Originally posted by h1a8
They are in the vicinity of each other in strength. Diana is more skilled and will get more hits than Supergirl gets. Plus she has the lasso.
Originally posted by abhilegend
Pure slugfest. No skills, just trading punches untill one of them gets KOED. Preboot versions. Who wins?
sneer Since carter is useless like usual--
Originally posted by carver9
Wonder Woman's stronger.http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/12/121335/2337024-supermanbatman056006_007.jpg
Wonder Woman contains her with one arm.
Originally posted by carver9
Are you talking about this?Also, how many times has Wonder Woman said to be the most powerful female on the planet?
Like I said earlier, Kara had absolutely no confidence whatsoever at that point--
And her powers were still developing. Superman didn't even know she had x-ray vision.
As for a couple examples of lip service, one of which is pretty sketchy at best in context? An actual showing is definitely better than that. Here's her fight with Bizarrogirl.
http://s1199.photobucket.com/user/Delta1938/library/Comparing/Heroes/Supergirl/Bizarrogirl/RoundOne
http://s1199.photobucket.com/user/Delta1938/library/Comparing/Heroes/Supergirl/Bizarrogirl/RoundTwo
Your move, fearful one.
Originally posted by Pillow Biter
There were serious inconsistencies in the depicted and stated power levels of all the Kryptonians, including Supergirl and Power Girl.
There are times when I'd pick Kara and times when I'd pick Wonder Woman.
In direct comparisons, Wonder Woman almost always seems at least equal physically. However, at various times Supergirl has performed feats that Wonder Woman probably could not have equaled, including showings versus the JLA and Superman himself.
It's a mess and you'll get no easy answers here.
What direct comparisons? The only ones I know of for Kara all have context, and the ones I've seen for Power Girl have PeeGee looking better unless you ignore Diana going, "Hey I've gotta actually FIGHT like an Amazon!!" thing.
Originally posted by h1a8
Sorry about that.
😄
Originally posted by h1a8
Well I say split. I strength is a wash (Kara might be stronger) but damage soak goes to WW.
Burden of proof is on you. Examples have been given that are above what's been shown for Wonder Woman, other than some lip service(one of which is iffy) and an out of context scan(that's been repeatedly debunked).
Originally posted by Delta1938I don't have a problem with WW being stronger. Hell, I hope she is.
😄Burden of proof is on you. Examples have been given that are above what's been shown for Wonder Woman, other than some lip service(one of which is iffy) and an out of context scan(that's been repeatedly debunked).
Who do you think is stronger? Or have the greater damage soak?
Originally posted by carver9
Wonder Woman's stronger.http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/12/121335/2337024-supermanbatman056006_007.jpg
Originally posted by carver9
Are you talking about this?Also, how many times has Wonder Woman said to be the most powerful female on the planet?
Since you're making such a big deal about lip service, here. Superman says Kara may be more powerful than him.
Bizarro in his Bizarrospeak says Supergirl is equal to him. I don't think you'll make a compelling case for Wonder Woman>Bizarro in regards to power.
But I'd really rather actually get to something that isn't lip service carty.
Originally posted by carver9
One of my showings is a combat showing.
I know.
Originally posted by carver9
Wonder Woman contains her with one arm.
And it was debunked.
Originally posted by Delta1938
sneer Since carter is useless like usual--Like I said earlier, Kara had absolutely no confidence whatsoever at that point--
And her powers were still developing. Superman didn't even know she had x-ray vision.
In fact your very scan was debunked a couple times before you even posted it!!
Originally posted by Q99
(And if we're talking restraints, WW could one-arm SG before she had training).
Originally posted by abhilegend
That's because Supergirl was afraid of using her powers at that time. Just two issues later Superman and Batman said that she might be stronger than superman himself. Wonder Woman must be stronger than superman too, right?
Originally posted by Q99
There is still the matter of Diana one-arm restraining her, or the other times Wondy's gone head to head with Supergirl.
Originally posted by abhilegend
That was when Kara was afraid of using her powers on anyone. Two issues later she was going to kill Superman with her bare hands after she let go due to black kryptonite. At that time Krypto sent her packing in fear and Artemis knocked her on her ass. That doesn't mean they were as powerful as Kara. Also what time she has gone toe to toe with Kara?
Originally posted by Delta1938
Yes, do leave out that Kara's powers were still developing AND she had no confidence. And what times have they gone head to head?
Originally posted by Delta1938
I know.And it was debunked.
In fact your very scan was debunked a couple times before you even posted it!!
OK, I wasn't talking about that scan even though it isn't debunked. I'm talking about the punch she landed on Batman that was said to be comparable to Superman punch. In the same issue, it was said that Wonder Woman is more dangerous than everyone out there.
Take out the most dangerous one first.
And yes, Supergirl is on the battlefield.
https://arousinggrammardotcom.files.wordpress.com/2014/09/supermanbatmanswitch36.jpg
Wonder Woman stomps.
Originally posted by carver9
OK, I wasn't talking about that scan even though it isn't debunked. I'm talking about the punch she landed on Batman that was said to be comparable to Superman punch. In the same issue, it was said that Wonder Woman is more dangerous than everyone out there.
😆 It has been debunked. Kara had no confidence whatsoever and her powers were still developing.
So an iffy statement because Batman was punched? That's all ya got?
Originally posted by Delta1938
😆 It has been debunked. Kara had no confidence whatsoever and her powers were still developing.So an iffy statement because Batman was punched? That's all ya got?
It wasn't debunked and during that time, Batman commented on Super girl cells absorbing more sunlight than Superman.
I don't need anything else. Proof brother, proof.
Originally posted by CogitoThat's exactly what I said. But delta gave me flack about it. Diana can take more punishment before giving up. Kara may be a little stronger though (not by a lot).
WW would win a straight up fight, but this is a wash.Supergirl may (and I can't emphasize that enough) have a slight edge in strength, but WW should have the endurance and willpower to take a beating longer before going down.
