Originally posted by Dramatic Gecko
From what I understand its near TP or above its level but doesn't compete with Ocarina and Majora.
Most negative opinions I've seen are from people who dislike the cell-shaded graphics and still have a grudge against WW. Check their respective Famitsu scores, there are some reviewers that didn't jump on the "best Zelda ever" wagon from the get to go.
I just think sailing in the gigantic sea of WW spells epic adventure in a way very few games have achieved.