Originally posted by red g jacks
to answer DDD... there are a few primary differences between the white immigrants and modern ethnic minorities. back in the day the ethos of the time was to work hard and earn your own. yea there were gangsters and obviously there were gangsters in italy before those people ever got on the boat so they just brought that culture with them. but all in all most people wanted to be a respectable member of society i think. these days kids get blasted with a bunch of degenerate messages basically saying **** society, **** the police, **** the govt, etc. on top of that with black people you're dealing with people we just now made first class citizens after centuries of us living with a very different configuration. so there's a lot of differences really. time, culture, context, etc. you shouldn't necessarily expect a straight comparison just because both situations deal with the same basic in-group/out-group dynamic.
Let's be clear that African Americans were among the hardest working Americans in history. Let's not forget that they were literally worked to death by the thousands for a long period of time in our history. White people do not have a monopoly on hard work and hard working ethics. Granted, edentured servitude is functionally the same as slavery and many of the "white immigrants" were indentured servants for multiple generations, in some circumstances. But I think the African Americans had it worse than the others (besides, probably, Native Americans).
So hard work and working hard is definitely part of African American heritage. It is a fundamental part of their heritage. Many of the immigrants that came to America just a century ago came here under the notion that they could easily make lots of money (not quite the same as a hard working mentality). But, yes, I agree that everyone, especially African Americans, wanted to be respected members of society during the great Italian immigration.
So how did they rise up and overcome their circumstances? They simply kept working hard and took the abuse until they started owning businesses or could extend their influence beyond their little communities. They didn't give up. They didn't make excuses such as, "We don't have educations. We cannot speak proper English. We don't own anything. We don't have food. We don't have a way to get to work." etc. Those were all things that applied to the Italian immigrants, but they didn't make those excuses: they just worked. I posted it before but it took 2 generations (my grandparents) to get them into a respectable SES compared to the rest of America. It wasn't until the 3rd gen that this hard-working mentality helped them rise above the average.
Where was I going with that? Oh, yes: African Americans can improve their situation by improving their situation. Sounds tautological, I know. But only they can improve their situation. It will take, best case scenario, 2 generations before they see parity (I rally do think the Italian American situation was a best case scenario and they benefited from an economic boom right after WWII). As for the gangster culture in African Americans, I just don't buy it. That's not a good excuse.