Originally posted by Zack M
I like pretty much every Snyder movie with the exception of Sucker Punch. But that was strictly a Snyder movie. Watchmen is probably my favorite comic book movie with the most replay value. And he had a good script to work with. MOS was solid and I also loved his Dawn of the Dead remake. Ben Affleck had the right idea to bring in Chris Terrio, because the script so far sounds pretty damn good, so I'm not worried about this.Of course it could still suck. Definitely in the cards, but I would bet otherwise.
I like Snyder as a director. Genuinely. I also liked a lot of Man of Steel.
There are just so many unknowns with this movie, and I think it's gonna be the one movie of the year where I won't know going in to it if I'm going to like it.
Affleck's Batman (and Irons's Alfred) is literally the only thing I look at and think "yeah, that's going to be awesome for sure".
Cavill, as good as he is, needs Superman to be written well.
Eisenberg and Gadot could be really good, or they could be ****ing awful. The uncertainty worries me.
Doomsday shouldn't be here at all unless they have something massive in mind for him later on.
The cameos could also suck, but they're cameos.
Amy Adams needs some serious work if she's gonna be a good Lois Lane.
Like I said, it's the uncertainty. I was pretty sure I was gonna enjoy Deadpool. I know I'll think X-Men is anywhere from "not great" to "okay". I'm sure Captain America will be good. Suicide Squad, unless the Joker is truly awful, looks like fun.
If they get the Superman and Batman dynamic right, then I think the movie will flourish on that alone. I am encouraged that they brought a new writer in, but whether that turns out well, we'll see.
At least this movie hinted that at least some of the characters will have a sense of humour, which is nice.