Vitiate vs Darth Tenebrous

Neph, I remember you liking Carthage...when he was attacking PT characters.

Also, I'll watch the vid you posted on the other thread later.

Again, just because it hasn't been shown doesn't mean it factually can't happen.

Originally posted by carthage
Sure they are if he can't replicate the same feats he's renowned for off nexus. He hasn't and he likely isn't capable of it, as he has no showings that demonstrate the contrary. Try again

Originally posted by carthage
You haven't demonstrated that Vitiate is capable of reacting to someone who has moved faster than Tython. But w/e continue to ignore that

Originally posted by carthage
Again prove it. What off nexus feats does he have to suggest he can? ZERO

Originally posted by SIDIOUS 66
Neph, I remember you liking Carthage...when he was attacking PT characters.

Also, I'll watch the vid you posted on the other thread later.

I can't possibly imagine he was this bad.

Or you could take my word for it. 😛

Again come back when you have something in the way of off nexus feats for Vitiate. This is getting tiresome and I have no doubt the other forumites are tired of the same back and forth. Vitiate simply has no off nexus showings that put on the same tier of Dooku or Tenebrous. Its as simple as that and all of his accolades correspond to showings when he was on a nexus and boosted.

You know I can't read a single thing you're saying right? It's so refreshing.

Not having to humiliate you in another thread is just as refreshing.

Originally posted by carthage
Again come back when you have something in the way of off nexus feats for Vitiate. This is getting tiresome and I have no doubt the other forumites are tired of the same back and forth. Vitiate simply has no off nexus showings that put on the same tier of Dooku or Tenebrous. Its as simple as that and all of his accolades correspond to showings when he was on a nexus and boosted.

Nobody here agrees with you, a lot of us think you are an ignorant dumbass.

And your word is not enough to debunk quotes from canon sources.

You and Neph are the only two who think so. Coincidentally, you're the two with the biggest fanboyish attractions to each of your respective favorite characters. I contribute more threads than either of you for the short duration I've been on this forum. Again, cannon is only as useful as respective showings. Vitiate has nothing that put him on par with Tenebrous, Dooku, or any higher tier Sith lord. Its time people stop listening to stark raving mad fanboy rants and simply analyze feats.

Originally posted by carthage
You and Neph are the only two who think so. Coincidentally, you're the two with the biggest fanboyish attractions to each of your respective favorite characters. I contribute more threads than either of you for the short duration I've been on this forum. Again, cannon is only as useful as respective showings. Vitiate has nothing that put him on par with Tenebrous, Dooku, or any higher tier Sith lord. Its time people stop listening to stark raving mad fanboy rants and simply analyze feats.

Cause I can think of around ten other people who also think you're an ignorant annoying douchebag.

I never said he was weak, I said he wasn't as strong as other Sith lords, he has no showings off nexus that prove he is as good as people think he is, and that he is massively overrated.

He obviously isn't weak based on his nexus showings and grasp of the force. He just doesn't crack the top 20 or even 30 in terms of raw ability.

Originally posted by carthage
He just doesn't crack the top 20 or even 30 in terms of raw ability.

Most of Vitiate's feats are against other powerful Sith on nexus, true....but again they benefit from the Nexus too. If you're somehow implying that it helps Vitiate more than the others, how does that make him less powerful?

Lawl, Tempest is the biggest Vitiate-detractor around and even he say Vitiate is in the top 5.

I have him at 2, behind Sidious (Possibly 3, behind Caedus), and I doubt anyone needs to guess where Legend puts him.

so?

Originally posted by carthage
so?

Originally posted by Emperordmb
You are alone in your beliefs and your placement of Vitiate is ridiculously low.

Public opinion means jack shit when it comes to his feats, sorry. I could care less where his placement is, he lacks feats off a darkside nexus that put him even in the top 10.

I'm glad vitiate is non canon

Well it looks like I was wrong. there is one person who agrees with Carthage's views.

Though having PT be the only guy who agrees with him really doesn't help his credibility very much.