Dr. Manhattan vs. THANOS

Started by h1a820 pages

Originally posted by Insane Titan
Thanos has hit intangible beings before the rest of your post is make believe nonsense and still waiting on this proof of a retcon
Prove it. Scans or issue?

It's found in a more recent Eternal series. Volume 4 or 3 I think. I don't know exactly where but if you have the series then you should be able to find it. You would see that I didn't make this up off the top of my head.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85

That means he can't prevent himself from making choices he is already going to make. That means if he sees himself being attacked and avoiding the attack then he will do it.
DM still has choice. Otherwise Ozy wouldn't have turned off his future vision and that would contradict what you are saying.

Originally posted by One-Punch
I don't see Dr. Manhattan beating most elite high heralds, let alone Thanos.
Thanos has no way to physically put DM down.
DM can at the very least teleport Thanos to a black hole. At the most he can teleport his head off.

Originally posted by Bouboumaster
Thanos would beat a bunch of Doctor Manhattan

How would he beat one of them? DM can reform as good as new. DM can become intangible. DM can duplicate himself over and over. DM can teleport Thanos to a black hole or probably his head off.

Originally posted by One-Punch
I don't see Dr. Manhattan beating most elite high heralds, let alone Thanos.
Thanos has no way to physically put DM down.
DM can at the very least teleport Thanos to a black hole. At the most he can teleport his head off.

Originally posted by h1a8
That means he can't prevent himself from making choices he is already going to make. That means if he sees himself being attacked and avoiding the attack then he will do it.
DM still has choice. Otherwise Ozy wouldn't have turned off his future vision and that would contradict what you are saying.

It does not replace the original timeline, where he does not avoid the attack, though.

Originally posted by h1a8
Prove it. Scans or issue?

It's found in a more recent Eternal series. Volume 4 or 3 I think. I don't know exactly where but if you have the series then you should be able to find it. You would see that I didn't make this up off the top of my head.

it happened on Celestial quest series issue 3 or 4.

You still lied as it said it's unpleasant and not drains their power. Plus Thanos is a mutant eternal and I gave you instances that proved you wrong troll

Titan.

thanos already won

Thanos stomps still

Originally posted by h1a8
Prove it. Scans or issue?

It's found in a more recent Eternal series. Volume 4 or 3 I think. I don't know exactly where but if you have the series then you should be able to find it. You would see that I didn't make this up off the top of my head.

Actually, you're lying again...because Thanos' ability to teleport without tech was never retconned.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Actually, you're lying again...because Thanos' ability to teleport without tech was never retconned.

So in your opinion how does DM win this fight?

Originally posted by Supra
So in your opinion how does DM win this fight?

No, DM has no way of beating Thanos and there is zero proof that DM can tank hits on the level Thanos can dish out.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
It does not replace the original timeline, where he does not avoid the attack, though.
I disagree. If he sees he is about to be attacked and can avoid then its all about choice. Otherwise why would ozy block his future seeing? That would contradict the movie and cimmon sense.

Originally posted by Silent Master
No, DM has no way of beating Thanos and there is zero proof that DM can tank hits on the level Thanos can dish out.
DM can reform, duplicate himself, ,etc. DM can teleport Thanos to a black hole

Originally posted by h1a8
DM can reform, duplicate himself, ,etc. DM can teleport Thanos to a black hole

And Thanos can just teleport out, you still haven't named a single valid way for DM to win

Originally posted by h1a8
I disagree. If he sees he is about to be attacked and can avoid then its all about choice. Otherwise why would ozy block his future seeing? That would contradict the movie and cimmon sense.

I do not need your agreement for it to be true. Why bring the movie up? Have you never read the comics?

I'm beginning to think you've never read the comics. I am usually quite patient - but if you are using movie depictions only, f*** off to the movie vs forums. This is the comic book versus forums. You may think it was a clever caveat that you inserted in there, but it wasn't.

I used to think you were actually a pretty good debater. Until I actually interacted with you, and discovered that you don't actually read the comics, you just make your mind up on the basis of your so-called 'common sense'. If anything, you've disappointed me, with the extent of your trolling.

You disagree with my statement that his choices do not affect the timeline where he made a different choice?

Sure, he MIGHT make a different choice (unlikely, as the comic then shows how scared he becomes of tampering with the timeline - he will still be in character, after all), but that would not affect the timeline where he gets punched in the blue dong.

Just answer a simple question for me. Have you actually read the comics?

^Ten-to-one, he'll start using that scan to claim that Dr Manhattan can make pocket universes and warp reality which makes him an Abstract-level character.

Oh DarkSaint, you've dug your own grave by trying to reasonably debate with this guy, instead of just ignoring him. 🙁

Originally posted by h1a8
DM can reform, duplicate himself, ,etc. DM can teleport Thanos to a black hole

Cite instances of him teleporting people into black holes.

Originally posted by h1a8
That means he can't prevent himself from making choices he is already going to make. That means if he sees himself being attacked and avoiding the attack then he will do it.
DM still has choice. Otherwise Ozy wouldn't have turned off his future vision and that would contradict what you are saying.

Self-contradiction ftw. 👆

Originally posted by h1a8
I disagree. If he sees he is about to be attacked and can avoid then its all about choice. Otherwise why would ozy block his future seeing? That would contradict the movie and cimmon sense.
Originally posted by Supra
How does he murder stomp the good Dr. if hes intangible?

I was championing for DM when the thread started and people said I was crazy but screw it ill champ again..

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Lol. Manhattan blew up a couple of human beings and a tank. Clearly, that means he can disintegrate Thanos. 😐

I agree DM cannot be disbursed from this fight but due to titans dense structure, disintegration really has no power play here..