Sinestro vs Magneto

Started by carver95 pages
carver9 Senior Member

Sinestro vs Magneto

Who would win in a straight up fight?

If you was the writer who would you write as the winner and why?

riv6672 Senior Member

Wow, guess you read that post!
😂

I'll probably be in the minority but i'm picking Sinestro.
I think a GL level ring is just more powerful than Magneto. Especially when used by an expert who has very few qualms about extreme messures.

yaadaveyaa Senior Member

Originally posted by riv6672
Wow, guess you read that post!
😂

I'll probably be in the minority but i'm picking Sinestro.
I think a GL level ring is just more powerful than Magneto. Especially when used by an expert who has very few qualms about extreme messures.

i dont disagree it honestly kinda depends on where they fight too, but i dont have enough sinestro feats to know if he can break mags shields or not, and if u give mags a lot of city material to work with then he might get burried in a ton of shit

quanchi112 Disney

Magneto wins.

deathslash Pyromaniacal Humanitarian

Sinestro

abhilegend Prince of All Saiyans
Originally posted by deathslash
Sinestro
carver9 Senior Member
Originally posted by yaadaveyaa
i dont disagree it honestly kinda depends on where they fight too, but i dont have enough sinestro feats to know if he can break mags shields or not, and if u give mags a lot of city material to work with then he might get burried in a ton of shit

The fight takes place in New York city

TheHulk Retired Debater

Damn it.......love both, a little more for Mags.

Sinestro should win barely. but i'll go for Magneto for the upset 🙂

yaadaveyaa Senior Member
Originally posted by carver9
The fight takes place in New York city

well in that case, theres no reason y magneto wouldnt bury sinestro here, hes going to have an unlimited amount of metal to throw at him from every angle and sit behind a shield and a wall of metal like he does, mags wins pretty handily in nyc

Decimus Senior Member

Sinestro hands down

yaadaveyaa Senior Member
Originally posted by Decimus
Sinestro hands down

in a major city with unlimted metal? no chance

TheHulk Retired Debater

Originally posted by yaadaveyaa
well in that case, theres no reason y magneto wouldnt bury sinestro here, hes going to have an unlimited amount of metal to throw at him from every angle and sit behind a shield and a wall of metal like he does, mags wins pretty handily in nyc
Ohh truly, Mags got a better chance if this fight is really in NY.

Decimus Senior Member

Originally posted by yaadaveyaa
in a major city with unlimted metal? no chance

The rings capabilities are beyond Magneto unless a massive downgrade happened to Sinestro that I'm unaware of he is too much for Magnus. Sinestro can control everything around him and his upper limit is just beyond Erik.

"Id" The Man of Tomorrow

Sinestro

Dampyre Senior Member

Sinestro should win but it would be an interesting fight to see.

abhilegend Prince of All Saiyans

Magneto isn't going to go through Sinestro's shields. Sinestro would **** him up at current levels.

Flyattractor Senior Member

Sinestro.

Shabazz916 Senior Member

Mags sinestro ring is metal of some kind... and the contructs aren't magic so they are some kind of energy mags for the win

Golgo13 Senior Member
Originally posted by "Id"
Sinestro
leonidas MWHAHAHAHA!

not sure how much dcnu sinestro differs from his classic counterpart, but i'd say this was pretty damn close most of the time. given the fits dr polaris has given hal in the past, mags would def be a problem for sinestro. i'd take sinestro for a majority, but none of the fights would be easy at all imo....assuming classic versions of the characters of course. sinestro. 6.5/10 maybe.