Originally posted by Firefly218
He'll be massively outclassed if he's on a team with Superman, batman and Wonder Woman. Frankly, I can't think of a scenario where the Justice League would actually need Arrow.
Kind of like how Black Widow and Hawkeye were massively outclassed on the Avengers. (Heck even Cap was). Yet Whedon made a way for them all to fit, and make them all useful. A great story teller and Director will do that. In fact they already have that issue with Batman. And Arrow is already outclassed by The Flash, yet they will clearly have team ups. Green Lantern was a regular on Smallville, and that was with one of the most powerful incarnations of Superman.
Also I never said Arrow would have to be part of the JL. He could show up in the Batman solo movies or something. And/or have a cameo in JL.
But The Flash of course needs to be in JL.
Originally posted by Firefly218
The point is, having TV Arrow and Flash in the movies rather than different movie versions will NOT help the movies. The proof is in the numbers. Arrow, relative to other network shows, has a very minor viewership. 3 million would be a good week for Arrow.
That's a pretty simplistic view to take tbh.
If they did join the Universes then it would obviously be hyped and marketed to the extent where most people are aware of that.
Then just the fact that the Flash would now have an origin story would aid their JL movie massively. Because so far the only solo franchise we're getting is Superman, and the only other build up we're getting to JL is BvS. They need a larger build up, and they need people to know that they're not just randomly putting in all the main heroes, but that others have an origin story and development somewhere- In this case that somewhere would be Tv. That alone will aid the JL film and that alone is reason enough to do it. Honestly if they just did the Flash movie instead of the Tv series then we wouldn't even be having this conversation.
As for the 3 million viewers, well the pilot had 4 million, and then there will be Flash's ratings to add to that, and that's excluding downloads. In the days before massive downloads the Sex and the City finale was supposed to be a successful one with 10million viewers. Guess what the Sex and the City movie grossed? Over $400mill WW. The you have to factor that as soon as it's announced that the TV and Movie Universes will be joined, new audiences will go catch up on Arrow and The Flash series and word of mouth and hype will spread. So you honestly can't tell me that including the Flash and/or Arrow in the movie Universe wouldn't make a difference of a good $100mill to the gross earnings.
Originally posted by Firefly218
And although combining TV and cinematic universes would drastically increase Arrow and Flash viewership, I still feel it would do more harm than good. The showrunners for Arrow and Flash would have to explain the events of MoS, and their impact on Oliver and Barry. I mean a ****in alien invasion happened and it was never mentioned in Arrow?
LOL So mention it in the next season. Not really a big issue if they make the decision to join them they could play around with the timeline as much as they wanted. Heck they could even say MOS takes place 5 years after Arrow if they wanted.
Originally posted by Firefly218
Also, Arrow wouldn't be able to have such important, intense story arcs. Next time Merlin is trying to destroy a whole city, viewers will be asking for Superman and batman rather than Arrow.
You mean like how viewers went crazy with intense arch in Cap2 because Thor, Hulk and Hawkeye didn't help out.
Or how everyone went crazy with the intense arch in IM3 because Cap, Thor and Hulk didn't help out.
No one's going to have a seizure over it. And like I already mentioned they can play with the timeline for the Tv series, a luxury the Marvel solo movies and MAOS really don't have.
Originally posted by Firefly218
MAOS suffered from the same thing. The only time MAOS could bring in a legitimate threat was after Captain America 2 had already introduced it and destroyed it.
That's not why MAOS sucked at the beginning. It was because there was a serious lack of creativity and the characters were not likeable. Arrow rocked from the beginning, and it's not like that began with a world ending threat. Besides SHIELD by it's very nature will mostly tackle world ending threats that most the world are not even aware of, kind of like James Bond.
Also now that The Flash is in the same Universe, Arrow already has those issues to deal with, but clearly the writers think they can handle those issues.
And you know for all the "Let's not stifle their Creativity" arguments, there's even more pressure for GREAT episodes, because there's no excuse not to have them. But fact is every show can and will disappoint at some time. Smallville had a horrible finale, without any shared universe issues. But at least being part of the Shared Universe would make it all more exciting, even when creativity is down and episodes are getting weaker.
Originally posted by Firefly218
Besides, having movie versions of Arrow and Flash could help the Tv shows just as much.
True, but not to the same extent. The Flash would benefit more than Arrow. In fact chances are without a shared universe, we won't even see Green Arrow on the big screen.