Originally posted by dadudemon
This is explicitly rejected by older Italian Americans. They were definitely not able to integrate with white America, in the beginning. Even if they tried, they couldn't, because of their physical appearance and names. It wasn't until they raised their SES that they were able to integrate. They first had to raise SES before they were accepted. It didn't work the other way around. The chicken definitely came before the egg.
my grand dad was from italy... he was a white man and considered himself white. what you're talking about is the fact that white people used to discriminate against other white ethnicities.. so the irish, the italians, poles etc might have been marginalized and self segregated in their own ways. but basically within a generation or two a white italian could marry a white irish and have generically white kids (i'm basically describing my grandparents tbh). not really the same as the white on black racism that was a part of the culture not only in this country but going back centuries if not thousands of years. shit even my grandparents were blatantly racist themselves. if you brought a black person around them they were a "mulignan" or whatever. italians are basically just a certain flavor of white people at the end of the day.
while italians and all those other ethnicities might have had it bad in one way or another i think from what i have learned about american history anyway that none of them even come close to comparing to the systematic cultural, political and financial oppression of the black community both in america and other slave colonies (haiti etc).
Right now, in America, I think the best way to succeed is to be born half Native American and half African American. You just have to be an average student and and average employee and you'll see better success than most Americans.maybe on paper... realistically being black has its advantages in certain scenarios and being white has its advantages in other scenarios. i would rather be black when applying for the scholarship but i'd definitely rather be white when dealing with the police in some of the areas i've lived in.The worst case scenario is to be born as a poor white American. The has the steepest "success" slope.
plus you have to keep in mind that being black or native american comes with the statistical likelihood that you'll grow up in worse neighborhoods, go to worse schools and be exposed to worse influences from day one. so you might not be the same level headed you if the cards were shuffled and you were dealt a different hand.