Magic Vs Science

Started by LeonBuco6663 pages

I wouldnt say they are the same thing boks

Originally posted by The Sorrow
MODERN definition I agree for the most part, but not all magic follows this law which is likely the point of the thread. Also it depends on who's standpoint we are looking at the op from.
i thought the issue was which was better the further up you go. The higher magicals in comic universes tend to have their magics pretty consistent otherwise a skyfather magically scrying some far off event might accidentally "rocks fall everybody dies" the whole thing if their magic decided to turn the viewpoint into a blackhole

It was more "on a whole" as in from street levelers magic to abstract magic and the same with science.

Do what happens to 3D magic in a 5th dimensional world then

Originally posted by LeonBuco666
It was more "on a whole" as in from street levelers magic to abstract magic and the same with science.
lower levels I'd say magic simply because with proper ritual and assuming cooperation I can get a deity to help in my endeavor and for a hell deity the cost is just my soul for a ridiculous amount of immediate gain 90% of the time. So low level comparable tech vs comparable mage, the mage has a pretty big ace if it really comes down to it where the tech hero is limited by resources and intelligence.

At higher levels they become more and more interchangeable but at the same time I don't see Odin and his ilk interacting with abstracts on the level of Reed or Pym as regularly as they seem to.... i.e. Galactus/LT/greater cosmic entities.

Originally posted by maxivitopowe
Do what happens to 3D magic in a 5th dimensional world then

the same chance a single plankton has of doing anything to us.

So not do

It was stated by mxy iirc, that the 3rd dimension, due to him being from the 5th dimension.....he describes it as a piece of paper, he can write, draw erase and do anything to the paper or on it

Originally posted by LeonBuco666
I wouldnt say they are the same thing boks

over simplified on my part. What i mean is in most fiction magic is a science. it's been pointed that way several times through the history of both DC and Marvel.

Originally posted by beatboks
over simplified on my part. What i mean is in most fiction magic is a science. it's been pointed that way several times through the history of both DC and Marvel.
oh I see.