Revan and ROTS Anakin vs ROTS Sidious and Dooku

Started by Kotor33 pages
Kotor3 Senior Member

Revan and ROTS Anakin vs ROTS Sidious and Dooku

All out who wins?

Trocity Undefeated and Undisputed

Team 2, Sids is just too much.

Kotor3 Senior Member

I believe Revan would give Sidious a good fight and would last longer than Dooku would against Anakin.

At the same time I could see Anakin losing to Dooku if he doesn't have the same focus as he did when he fought Dooku in ROTS.

I see the fight going either way.

Sinious Yo Da Best

Team 2 solidly.

Originally posted by Kotor3
I believe Revan would give Sidious a good fight and would last longer than Dooku would against Anakin.

Naah

carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

Team 2.

Kotor3 Senior Member

Originally posted by Sinious
Team 2 solidly.

Naah


I'm guessing the fact that Revan was able to go up against an fully empowered emperor vitiate on a dark nexus is not enough for you.

Sinious Yo Da Best
Originally posted by Kotor3
I'm guessing the fact that Revan was able to go up against an fully empowered emperor vitiate on a dark nexus is not enough for you.

Well he was defeated wasn't he? You make it sound like he achieved something against the Sith Emperor. Its a fact that Vitiate is considerably more powerful than Revan where Dooku and Anakin are almost equals. Sidious vs Revan would probably end faster than Dooku vs Anakin.

Kotor3 Senior Member

Originally posted by Sinious
Well he was defeated wasn't he? You make it sound like he achieved something against the Sith Emperor. Its a fact that Vitiate is considerably more powerful than Revan where Dooku and Anakin are almost equals. Sidious vs Revan would probably end faster than Dooku vs Anakin.

I personally feel that a fully empowered Vitiate is above ROTS Sidious and more on the level of ROTJ or DE Sidious. The point is Revan not only got off attacks that sent knock Vitiate down he was able to keep up with his speed and wasn’t obliterated when hit with Vitiate his lighting attack. I believe that speaks much as to how powerful and knowledgeable Revan is in the force.

I do not feel that ROTS Sidious is far above Revan as I view Revan to be above Dooku.

NewGuy01 perpetual

*whistles*

You're really determined.

Sinious Yo Da Best

Originally posted by Kotor3
I personally feel that a fully empowered Vitiate is above ROTS Sidious and more on the level of ROTJ or DE Sidious. The point is Revan not only got off attacks that sent knock Vitiate down he was able to keep up with his speed and wasn’t obliterated when hit with Vitiate his lighting attack. I believe that speaks much as to how powerful and knowledgeable Revan is in the force.

I do not feel that ROTS Sidious is far above Revan as I view Revan to be above Dooku.

Im not arguing with any of this. Still though, Anakin and Dooku are like equals. Even if Sidious isnt A LOT more powerful than Revan, the gap is wider for sure. Also, Sidious' saber skills make him more dangerous than Vitiate in combat. He is more powerful in the force than Revan which means he could easily come close to Revan and turn this into a saber fight and then just strike him down before Anakin gets to kill Dooku. I don't see how team 1 has a chance here.

carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

Sinus speaks sense for once in his life

Sinious Yo Da Best

lol I've never denied Sidious' supremacy in combat though.

Oh and Sinious*

Trocity Undefeated and Undisputed
Originally posted by Sinious
, Sidious' saber skills make him more dangerous than Vitiate in combat. He is more powerful in the force than Revan which means he could easily come close to Revan and turn this into a saber fight and then just strike him down before Anakin gets to kill Dooku. I don't see how team 1 has a chance here.

👆

Kotor3 Senior Member

Originally posted by Sinious
Im not arguing with any of this. Still though, Anakin and Dooku are like equals. Even if Sidious isnt A LOT more powerful than Revan, the gap is wider for sure. Also, Sidious' saber skills make him more dangerous than Vitiate in combat. He is more powerful in the force than Revan which means he could easily come close to Revan and turn this into a saber fight and then just strike him down before Anakin gets to kill Dooku. I don't see how team 1 has a chance here.

I understand your point and it is definitely valid. It could definitely go that way. The only counter I have is that Revan has shown the ability to combat and defeat an individual (SF Malak) who was stated to have superior saber skills and was more powerful (than Revan) while amped by the Star Forge.

While your points concerning Sidious are valid based upon Revan’s battle on the SF I could see the battle lasting for a while and perhaps longer than Anakin and Dooku as Anakin has shown in the right state of mind he can quickly take out Dooku.

FreshestSlice Eternal Commander

Malak was not more powerful than Revan, even when amped by the Star Forge. I'm not sure where you got that from.

Sinious Yo Da Best

Yeah he really wasn't and he was no where near Sidious' level.

Also, Anakin may have defeated Dooku like that but Dooku right before losing to Anakin dominated a fight against Anakin and his master. If Anakin had faced Dooku alone, he might have died instead of Dooku.

AncientPower The Chosen One

Sidious potentially solos but with Dooku this is a solid 9/10 win.

FreshestSlice Eternal Commander

Originally posted by Sinious

Also, Anakin may have defeated Dooku like that but Dooku right before losing to Anakin dominated a fight against Anakin and his master. If Anakin had faced Dooku alone, he might have died instead of Dooku.


Dooku wasn't dominating in that fight. The only time he had the edge is when he talked about Shmi, and that only lasted a few seconds at best.

Sinious Yo Da Best

I meant that he was able disable Anakin completely with a kick and then TK Obi-wan.

Kotor3 Senior Member

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
Malak was not more powerful than Revan, even when amped by the Star Forge. I'm not sure where you got that from.

There is no quote that I know of that states this specifically. Even though Revan may have had a stronger connection to the force (as stated by Malak), having fought through the SF as a Jedi (which would attribute no amplifying effects) without a fully restored memory, it is my assumption that Malak (who professed to have grown in power or surpassed Darth Revan) with the amplifying effects of the SF would be stronger than Revan at the time of their encounter.