Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
I actually meant for Dooku to have Ventress on his team as well but still sabers only. Who wins.
I was going to say Maul+Kenobi stomp. But Ventress evens the odds.
I think Dooku's solidly above Maul and Kenobi individually but Maul and Kenobi are solidly above Ventress individually as well.
So dunno. Leaning towards Dooku and Ventress since Dooku is the best swordsman here.
Good match up.
Originally posted by DARTH POWER
I was going to say Maul+Kenobi stomp. But Ventress evens the odds.I think Dooku's solidly above Maul and Kenobi individually but Maul and Kenobi are solidly above Ventress individually as well.
So dunno. Leaning towards Dooku and Ventress since Dooku is the best swordsman here.
Good match up.
I agree with this. If we add Ventress in, then Team 2 would have a better chance. Dooku can beat either of them on his own, so all Ventress has to do is defend herself until Dooku finishes up with whoever he fights.
Originally posted by ILS
Dooku is a tier 9 duelist. Maul, Kenobi and Ventress are all tier 8s. Maul and Kenobi would most certainly take Dooku in a 2v1 and you'd be kidding yourself to think otherwise.
Dooku might be able to dispatch Kenobi in the early stage of duel. If he will do that before he will becaome tired, then he should be able to defeat Maul in one vs one battle.
Originally posted by Marco1907
So Emokin is tier 9 but even TCW Maul is not 9 ? .... That defies the logic.TCW Maul is certainly tier 9. I am sure Nick Gillard would agree with this especially after the Maul vs. Sidious duel. Or when the time Maul stomped Savage.
^ lol
Originally posted by ILS
Dooku is a tier 9 duelist. Maul, Kenobi and Ventress are all tier 8s. Maul and Kenobi would most certainly take Dooku in a 2v1 and you'd be kidding yourself to think otherwise.
Where are you pulling these numbers from?
Originally posted by Marco1907
Not to mention tier 9 Emokin let Dooku to ragdoll Obi-Wan while they were fighting 2 v 1....Does it make sense? ? Hell no. Emokin was tier 8 just like Obi-Wan.
Both Anakin and Obi-Wan started their duel with Dooku as level 8 duelists. During the fight, after Dooku's taunts, he became level 9 duelist. It continues, I believie, to his raid on the Temple. As a level 9 he killed Drallig with total ease. After that, he became conflicted a bit, and "Padme's and Kenobi's betrayal" finally mind****ed him. He wasn't ready mentally to face Kenobi.
Anyway, after season 6 of TCW and SoD, I'm not sure if this Gillard's quote is still a reliable source.
Originally posted by McP
Both Anakin and Obi-Wan started their duel with Dooku as level 8 duelists. During the fight, after Dooku's taunts, he became level 9 duelist. It continues, I believie, to his raid on the Temple. As a level 9 he killed Drallig with total ease. After that, he became conflicted a bit, and "Padme's and Kenobi's betrayal" finally mind****ed him. He wasn't ready mentally to face Kenobi.
Yeah I agree with this. He was not ready for being level 9. Drallig doesn't have any dueling feats though, army of 501 did the job at the temple. And what do you think about TCW Maul ? He should be level 9 after his power up in TCW.
I think that Maul was still level 8 duelist. I believe him to be Kenobi's equal in sabers, and superior with the Force.
I just doubt, that Dooku and Windu are level 9 at this moment. Especially after SoD - Windu couldn't defeat Talzin (or even forced her onto defensive), and Sidious has beaten her while she was controling Dooku's body. She had full control over his body, her skills and was quite safe, since I doubt that Sidious wanted to kill Dooku. And Sidious disarmed her with total ease.
More then that, Maul did very well against Windu and Secura.
And excluding his duel with Sidious and some hype, Mace has nothing that would place him in Yoda's and Sidious' league.
As a duelist he couldn't even find any advantage over Bulq. Still, he was second only to Yoda in the Order, but I doubt, that he was in the same league.