Second Place Sith Lord Battle #3: Darth Caedus vs Vitiate

Started by Nephthys8 pages

I put Caedus and Revan on the same tier btw. So I imagine a similar fight occurring.

So your ranking is: Sidious>Bane>Youda>Zannah>Hero>Caedus>Revan>Anakin?

Revan became a lethal threat to him at some point of the fight and the reasons for that are pretty obvious.

I wonder how Caedus would fare against Vitiate's mental attacks. Not well I think.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
So your ranking is: Sidious>Bane>Youda>Zannah>Hero>Caedus>Revan>Anakin?

I don't put Sidious above Bane. 🙂

Originally posted by Nephthys
I don't put Sidious above Bane. 🙂

Really?

Really.

I believe he has them as equals.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I wonder how Caedus would fare against Vitiate's mental attacks. Not well I think.

If the HoT is powerful enough, Caedus definitely is.


I don't put Sidious above Bane. 🙂

First, ew. Second, so you're saying Bane's entire point in existing was to fail?

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
If the HoT is powerful enough, Caedus definitely is.

Oh sorry I didnt realize this was weakened Vitiate.

First, ew. Second, so you're saying Bane's entire point in existing was to fail?

👆

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I believe he has them as equals.

I need a bigger facepalm Smiley.

I've lost so much respect for you, Nephthys.

Dang.

Prep doesn't mean shit.

Caedus.

Originally posted by Sinious
Oh sorry I didnt realize this was weakened Vitiate.

👆

To my knowledge, Vitiate wasn't weakened during that fight. He was both amped by two Nexii and weakened due to his failed ritual attempts.

For the thread, since I'm not knowledgeable enough on Caedus, I'll see what the community decides on that. Entertain me. 😄

He was most definitely weakened. That was kinda the whole point. Beyond that, the next expansion makes it clear that nobody during the TOR era can defeat a full powered Vitiate.

Originally posted by Nargaroth
To my knowledge, Vitiate wasn't weakened during that fight. He was both amped by two Nexii and weakened due to his failed ritual attempts.

For the thread, since I'm not knowledgeable enough on Caedus, I'll see what the community decides on that. Entertain me. 😄

That nexus argument won't do you any good buddy. He was never stated to be amped where he was stated to be weakened multiple times in SWTOR. The entire point of that confrontation was to catch Vitiate while he was weakened.

Originally posted by Sinious
That nexus argument won't do you any good buddy. He was never stated to be amped where he was stated to be weakened multiple times in SWTOR. The entire point of that confrontation was to catch Vitiate while he was weakened.

I never claimed he wasn't weakened at all. I said that, again to my memory, he wasn't weakened during the fight itself due to Nexus amp. That's different.

Originally posted by Sinious
Oh sorry I didnt realize this was weakened Vitiate.

Vitiate doesn't mention him being weakened when he brought up his mind domination. I'm speaking solely on that.

Originally posted by Sinious
That nexus argument won't do you any good buddy. He was never stated to be amped where he was stated to be weakened multiple times in SWTOR. The entire point of that confrontation was to catch Vitiate while he was weakened.

Yep. The argument was stupid before and now, with the next expansion coming out, shown to be flat out wrong.

Originally posted by Nargaroth
I never claimed he wasn't weakened at all. I said that, again to my memory, he wasn't weakened during the fight itself due to Nexus amp. That's different.

and you have quote for this?

Vitiate almost never left Dromund Kaas so underrating his feats due to the nexus of that planet doesn't really make sense especially when the author never said anything about him being amped.

And he was weakened cause he tried to pull off possibly the hardest ritual ever and failed. Scourge's entire plan was built on this idea and nothing hints that he reached his full power back before the fight.

Originally posted by ares834
Yep. The argument was stupid before and now, with the next expansion coming out, shown to be flat out wrong.

👆

Originally posted by Sinious
and you have quote for this?

Vitiate almost never left Dromund Kaas so underrating his feats due to the nexus of that planet doesn't really make sense especially when the author never said anything about him being amped.

And he was weakened cause he tried to pull off possibly the hardest ritual ever and failed. Scourge's entire plan was built on this idea and nothing hints that he reached his full power back before the fight.

👆

My point was that his feats in that instance were neutral actually, because he was both amped, which is self-evident, and you not liking it I'm afraid doesn't change that fact, and weakened, which I never denied, so no, I wasn't lowballing him (at least not for how he performed during that fight).

I agree, however, that he didn't prepare for that fight, and I actually think that he lost because he underestimated Hot. After all, I don't think he'd take that much seriously an opponent he had already defeated when supported by other Jedi.