Potter Magic vs. Lotr Magic

Started by ares8344 pages
Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Sorry, but Gandalf the White scares off Nazghul and should he ever use his full power (which he is actually forbidden from doing within the story), he could match or defeat Sauron.

Perhaps a ringless Sauron. Yet, even then, he should struggle but against the full-might of Sauron I don't see how even Gandalf the White fully unleashed could win.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
The Nazghul were fewer, not on mounts, and ambushed. Gandalf charged all of them while they were flying while he was himself on a horse.

The point stands.

1. The Witch King is in the throes of his full power and is prophesized to be defeated only by a woman, so this is obviously PIS. Again, I pointed out that Gandalf the White, unleashed, would destroy the Witch King in the absence of plot constriction.

2. When does Gandalf the White run from a few orcs? Ever?

Are you not able to differentiate between Gandalf the Grey, Gandalf the White, and Gandalf the Maiar?

Wait, nevermind. You have a Voldemort signature.

Yeah, he has that flat nose and his phallic wand. Pretty awesome.

excuses. Gandalf used a white light to run them off. Pathetic. But then again a man using a torch to crush them all together already did that in the first movie.

Speculation. Gandalf was overpowered. Quit hiding from the movie and pretending what you want to have occurred in place of what actually occurred. You're a fanboy who ignores facts.

Gandalf the White is overpowered by someone Aragorn beat singlehandedly by Aragorn. 😂

I unlike you don't worship hyperbole and play make believe. Gandalf is a guy who bonks orcs on the head with a staff. Pathetic.

Voldemort creates fifty foot snakes whereas Gandalfs magic is a bright flashlight or burns pine cones.

😂

Originally posted by quanchi112
You're a fanboy who ignores facts.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
What facts have I ignored ? If you fail to address my post then you concede.

Torch beat a guy who overpowered Gandalf the White.

Voldemorts magical destroying barrier feat crushes any pathetic Gandalf feat.

You are wrong. Don't try to dictate the rules to me.

Gandalf solos.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
You are wrong. Don't try to dictate the rules to me.

Gandalf solos.

This isn't a versus. What has Gandalf done greater than Voldemort destroying the Hogwarts shield.

Gandalf created peace in Middle-Earth, held a Ring of Power, and sported a better beard.

Your argument is invalid.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Gandalf created peace in Middle-Earth, held a Ring of Power, and sported a better beard.

Your argument is invalid.

The ring was destroyed which stopped them so Gandalf only aided along with everyone else.

Gandalf was also bested in a wizard push battle. He also was bested despite a torch being powerful enough to beat the Witch King.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Gandalf created peace in Middle-Earth, held a Ring of Power, and sported a better beard.

Your argument is invalid.

You can't argue with that.

And you need to stop bringing up Gandalf the Grey feats when debating. Gandalf the White is in another league. Maybe stop wanking to Voldemort and rewatch the films.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
You can't argue with that.

And you need to stop bringing up Gandalf the Grey feats when debating. Gandalf the White is in another league. Maybe stop wanking to Voldemort and rewatch the films.

Gandalf the white lacked torch power against the Witch King.

Voldemort's fire snake alone or Avada Kedavra is better than anything Ganualf has ever done.

Sorry, Gandalf the White came back from the dead after defeating a balrog in a melee battle. FYI, a balrog is a Maiar. I'd like to see Voldemort kill one of those.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Sorry, Gandalf the White came back from the dead after defeating a balrog in a melee battle. FYI, a balrog is a Maiar. I'd like to see Voldemort kill one of those.
Hyperbole and when in the movies so they describe what that is.

Gandalf came back after dying through no power of his own. Voldemort created a fail safe in order to do so. Voldemort would easily kill one with an Avada Kedavra. One shot.

He wouldn't die along with it like Gandalf.

😂

Sorry, Khanchi, but Avada Kedavra is blockable and dodgeable. You can block it with inanimate objects of magical origin. The balrog can summon weapons from thin air. Also, it targets the soul; an angelic being such as a balrog could defend against this since it is pretty much supernatural.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Sorry, Khanchi, but Avada Kedavra is blockable and dodgeable. You can block it with inanimate objects of magical origin. The balrog can summon weapons from thin air. Also, it targets the soul; an angelic being such as a balrog could defend against this since it is pretty much supernatural.
The Balrog isn't known for dodging things. Prove he doesn't have a soul.

Prove the Mair thing from the movies. 🙂

Voldemort can apparate and be all over the place and fly while attacking. Gandalf is just some dunce who can't even fly and often runs from attackers.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Based on what in the movies ? Quit just spouting nonsense and actually debate, Palpatine

Just like in those two other same threads you made, your ignorance and outright hatred of LoTR coupled with your man-crush on Voldermort and the Harry Potter franchise being your favorite do not dictate the rules, shitlip.

Originally posted by Robtard
Just like in those two other same threads you made, your ignorance and outright hatred of LoTR coupled with your man-crush on Voldermort and the Harry Potter franchise being your favorite do not dictate the rules, shitlip.
I am not ignorant at all with regards to the hyperbole lets bring some book stuff in here because were upset Voldemort shitstomps the weak mages from the Lotr universe.

Actually debate, Roberto.

There's never debating with, it's people constantly correcting you and you doing flips 🙂

Cry more now 🙂

Originally posted by Robtard
There's never debating with, it's people constantly correcting you and you doing flips 🙂

Cry more now 🙂

Based off what is Lotr more powerful ? Answer a question, sport.

You have this sickness in making the same threads over and over just s you can wank your favorite franchise.

Go make a Harry Potter respect thread and you can go wild in there.

Originally posted by Robtard
You have this sickness in making the same threads over and over just s you can wank your favorite franchise.

Go make a Harry Potter respect thread and you can go wild in there.

See you concede by not debating and avoiding the topic.