage, all u have to look at is Infinite Crisis #5.. They never really destroyed worlds in the literal sense. In reality their fight never really went past a few city blocks.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
F U for showing us saggy old **** WW again

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
This is the fight as seen in IC #5. Throughout the fight, we see them "shattering worlds" and experiencing each other's lives with each blow (as seen in tie-ins like Superman #226, Action Comics#836, Adventures of Superman #649).

Even attacks that include heat vision "shattered worlds" and swapped memories 😕... All the while earth 2 is in flux due to Alexander Luthor's meddling. And still u want everyone to believe it's a standard run o' the mill planet busting feat??? Are u nutz?

In terms of actual physical collateral damage, all u have to look at is Infinite Crisis #5.. They never really destroyed worlds in the literal sense. In reality their fight never really went past a few city blocks.

Its a different fight with totally different writers and circumstances. There was no mention of world shattering or even them sharing the memories like they did in the Joe Kelly fight. Lois Lane of earth-2 was alive when this fight took place in AOS 649, AC 836 and Superman 226.

Yet, superman only reached on Earth-2 AFTER Lois Lane died on Earth-2 and he heard Kal-L screaming in IC 5. The scenarios are different, the time of fighting is different and the outcome is different under a different writer. Its a different fight altogether.

Pretty disingenuous of you as always though.

Originally posted by abhilegend
No it isn't.

Its a different fight with totally different writers and circumstances. There was no mention of world shattering or even them sharing the memories like they did in the Joe Kelly fight. Lois Lane of earth-2 was alive when this fight took place in AOS 649, AC 836 and Superman 226.

Yet, superman only reached on Earth-2 AFTER Lois Lane died on Earth-2 and he heard Kal-L screaming in IC 5. The scenarios are different, the time of fighting is different and the outcome is different under a different writer. Its a different fight altogether.

Pretty disingenuous of you as always though.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
What? Please explain ureself. Are u trying to tell me IC #5 is a totally different fight from AoS #649AC #836, & Superman #226?

But when we see the fight in IC 5, superman didn't even came to Earth-2 untill lois died which directly contradicts AC 836, there was no memory sharing with punches, no "world shattering" punches and most importantly Supermen weren't stopped by Wonder Woman in tie-ins. Its not the first time an Event book has ignored a tie-in. Infinity Gauntlet, Infinity War and Infinity Crusade have many such errors. You remember Maelstrom vs IG Thanos in Quasar and how Starlin ignored in IG, right? Its one of those cases.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Yes. Johns apparently forgot that the fight was already taking place in Superman titles and wrote it as if it started in IC 5. Look at the bottom where it says "To be continued in Infinite Crisis 5"

But when we see the fight in IC 5, superman didn't even came to Earth-2 untill lois died which directly contradicts AC 836, there was no memory sharing with punches, no "world shattering" punches and most importantly Supermen weren't stopped by Wonder Woman in tie-ins. Its not the first time an Event book has ignored a tie-in. Infinity Gauntlet, Infinity War and Infinity Crusade have many such errors. You remember Maelstrom vs IG Thanos in Quasar and how Starlin ignored in IG, right? Its one of those cases.

Fer cryin out loud there is a Trade Paperback titled "Superman: Infinite Crisis" that collects IC #5, Supes #226, AC#836, and AoS #649. It brings to light the happenings of what transpired when they came to blows in the main story which is from IC #5.

Seriously Ahbi... This has got to stop.
Wtf are u talking about?

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
WTF!? Are u purposely being obtuse? It doesn't mean just because it said "to be continued in IC5" that it's a totally different fight.
U are delusional. For example in AoS #649, there's a pause in their fight in which they're minds are back in the empty and uninhabited earth as was clearly depicted in their tussle during IC#5.

Fer cryin out loud there is a Trade Paperback titled "Superman: Infinite Crisis" that collects IC #5, Supes #226, AC#836, and AoS #649. It brings to light the happenings of what transpired when they came to blows in the main story which is from IC #5.

Seriously Ahbi... This has got to stop.
Wtf are u talking about?

Originally posted by JBL
Has superman ever destroyed a planet in 1,2,3,4 or 5 hits? NO. He has not. You cannot say that a character that has been around for 50 plus years, who has NEVER been shown to punch a planet to destruction, can do it. It has to be done for it to count. That goes for any high strength character.

In 50 years I've never seen Superman kill a human. Obviously he can't do it... 🙄

Originally posted by abhilegend
So tell me Celey, how is Lois Lane alive in AC 836 when she already died before Supermen started to fight in IC 5? Now you're telling me that since all these are collected in a TPB, this is one fight? Hahaha, that's one of the most laughable excuses I've ever seen.

Laughable excuse? Wtf?!!? Again u are purposely trying to be obtuse? All this swapping of memories were in chronological order. It was all part of the "This Is Your Life" story arc which ran through a. Superman #26, b. Action Comics #836, and c. Adventures of Superman #649 consecutively. Like I said, it went into detail of what was happening in Infinite Crisis #5 when both Supermen came to blows in the uninhabited Metropolis of earth 2. They even had a collected trade paperback titled "Superman: Infinite Crisis" that collected those 3 books plus Infinite Crisis #5.

Seriously man... Concede the point. U are going down like a house of cards. Save face... Please.

Jake where are you? I think the House of El really does need you now.

Originally posted by abhilegend

The last time I asked rage, he didn't answer where he found the interview. Its getting tiresome when Celey and Carver are shouting "feat debunked" every time without any proof at all.

Ah I see. Well I still think that you make yourself work too hard in these things. But do your thing man...

Mogo wins...never said which planet 😄

Originally posted by dmills
Ah I see. Well I still think that you make yourself work too hard in these things. But do your thing man...