DP Tyrant vs Arena Monarch

Started by carver95 pages

DP Tyrant vs Arena Monarch

This is Monarch when he took on all of the hero's in the Arena vs Depowered Tyrant.

Who comes out on top?

Monarch

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Monarch
Based on ?

Hm. Arenarch only had one feat that might be perceived as 'poor', and that was when the GL of Earth-32 unlocked all the safeties on his ring--forcing it to go critical mass. When he then unleashed the totality of his ring's power on Arenarch, it opened up the faceplate of his armor, which made him uncontrollably release some of his energy:
http://imgur.com/IRJr5yO
http://imgur.com/MFUD3PZ
http://imgur.com/AAcQKpv
http://imgur.com/JGrvaiV
But as you can see, it was ultimately little more than a page-long inconvenience.

However, I found that showing somewhat inconsistent, given that later in the series, Arenarch willingly opened up his armor's faceplate(for several pages) for the very purpose of releasing controlled energy attacks whilst fighting the alternate Captain Atoms:
http://imgur.com/rTxFvur
http://imgur.com/IdsEniT
http://imgur.com/aYKLtHi
http://imgur.com/6fV2wYu
http://imgur.com/thKsAPO
http://imgur.com/HxwnQJO
http://imgur.com/eNkCz1r

He also removed his entire helmet in a completely unrelated comic without incident(Ion: GotU #10):
http://imgur.com/r1NKliM
http://imgur.com/1IhdxoD

So yeah...

_______

Aside from that, however, he was portrayed as nigh-unbeatable...

Effortlessly slapping away multiple Supermen--including one of the most evolved versions of Supes we've ever seen on panel(ie. Earth-16 Chris Kent):
http://imgur.com/ZEm0YY1

http://imgur.com/7et4b1W
http://imgur.com/dPUFziR
http://imgur.com/Obzt1CC

Swatting away a group consisting of versions of Superman, CA, WW, Flash, etc.:
http://imgur.com/D54wN7n
http://imgur.com/24MAwvn

Stomping multiple Green Lanterns:
http://imgur.com/SvnfHKG
http://imgur.com/ZTNXawy
http://imgur.com/IRJr5yO
http://imgur.com/MFUD3PZ

Stomping multiple Supermen+multiple Wonder Women:
http://imgur.com/wJ140VP
http://imgur.com/RWvkN21

Gesturely releasing continent-busting attacks... Just to press the intimidation factor:
http://imgur.com/atQAMpO
http://imgur.com/ce1EUkX

Owning every version of Captain Atom in the multiverse simultaneously:
http://imgur.com/RY29bZ2
http://imgur.com/dNSJV5w

http://imgur.com/TVxMUMe
http://imgur.com/5LeznLl
http://imgur.com/zzqOZpV
http://imgur.com/rTxFvur
http://imgur.com/IdsEniT
http://imgur.com/aYKLtHi
http://imgur.com/6fV2wYu
http://imgur.com/thKsAPO
http://imgur.com/HxwnQJO
http://imgur.com/eNkCz1r
http://imgur.com/rMev10s
http://imgur.com/bHzL9Jm

And just for a point of reference, the characters Arenarch so effortlessly owned were a collection of "the most powerful heroes and villains from throughout the multiverse.":
http://i.imgur.com/cAnP7Ca.jpg
ie. they weren't intended to be weak fodder(the ease in which Arenarch slew them notwithstanding.) They were intended to be the best of the best.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Based on ?

Comics and common sense.

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
Comics and common sense.
Far less than Tyrant breached Monarch's armor.

Evidence supports me.

🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
Far less than Tyrant breached Monarch's armor.

Evidence supports me.

🙂

I'm not really convinced either way so far, but I do want to point out that evidence involves presenting it, not just appealing to it. So far Galan's the only one that has presented evidence, or even a means of victory based on feats (referring to common feats would count, of course...no need to show every single scan)

Which isn't to say that Monarch wins. Just that you're not doing much that's convincing in rebuttal.

srug

Tyrant.

