ROTJ Luke vs ROTS Anakin

Started by Kotor34 pages
Kotor3 Senior Member

ROTJ Luke vs ROTS Anakin

Luke goes back in time to stop Anakin from becoming Vader. Anakin has just turn to the dark side. Battle takes place where Obi fought Anakin.

Who wins?

Impediment Endless

Anakin slaughters Luke.

Kotor3 Senior Member

I forgot to add this to the thread. Leia comes with Luke. Anakins force chokes her. This starts the battle.

quanchi112 Disney

Anakin wins.

StealthRanger S Class Demon

ROTJ Vader>Anakin in terms of raw power and Luke was able to evenly match and overpower him

Anakin prolly has an edge in skill in melee though

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by StealthRanger
ROTJ Vader>Anakin in terms of raw power and Luke was able to evenly match and overpower him

Anakin prolly has an edge in skill in melee though

Based on what ? Quit making things up without proof.

StealthRanger S Class Demon

Go away quanchi

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by StealthRanger
Go away quanchi
Back your claim.

Impediment Endless

Annie rapes.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Impediment
Annie rapes.
👆

StealthRanger S Class Demon

Vader casually flinging large metal objects at Luke in ESB. Contrast to his ROTS self who was above Dooku who needed some effort to bring down large rocks from a ceiling

That and it's rather silly to believe he got weaker between ROTS and ANH

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by StealthRanger
Vader casually flinging large metal objects at Luke in ESB. Contrast to his ROTS self who was above Dooku who needed some effort to bring down large rocks from a ceiling

That and it's rather silly to believe he got weaker between ROTS and ANH

Look at Annie when he got pissed off Padme died. Far more impressive than that weak display.

Anakin rapes.

StealthRanger S Class Demon

Not even relevant to actual combat

You suck at rebuttals and trolling

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by StealthRanger
Not even relevant to actual combat

You suck at rebuttals and trolling

Suit Vader is far slower and if he stands there Anakin would have cleaved him in two. Luke was a loser. He took on a slower, shittier Vader.

We see a noob Luke keep up with him. Awful.

StealthRanger S Class Demon

He was physically stronger and had greater force power than his ROTS self

Vader was holding back against Luke by trying not to kill him. COntext

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by StealthRanger
He was physically stronger and had greater force power than his ROTS self

Vader was holding back against Luke by trying not to kill him. COntext

Less Midichlorians.

Slower and less mobility.

Not to the point you're implying. Movements are far slower than Anakin in ep three.

You're always wrong.

playa1258 Fear is the mind killer

Anakin

StealthRanger S Class Demon
Originally posted by quanchi112
Less Midichlorians.

Only means anything in terms of potential to become powerful

Slower and less mobility.

Does a decent job of keeping up with Obi-Wan

Not to the point you're implying. Movements are far slower than Anakin in ep three.

Based on?

You're always wrong.

Says the guy who thinks Khan or Voldemort>Superman

BruceSkywalker The BatLord of the Jedi

You should have given Luke his NJO feats 😠 😠 😠 😠 😠

Luke dies horribly

DTM Senior Member

Unfortunately the timeframe when ROTJ was made and ROTS was made has alot to do with this fight, as special/fighting effects in film between the decades is a key factor here. Taking that real world issue out of this, personally I feel this is a pretty darn close fight, one in the end I probably would give to Anakin (superior experience and training), but Luke would make him work for it.