Thor vs. Avengers Hulk Rematch

Originally posted by Firefly218
Hulk was temporarily overwhelmed before getting back up, taking out hundreds of more chitauri, destroying the central antagonist and saving Tony Stark's life. I think it's fair to say Hulk won. He dominated the entire battle.

Temporarily? If IM hadn't taken out the mothership, Hulk wouldn't have been able to get out of that predicament on his own. He was bombarded by Chitauri, was unable to extricate himself or fight back, and later on when the chitauri auto-died then we seem him groggy and bleeding.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Still waiting for you to back up your claim.

Is this the Thorgasm speaking? 😆

Originally posted by FrothByte
Temporarily? If IM hadn't taken out the mothership, Hulk wouldn't have been able to get out of that predicament on his own. He was bombarded by Chitauri, was unable to extricate himself or fight back, and later on when the chitauri auto-died then we seem him groggy and bleeding.

No. We see Hulk killing chitauri and beating on loki before the mothership is destroyed and after his "overwhelmed by laser fire" episode. Hulk also saves Iron Man's life after he destroys the mothership. You're remembering the scene wrong.

Hulk got out of his predicament on his own and before the chitauri auto-died

Originally posted by Firefly218
Is this the Thorgasm speaking? 😆

So you concede then? Good.

^ SNL? Really?

And no, I don't concede

Thor Goes down in both matches.

Originally posted by Firefly218
No. We see Hulk killing chitauri and beating on loki before the mothership is destroyed and after his "overwhelmed by laser fire" episode. Hulk also saves Iron Man's life after he destroys the mothership. You're remembering the scene wrong.

Hulk got out of his predicament on his own and before the chitauri auto-died

Just re-watched the scene. Looks like we both remembered wrong. Hulk beats on Loki first before he gets ganged up on by the chitauri. Then just before the mothership explodes (as IM is flying the missile) we see Hulk getting up from a pile of rubble looking dazed and bleeding.

So... looks like the chitauri just left Hulk alone, probably thought he was dead. However, Hulk did not get out of his predicament on his own. The chitauri left him alone. He was unable to beat back the chitauri nor was he able to power-out of his predicament.

Thor never had any such worries, because Thor is superior.

Thor wins.

/thread.

Originally posted by Firefly218
Thor vs. Avengers Hulk

Thor is NOT holding back, and is going full force.
Hulk is extremely pissed off, he thinks Thor killed Betty Ross
Fight takes place in city without civilians

Round 1: Thor gets Mjolnir (cant use lightning)
Round 2: Thor doesn't get Mjolnir

Thor's hammer didn't help him much in the first fight, and the second fight ends worse then the first.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Thor never had any such worries, because Thor is superior.

Thor wins.

/thread.

I agree; even holding back, Thor was able to give an out of control Hulk a good fight.

Originally posted by Silent Master
I agree; even holding back, Thor was able to give an out of control Hulk a good fight.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Based on ?

Evidence provided which you handily ignored.

Originally posted by Silent Master
By all means, prove that the Hulk took out anywhere close to hundreds of aliens after getting back up.

He actually didn't take out any aliens or Loki after getting battered by that laser barrage.

Getting up from that wreckage was the last thing he did before saving IM.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Evidence provided which you handily ignored.

Hulk was definitely getting the better of him. No doubt about it.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Your perspective is rather unique and speculators at best.

Hulk was definitely getting the better of him. No doubt about it.

I've posted tons of evidence to show that Thor was weakened during the events of The Avengers, that he's holding back, and that in a neutral setting he'd make mincemeat out of Hulk. Here, you can do the same for yourself:

Answer yes or no to the following -

[list]
[*] Did Thor use his flying?
[*] Did Thor do any running strikes or flying strikes?
[*] Did Thor use his lightning, either to strike Hulk or to charge his hammer?
[*] Did Thor spin his hammer for momentum in a strike?
[*] Did Thor display any of the offensive abilities he did in both of his movies, up to and including all of the above?
[*] Was Thor explicitly weakened by his unusual descent to Earth, both before the events of the film and later from the carrier?
[*] Did Thor still do better than Hulk anyways when fighting the chitauri, because he was able to start doing stuff above?[/list]

Answer Key:

Spoiler:

1. No
2. No
3. No
4. No
5. No
6. Yes
7. Yes

Stealth, don't let your Thorgasm ruin the keyboard

Your debate method is solid.

"HURR THORGASM" is effective at proving your assertions, in the same way tin foil protects you against the vacuum of space.

Originally posted by quanchi112

Hulk was definitely getting the better of him. No doubt about it.

Why, because he threw him just before the fight got broken up?

Nah, Thor was clearly winning on points, and without even giving putting half his powers into the fight.

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Your debate method is solid.

"HURR THORGASM" is effective at proving your assertions, in the same way tin foil protects you against the vacuum of space.

That comment actually had nothing to do with my assertions.

Mad simile skills btw

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Why, because he threw him just before the fight got broken up?

Nah, Thor was clearly winning on points, and without even giving putting half his powers into the fight.