Originally posted by Digi
I'm not really convinced either way so far, but I do want to point out that evidence involves presenting it, not just appealing to it. So far Galan's the only one that has presented evidence, or even a means of victory based on feats (referring to common feats would count, of course...no need to show every single scan)

Which isn't to say that Monarch wins. Just that you're not doing much that's convincing in rebuttal.

srug

I have posted the scans many times prior but don't have access to them from my iPad. That is why I don't post as many scans as I used to.

I'd definitely battlezone this against Rao if he ever mustered up the courage.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I have posted the scans many times prior but don't have access to them from my iPad. That is why I don't post as many scans as I used to.

I'd definitely battlezone this against Rao if he ever mustered up the courage.

lol, fair enough. Like I said, posting each scan isn't necessary. Text references only would suffice. But to the many who are seeing this particular battle for the first time, "evidence supports me" won't be terribly convincing.

I think this is a close match. Both have multiple feats of wrecking top tier heralds by the handful. Monarch seems to have the more exploitable weakness with his suit, but I also think his collective body of feats is more impressive from a raw power standpoint.

Originally posted by Digi
lol, fair enough. Like I said, posting each scan isn't necessary. Text references only would suffice. But to the many who are seeing this particular battle for the first time, "evidence supports me" won't be terribly convincing.

I think this is a close match. Both have multiple feats of wrecking top tier heralds by the handful. Monarch seems to have the more exploitable weakness with his suit, but I also think his collective body of feats is more impressive from a raw power standpoint.

A green lantern breached his armor which is true. Superboy Prime at his base levels defeated him.

Tyrant took on a well fed Galactus and was winning. I don't see this as even being close.

It strikes me as odd that none of Arenarch's other durability feats are being considered... That only a single 'low' showing is being cherry-picked over everything else. One thing is for sure: the 'critical mass' ring attack must have been insanely powerful, given the plethora of other attacks from very powerful beings Arenarch tanked w/o so much as a scratch to show for it.

It also strikes me as odd that the inconsistency of said 'low' showing is being overlooked. Arenarch purposefully removed his faceplate later on in the story, as well as in an entirely different series. Without incident.

But hey, whatever it takes to give Tyrant the win, I guess. 👆

Originally posted by quanchi112
A weakened Tyrant took on a well fed Galactus and was winning. I don't see this as even being close.

😄

Originally posted by quanchi112
A green lantern breached his armor which is true. Superboy Prime at his base levels defeated him.

Tyrant took on a well fed Galactus and was winning. I don't see this as even being close.

Wasn't that pre-DP? Ah, wait, I remember what you're referring to. Yeah, that's the best point in his favor, no doubt. I'm not sure it makes this definitive, though I agree that no single feat of Monarch's matches it...but that's the type of specific reference that is needed to make the case.

Originally posted by Digi
Wasn't that pre-DP? Ah, wait, I remember what you're referring to. Yeah, that's the best point in his favor, no doubt. I'm not sure it makes this definitive, though I agree that no single feat of Monarch's matches it...but that's the type of specific reference that is needed to make the case.
His powers increased after that not the durability of his suit which was still ripped wide open by prime. Above herald level power breaches it considering herald level power has done so as well.

Originally posted by Digi
Wasn't that pre-DP? Ah, wait, I remember what you're referring to. Yeah, that's the best point in his favor, no doubt. I'm not sure it makes this definitive, though I agree that no single feat of Monarch's matches it...but that's the type of specific reference that is needed to make the case.

Notice Galactus was VERY well FED :

While "DP" Tyrant was WEAKENED :

That's what makes the showing even more impressive despite the sh|t writing.

I've seen the respect thread, but thanks. It just took me a minute to remember the feat. His initial, full-size clash with Big G and subsequent battle with the heralds is much more well-known.

lol did quan just challenge galan to a bz? i find that pretty hilarious for a variety of reasons....

Originally posted by zopzop
😄

That settles it, you're Quanchi level!

Originally posted by leonidas
lol did quan just challenge galan to a bz? i find that pretty hilarious for a variety of reasons....

Nah it was Rao.