Darth Zannah vs Revan Reborn

Started by ares83418 pages

And I think it massively more likely that he didn't considering he was a selfish power-hungry Sith Lord and that he would then spend hundreds of years in Vitiate's mind.

So Nihilus is hungry, but nothing saying he is massively weakened. Ok.

BTW, I don't think Meetra's comparison is valid as Nihilus is a wound.

There camp is literally about 3 feet from the Temple... and they have tamed Rancors and Scouts patrolling the area right around it.
They would see a ship come from the sky. This is proven because they tell Revan how they see ships of Malak coming up and down.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
There camp is literally about 3 feet from the Temple... and they have tamed Rancors and Scouts patrolling the area right around it.
They would see a ship come from the sky. This is proven because they tell Revan how they see ships of Malak coming up and down.

But its not as if they can see into the ****in' cockpit to see who's in there or see through the walls of the temple. I don't recall them even mentioning the dozens of Sith in the temple either. It seems to me they were totally in the dark about anything and couldn't even access the temple.

No. They specifically discussed how they saw Dark Jedi entering and leaving the temple.
Meanwhile, both tribes specifically discussed how Revan never returned to the world after leaving.
Just concede Neph, I already beat you in this months ago.

Originally posted by ares834
And I think it massively more likely that he didn't considering he was a selfish power-hungry Sith Lord and that he would then spend hundreds of years in Vitiate's mind.

So Nihilus is hungry, but nothing saying he is massively weakened. Ok.

BTW, I don't think Meetra's comparison is valid as Nihilus is a wound.

Theres no reason to be selfish and power hungry when he's ****ing dead. The holocron clearly had a way of choosing who it revealed itself to so theres little chance of anyone finding it while Revan's alive. Why even make a holocron unless you actually want to teach others your knowledge? Also, Revan originated the Rule of Two so he's clearly okay with being succeeded by one stronger than himself. His words don't convey a person who'd hide knowledge out of selfishness. And theres no indication he learned shit from Vitiate's mind.

It says he suffers from hunger. He was very hunger. Whatever.

Cool.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
No. They specifically discussed how they saw Dark Jedi entering and leaving the temple.
Meanwhile, both tribes specifically discussed how Revan never returned to the world after leaving.
Just concede Neph, I already beat you in this months ago.

Just because they never saw him doesn't mean he didn't. As I've pointed out theres a perfectly viable way for him to get their without being seen by the Rakata and no reason for him to leave the temple while visiting.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Just because they never saw him doesn't mean he didn't. As I've pointed out theres a perfectly viable way for him to get their without being seen by the Rakata and no reason for him to leave the temple while visiting.

You do realize you are repeating what you said months ago?

No, cuz I can't remember what I wrote back then.

But why argue that this was the case when there is nothing to insinuate such? Right now all you're bringing to the table is baseless denial against a supported argument.

Originally posted by Nephthys
No, cuz I can't remember what I wrote back then.

Obviously he intends to teach others with it. Whether he is he's to hand out all of his knowledge or not is a more difficult thing to say.

And he claims to know more about Vitiate than anyone else due to being in his mind. So clearly he was learning "shit from Vitiate's mind".

Originally posted by NewGuy01
But why argue that this was the case when there is nothing to insinuate such? Right now all you're bringing to the table is baseless denial against a supported argument.

If this was directed at me, my original point was that since Zannah has Revan's holocron plus at least 2 others and change, her force knowledge is greater than his. Which is the supported argument. Ares is suggesting the possibility that Revan left knowledge out of his holocron with nothing to insinuate it.

If you're backing me up though, thanks. 👆

Originally posted by ares834
Obviously he intends to teach others with it. Whether he is he's to hand out all of his knowledge or not is a more difficult thing to say.

And he claims to know more about Vitiate than anyone else due to being in his mind. So clearly he was learning "shit from Vitiate's mind".

As I said, theres nothing to suggest he wouldn't put it all in there and things indicating he would.

Like how he thinks and shit, nothing indicating he absorbed Vitiate's knowledge. Again, this is baseless speculation.

Originally posted by Nephthys
If this was directed at me, my original point was that since Zannah has Revan's holocron plus at least 2 others and change, her force knowledge is greater than his. Which is the supported argument. Ares is suggesting the possibility that Revan left knowledge out of his holocron with nothing to insinuate it.

If you're backing me up though, thanks. 👆

Awh, well now I wish I was backing you up. 🙁

I wasn't, though. Who has the greater force knowledge is up for debate, but on the point of when Revan's holocron was created, Ant has laid down evidence to support his point and you are attempting to refute it with pretty plain denial without even having a basis for your argument. It really doesn't work.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
but on the point of when Revan's holocron was created, Ant has laid down evidence to support his point and you are attempting to refute it with pretty plain denial without even having a basis for your argument. It really doesn't work.

"I really am the best."
--Darth Nox (Myself)

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Awh, well now I wish I was backing you up. 🙁

I wasn't, though. Who has the greater force knowledge is up for debate, but on the point of when Revan's holocron was created, Ant has laid down evidence to support his point and you are attempting to refute it with pretty plain denial without even having a basis for your argument. It really doesn't work.

All Ant's brought up is that the Rakata never saw Revan against after they opened the temple for him. Which only establishes that Revan wasn't seen by them, not that he never went back there. I'm denying nothing, just pointing out the limitations in Ants evidence.

(also doesn't that imply that they never even saw him leave Lehon, indicating he could go to and from the planet without being seen by them?)

Originally posted by Nephthys
Like how he thinks and shit, nothing indicating he absorbed Vitiate's knowledge. Again, this is baseless speculation.

It is. Just as yours is.

Originally posted by Nephthys
All Ant's brought up is that the Rakata never saw Revan against after they opened the temple for him. Which only establishes that Revan wasn't seen by them, not that he never went back there. I'm denying nothing, just pointing out the limitations in Ants evidence.\

All I brought up? Dude. I used diagrams and scans and mass quotes. I'm rather upset you don't remember, I spent an immense amount of time on it.

Ok, you're making shit up now. My memory isn't that bad.

If not, post a link bro.

Originally posted by ares834
It is. Just as yours is.

What is?

No clue where it is. Our debate has spanned dozens of topics. I remember it is right below our debate on Revan's usage on Force Drain though. Rememberrrr?

You're lying.