Godzilla vs Sinestro

Originally posted by tkitna
Looking at those scans, its hard for me to understand how somebody perceives he wasn't KO'd or scratched. He's laying motionless in the one panel. The next has him maybe starting to move. Also his costume looks like swiss cheese. I'm sure he had a scratch or two on him.

Regardless, it doesn't mean anything to me. I think we all realize Sinestro beats the lizard.

And I didn't mean "not a scratch" literally. Duh.

Your right. I guess he was just in the fetus position. My fault for not reading the caption box. I thought it was continuation of Hal.

Originally posted by tkitna
Your right. I guess he was just in the fetus position. My fault for not reading the caption box. I thought it was continuation of Hal.

Godzilla, like Chuck Norris, doesnt cry.

Seriously though, high and low end showings aside, i see nothing here to change MY mind. I actually saw a few facts to reenforce my opinion on a Godzilla win.

Originally posted by riv6672
Godzilla, like Chuck Norris, doesnt cry.

Seriously though, high and low end showings aside, i see nothing here to change MY mind. I actually saw a few facts to reenforce my opinion on a Godzilla win.

Sinestro tanked a planetary destruction and you still say Godzilla wins? Why? How?

Godzilla's not a planetary destruction.

I'm not going to be more long winded than that, because you arent going to change your opinion, and i dont really mind that.

Originally posted by riv6672
Godzilla's not a planetary destruction.

I'm not going to be more long winded than that, because you arent going to change your opinion, and i dont really mind that.

I could change my opinion if you brought any compelling argument to it. These debates aren't so you can come and say "I think this and nothing will change my mind" you know? I happen to be a Godzilla fan and if Goji can actually win this I'd like to know it.

Maybe you will change your mind if I brought more info about Sinestro? What about that?

Actually MOST of these debates are "i think this and nothing will change my mind". Which is okay.

The evidence is already in this thread, and the Godzilla/Hulk thread, enough to suit me, anyway. my You dont have to provide anything on my account, though.

Originally posted by riv6672
Actually MOST of these debates are "i think this and nothing will change my mind". Which is okay.

The evidence is already in this thread, and the Godzilla/Hulk thread, enough to suit me, anyway. my You dont have to provide anything on my account, though.

Anyways, I'm ok with you not wanting to discuss or anything, you can do what you want with your spare time.

People should come and explain their positions to add and make it a worthy discussion, since that's not happening no point in dwelling on it further 👆

👆

again, many of the stated feats are being misinterpreted. his healing in particular is really being misrepresented--especially given sinestro's power set. it would be simple for sinestro to scan godzilla and destroy his second brain. that would easily take zilla out. gl's can fly through STARS. it would also be simple to redirect his breath weapon via constructs in most cases.

logically and by feats, there really is no way godzilla wins this match.

Originally posted by Bentley
Anyways, I'm ok with you not wanting to discuss or anything, you can do what you want with your spare time.

People should come and explain their positions to add and make it a worthy discussion, since that's not happening no point in dwelling on it further 👆

Originally posted by leonidas
👆

again, many of the stated feats are being misinterpreted. his healing in particular is really being misrepresented--especially given sinestro's power set. it would be simple for sinestro to scan godzilla and destroy his second brain. that would easily take zilla out. gl's can fly through STARS. it would also be simple to redirect his breath weapon via constructs in most cases.

logically and by feats, there really is no way godzilla wins this match.

Originally posted by leonidas
👆

again, many of the stated feats are being misinterpreted. his healing in particular is really being misrepresented--especially given sinestro's power set. it would be simple for sinestro to scan godzilla and destroy his second brain. that would easily take zilla out. gl's can fly through STARS. it would also be simple to redirect his breath weapon via constructs in most cases.

logically and by feats, there really is no way godzilla wins this match.

Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya
QFT

Like i said, "i think this and nothing will change my mind".

Originally posted by riv6672
Well, there's nothing i, personally, can add to this thread other than to point out the obvious, like, Godzilla is not an explosion, or a star; he's going to be fighting back.
Thats not likely to change your mind, so why waste time and fill up the thread with back and forth between us?

Well, I wouldn't care that much about how long the discussion is, these forums are to argue and debate, if we are civil and fair with all the posters that participate on the discussion, I'm pretty sure we're encouraged to exchange points of view.

The example of the planetary explosion is compelling because it features a damage output exponentially above what Godzilla has mustered, and this was actually resisted by Sinestro without any difficulty. It's easy to make analogies about it, which are pretty convincing. Imagine that I built a robot that could take a bullet shot. And then we send a chihuahua against that same robot, and the machine will be actively defending against the chihuahua. Would it be fair to assume that the chihuahua's teeth will go to the solid casing that can stand a bullet? Most people would dismiss it quickly. Is it different to talk about the fight between to mobile beings and a single attack? Yes, of course, but it doesn't always matter.

On the flip side, super powered characters are known to survive ridiculously powerful explosive events, yet get knocked around by physical forces like punches to the face and power beams.

Originally posted by riv6672
On the flip side, super powered characters are known to survive ridiculously powerful explosive events, yet get knocked around by physical forces like punches to the face and power beams.

Yes, this is why the forum features rules that try to minimize those inconsistensies when they can be explained/justified by plot (PIS) or character errors (CIS). This is also why we rate each battle from a value out of ten, allowing for certain diversity in internal showings.

There are rules such as "characters fight to the best of their abilities", that are made in the spirit of people agreeing more or less in a standard level on characters and not being up to an absolute freedom of interpretation on showings. Opinion is fine, but when you can pick who is weak beacuse you consider their lowshowings, it can easily become a game of playing favorites, which is horrific in the long run for the health of any discussion.

Unrelated to all that, there is also the fact that Sinestro has many other showings that put him on a planetary level of power which might not feature explosions.

Originally posted by leonidas
👆

again, many of the stated feats are being misinterpreted. his healing in particular is really being misrepresented--especially given sinestro's power set. it would be simple for sinestro to scan godzilla and destroy his second brain. that would easily take zilla out. gl's can fly through STARS. it would also be simple to redirect his breath weapon via constructs in most cases.

logically and by feats, there really is no way godzilla wins this match.

The second Brain instance your referring to is only one version out of 10+ versions of GZ. the Heisei version. So stating the second brain versions is un accurate too as all the other versions had only one. Showa GZ specifically stated as having a small single brain in GZ vs King Kong.

Just wanted to point that out. 🙂

Originally posted by Bentley
Mechagodzillas and MegaKing Ghidorah are alien tech though, no telling in how strong they are when compared with conventional machines.

Godzilla can hurt Sinestro, to say otherwise is insane & lol at downplaying the Gverse tech.

That said Big G can't pull wins here unless Sinestro fights very dumb.

Godzilla is awesome and powerful enough to hurt Sinestro, though not with Parallax at his command. I think the Sinestro Corps gets a new Member ^^.