Saesee Tiin vs. Darth Baras

Idk, the standard ones you see at the battle of Geonosis.

B1 model, 65 kg weight.

Irrelevant, fact is that Tiin threw it farther than Mace did.

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Irrelevant, fact is that Tiin threw it farther than Mace did.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
And Mace threw it more accurately? Were both trying to throw the droid in to somewhere?

Originally posted by Intrepid37
They were just throwing it. Tiin's flew 4 kilometers, Mace's flew 3 kilometers and hit a squad of droids. Tiin says Mace's throw was good but his own was better, then Mace says that his throw was more crucial as it hit the droids whereas Tiin didn't hit anything.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
It seems that Mace deliberately targeted other droids with his throw while Tinn just was being wild.

Uh, yeah really. He was purposefully aiming at them.

It didn't say so last I checked.

Mace still says that precision is more important than power, to counter Tiin's smack talk, heavily implying that Tiin is more powerful.

Precision = Accuracy. Windu was deliberately aiming that them. He's saying that a precise throw was better than just throwing the droid as far as possible. That doesn't mean that Windu couldn't throw it further if he'd actually wanted to.

You have no proof he could have thrown it farther, much less over 1 kilometer.

Also regardless of SWL being your friend or whatever, you have to admit his logic about Tiin not being legitimately powerful is insane.

And you have no proof that he could not. Windu was not trying to throw it as hard as he could, therefore it doesn't work as a comparison.

I do disagree with him. Of course, powerful is a relative word. I don't think Tiin could stand up to Baras for very long at all.

I don't have to prove a negative, bro.

You're trying to use the instance as proof that Tiin is more powerful than Windu. Which btw is ****ing hilarious. You're suggesting that because Tiin threw it further than Windu he's more powerful. As I've pointed out, Windu wasn't trying to throw the droid as far as he could like Tiin was. Therefore the onus is on you to find some other way to prove that Windu wouldn't be able to throw it that far, otherwise your argument is completely worthless.

No, t's on you to prove that Mace could throw it longer than ge did, which means more than one kilometer longer, since Tiin threw it four and Mace threw it a little under three.

I don't need to prove anything. Maybe he could, maybe he couldn't. He didn't even try to. There's no comparison here at all, so there's no point in discussing it.

If you want to try to use the feat to compare to Windu independent of his own throw, suggesting that Windu hasn't ever equalled something like that, that's different. But then I would just ignore the entire thing anyway seeing as its a CWC feat so not really much hope there. And Windu's own CWC feats far eclipse that throw anyway.

CWC is also retarded as it's inconsistent within itself. Mace handles an army of battle droids on Dantooine, but loses to a dozen regular people in the CWC comic.

👆

Seems like some people need to educate themselves on Tiin:
http://www.comicvine.com/profile/silver2467/blog/saesee-tiin-respect-thread/78153/
He takes Baras.

Well none of the image links work, so thats certainly not wowing me. I'm guessing they're all CWC though.

I'm not seeing anything suggesting Baras doesn't rush him into the dirt though.