Potter Magic vs. Lotr Magic

Started by Stealth Moose4 pages
Originally posted by quanchi112
And it looks friggin amazing. Keep your envy in your pants.

I actually can make much better sigs, thanks.

Also, my previous statement, which you did not address, possibly due to your reliance on an iFail, still stands; we can't accurately predict LotR magic can even defend against Potter magic, so this thread is bust.

Re: Potter Magic vs. Lotr Magic

Originally posted by quanchi112
Which is more powerful and which would you personally rather wield.

I think LOTR magic in raw form is more powerful, and capable of being wielded without use of wands or magic words.

That said if I were to choose, I'd prefer to have Potter magic because its more versatile. LOTR magic seems more geared towards combat.

Originally posted by FrothByte
I think LOTR magic in raw form is more powerful, and capable of being wielded without use of wands or magic words.

That said if I were to choose, I'd prefer to have Potter magic because its more versatile. LOTR magic seems more geared towards combat.

Agreed. 👆

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
I actually can make much better sigs, thanks.

Also, my previous statement, which you did not address, possibly due to your reliance on an iFail, still stands; we can't accurately predict LotR magic can even defend against Potter magic, so this thread is bust.

My sig is ten times better. Nice try.

Ah I see ifail is more or less how you describe yourself. Now I get it.

This isn't about formidability this is about which is more powerful. How don't you get it ?

Potter magic is clearly more powerful.

Re: Re: Potter Magic vs. Lotr Magic

Originally posted by FrothByte
I think LOTR magic in raw form is more powerful, and capable of being wielded without use of wands or magic words.

That said if I were to choose, I'd prefer to have Potter magic because its more versatile. LOTR magic seems more geared towards combat.

how is it more powerful ? What does a wand have anything to do with power ?

We see Dumbledore use magic minus a wand too.

So how do you expect people to weigh in on threads when you don't agree with them no matter how they present the argument? Like, can we have a quanchi rubric of how to debate with fallacies?

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
So how do you expect people to weigh in on threads when you don't agree with them no matter how they present the argument? Like, can we have a quanchi rubric of how to debate with fallacies?
I gave my opinion and just because two people disagree Thats what makes for interesting debate. I guess you'd rather have everyone high fiving in agreement.

Now what makes you believe Lotr is more powerful ? Explain.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
So how do you expect people to weigh in on threads when you don't agree with them no matter how they present the argument? Like, can we have a quanchi rubric of how to debate with fallacies?

😂

Okay, let me play along.

LotR magic wins because Gandalf is cooler than Dumbledore and Voldemort.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Okay, let me play along.

LotR magic wins because Gandalf is cooler than Dumbledore and Voldemort.

Do you think Gandalf is more powerful than Voldemort ?

😂

It's been decided that Potter magic reigns supreme.

Re: Potter Magic vs. Lotr Magic

Originally posted by quanchi112
Which is more powerful and which would you personally rather wield.

How many times are you going to keep making the same thread, shitlip?

Originally posted by Robtard
How many times are you going to keep making the same thread, shitlip?
Weigh in. Quit running.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Weigh in. Quit running.

Already have in the other same exact threads you made, dummy.

Just like the other two "which magic is better Potter or LoTR" threads you made, the LoTR divine beings shit all over Potter in this one too.

Now proceed to argue like a fanboy that Potter wins cos it happens to be your favorite franchise, shitlip 🙂

Originally posted by Robtard
Already have in the other same exact threads you made, dummy.

Just like the other two "which magic is better Potter or LoTR" threads you made, the LoTR divine beings shit all over Potter in this one too.

Now proceed to argue like a fanboy that Potter wins cos it happens to be your favorite franchise, shitlip 🙂

Based on what in the movies ? Quit just spouting nonsense and actually debate, Palpatine

Originally posted by quanchi112
Do you think Gandalf is more powerful than Voldemort ?

😂

Again, you have Voldemort on that index card you call a signature, so obviously you refuse to accept anything but Voldemort's absolute dominance.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Again, you have Voldemort on that index card you call a signature, so obviously you refuse to accept anything but Voldemort's absolute dominance.
How much I like Voldemort doesn't change what he has done in the films. His power absolutely craps all over the guy who hides from orcs in trees and throws burning pine cones at them.

😆

Originally posted by quanchi112
How much I like Voldemort doesn't change what he has done in the films. His power absolutely craps all over the guy who hides from orcs in trees and throws burning pine cones at them.

😆

Sorry, but Gandalf the White scares off Nazghul and should he ever use his full power (which he is actually forbidden from doing within the story), he could match or defeat Sauron.

So I don't see your point.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Sorry, but Gandalf the White scares off Nazghul and should he ever use his full power (which he is actually forbidden from doing within the story), he could match or defeat Sauron.

So I don't see your point.

Aragorn beat the Nazgul by himself with a torch. You're hilarious. 😂

Gandalf had his staff broken by the Witch king. He also frequently runs from orcs and goblins like a coward.

Gandalf was drummed by Saruman. Sauron would wreck Gandalf. He's pathetic.

Voldemort has far more impressive power than a light which runs off Nazgul when a torch can actually defeat them.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Aragorn beat the Nazgul by himself with a torch. You're hilarious. 😂

The Nazghul were fewer, not on mounts, and ambushed. Gandalf charged all of them while they were flying while he was himself on a horse.

The point stands.

Gandalf had his staff broken by the Witch king. He also frequently runs from orcs and goblins like a coward.

1. The Witch King is in the throes of his full power and is prophesized to be defeated only by a woman, so this is obviously PIS. Again, I pointed out that Gandalf the White, unleashed, would destroy the Witch King in the absence of plot constriction.

2. When does Gandalf the White run from a few orcs? Ever?

Gandalf was drummed by Saruman. Sauron would wreck Gandalf. He's pathetic.

Are you not able to differentiate between Gandalf the Grey, Gandalf the White, and Gandalf the Maiar?

Wait, nevermind. You have a Voldemort signature.

Voldemort has far more impressive power than a light which runs off Nazgul when a torch can actually defeat them.

Yeah, he has that flat nose and his phallic wand. Pretty awesome.