Captain America vs Batman

Ive been debating this one with a friend for the evening, I say Batman would win. And before all you Cap fanboys jump on here, representing your cap denominator let me just point out; Bats vs Cap can really be distilled down to three categories: Physicality, Fighting Skill, Gadgets; Cap wins Physicality for sure, he can bench 1200, Bats can press 1000; Cap is faster and more durable BUT Batman has more fighting skill; Cap knows about 12 martial arts while Batman has mastered 127, meaning that anything Cap can throw at Batman h2h will be countered. gadgets is also a no brainer for Batman because while Caps shield is very durable and quite versatile he doesnt have explosives, gas attack, projectiles, tazers etc like Batman does, more versatility in weaponry equals Batman finding a way around the shields defence. 2 out of 3 categories go to Batman. Its a helluva fight but Batman wins 6/10

I would go for comics Batman over Captain America.

But this is the Movie Versus. Every film version of Batman would lose.

Originally posted by Placidity
Every film version of Batman would lose.

Until the Batman v Superman movie get released and what it has to offer for Bat's

for now Capt wins.

BUT BATS WILL HAVE HIS REVENGE!

Cap would kick Batmans ass. All film versions.

Animated Conroy Batman? I don't know. That's a tough call.

Caps beats Baleman 10/10

another bait thread, won;t play into assholishniss...

anyway animated batman stomps , but movie batman loses

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
another bait thread, won;t play into assholishniss...

anyway animated batman stomps , but movie batman loses

batman is no way shape or form beats cap... standard equipment cap rapes batman with the shield...

without weapons cap breaks batman's back... batman is human is isn't taking high level punishment like cap can period

Originally posted by Silent Master
Caps beats Baleman 10/10

You don't say, more like 1/10.

Cap beats him once, then Bat preps and beats Cap the other 9 times 😆 😆

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
You don't say, more like 1/10.

Cap beats him once, then Bat preps and beats Cap the other 9 times 😆 😆

why is prep needed between two mortal's with no powers...

Because... he's Batman...that's how he rolls.

Per the OP, there is no prep in this fight.....thus Cap beats Baleman 10/10.

Movie Batman didn't show much if at all prep skills. The movies were too focused on action to showcase any of the dedication and time it takes for prep.

So even if he did have time...would it really matter?

Originally posted by KingD19
Movie Batman didn't show much if at all prep skills. The movies were too focused on action to showcase any of the dedication and time it takes for prep.

So even if he did have time...would it really matter?

Hell ya it would, plus look at all his gear and weapons.

His gear and weapons would help, well that depends on what he's allowed(but Cap did take down a Quinjet with just his shield). But as I said, he's shown pretty much no prep skills unless I'm missing something. For instance, comic Batman would have saved Rachel and Harvey.

Originally posted by Placidity
Every film version of Batman would lose.

Originally posted by Impediment
Cap would kick Batmans ass. All film versions.

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
movie batman loses

While it almost goes with out saying that Captain America of the MCU would crush Nolan Batman.

Burton/Schumacher, Anthology Batman if you will. Stands a fair chance against him.

Not saying said version of Batman could beat MCU Cap per se. Just that it would be a good fight.

It would so not be a good fight. Cap would dominate Bat in every way.

Originally posted by RJ 2.0
It would so not be a good fight. Cap would dominate Bat in every way.

How is that? From what I recall they have similar enough feats, that their is no reason to assume it would not be a good fight.

In case their is something I have forgotten. Please feel free to present a case for Cap dominating Bats.

Originally posted by Riot-Gear
How is that? From what I recall they have similar enough feats, that their is no reason to assume it would not be a good fight.

In case their is something I have forgotten. Please feel free to present a case for Cap dominating Bats.

Animated Batman is a different story though.