Best Debater by Era [Friendly Competition]

Started by Nephthys12 pages
Originally posted by FreshestSlice
Actually you don't have to defend yourself. If you can "smack ass" around then you shouldn't care.

But I do care! I want Ant and Sel to like and respect me!

Also I wonder if peeps can still say Carthage is better than me while he's arguing that Saesee Tiin > Darth Krayt, Maul and Malgus. 😆

ME? 😄

Originally posted by Nephthys
But I do care! I want Ant and Sel to like and respect me!

It's not a joke when it's true, man.

Also I wonder if peeps can still say Carthage is better than me while he's arguing that Saesee Tiin > Darth Krayt, Maul and Malgus. 😆

He doesn't have to be right to be a better debater.

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
It's not a joke when it's true, man.

He doesn't have to be right to be a better debater.

Joke?

He does have to be sane.....r than me, though.

Tiin really is better than all Sith, he has that accolade and can lift droids.

Originally posted by carthage
I'm not certain how you'd have to be an expert "In Darth Bane's era", so DMB shouldn't be up there. If you have the patience to sit through 3 terrible books about a mediocre character/terrible duelist then you can be an expert on Darth Bane, being called a Darth Bane expert is like receiving an Underground Basket weaving degree from a diploma mill.

Wow, cool off for a day man seriously.

Originally posted by Nephthys
*snip*

😍
I love that I can get to you so easily, you really do crave affection don't you?
You actually managed to fill this post with more double standards than your usual debates so that's actually an accomplishment in itself. Just a few
Notes though, off the top of my head.

- I never ended up trying in that debate, I said I wish I had. I spent too much time working on PM's for fated. Not to mention your part of the poll grew by 7 votes in 5 minutes, you Had the backing of socks ggwp?
- And indeed? I don't take my opinion as established canon. You do. Or are you forgetting your own argument about that opinion? [There's no hint in the passage so it has to merit at all, deal with it the Revan novel retconned her power] despite conclusive proof that the effect happened to every Jedi on the planet, and word from the author.
- Honestly everyone says Ant lost to piss him off, not sure anyone actually believes it.
- "Hi-Larious coming from you" haha what? I don't try and put my favorite Jedi as Yoda tier, I never put Traya far above people like Dooku because I know her place. HOT bro. HOT.
- You mad btw. Taking this real personal
- I honestly couldn't care less where you rank me, I never debate seriously here anyway.
- Taking Legend's opinions as a way to back up your own is literally like jumping off the sanity cliff.

I won't reply to whatever you send back to this, I just saw other people say "You mad" or laugh at it and wanted to explain why 😍

Originally posted by Aurbere
The title says 'friendly competition' but the thread has rapidly devolved into a pointless dong measuring contest.

Friendly banter, Not the first time I've told him I respect Carthage more than him, he just gets a bit Irate... He still loves me.

Originally posted by Selenial
Friendly banter, Not the first time I've told him I respect Carthage more than him, he just gets a bit Irate... He still loves me.

I'm not sure I would consider any of that 'friendly'. I don't have many friends though.

Originally posted by Sinious
Wow, cool off for a day man seriously.

I was talking about Karpashyn bro. Do you like his books?

Originally posted by Selenial
Friendly banter

I lol'd.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
I lol'd.

😄

Regardless of what anyone thinks, Zannahs votes got bumped up by my friend Intrepid and all that was on top of the fact Zannah/DMB ignored proof Vorpal and Ancientpower brought that Zannahs illusions wouldt work. No one ever bothered to tackle the fact Zannah is hilariously out of her league in a duel though.

Originally posted by Selenial
😄

Deep down, you know that designating any of this as, "friendly banter," is a gross manipulation.

Originally posted by Aurbere
I'm not sure I would consider any of that 'friendly'. I don't have many friends though.

Retardation is a desirable trait in a friend, considering I've seen that one thrown around a lot. That and spreading Ebola. If anything, we aren't being nice enough.

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Deep down, you know that designating any of this as, "friendly banter," is a gross manipulation.

Of course it is.... 😕

Originally posted by Selenial
😍
I love that I can get to you so easily, you really do crave affection don't you?
You actually managed to fill this post with more double standards than your usual debates so that's actually an accomplishment in itself. Just a few
Notes though, off the top of my head.

- I never ended up trying in that debate, I said I wish I had. I spent too much time working on PM's for fated. Not to mention your part of the poll grew by 7 votes in 5 minutes, you Had the backing of socks ggwp?
- And indeed? I don't take my opinion as established canon. You do. Or are you forgetting your own argument about that opinion? [There's no hint in the passage so it has to merit at all, deal with it the Revan novel retconned her power] despite conclusive proof that the effect happened to every Jedi on the planet, and word from the author.
- Honestly everyone says Ant lost to piss him off, not sure anyone actually believes it.
- "Hi-Larious coming from you" haha what? I don't try and put my favorite Jedi as Yoda tier, I never put Traya far above people like Dooku because I know her place. HOT bro. HOT.
- You mad btw. Taking this real personal
- I honestly couldn't care less where you rank me, I never debate seriously here anyway.
- Taking Legend's opinions as a way to back up your own is literally like jumping off the sanity cliff.

I won't reply to whatever you send back to this, I just saw other people say "You mad" or laugh at it and wanted to explain why 😍

If by getting to me you mean that you said something about me that I thought was unfair, so I defended myself, you replied and then I replied back, baby you just broke my achy breaky heart.

- Socks were messing up the poll on both sides. But it doesn't matter. In the end it came down to who the OP felt had made the better argument, and that was me. It didn't help that you and others kept going on about Jaina resisting Abeloth, which was revealed to be false.

- That isn't an opinion, thats a fact. I take things in that case as they were presented and don't try to formulate excuses for why she was less impressive in the book. If you'll recall, I have my own theory to excuse her loss of power. Unlike you though, I don't act as if it's true. I also don't think the portrayal should be paid attention to because Drew didn't research the character or give a shit about her. But boo hoo, I don't get to make that call.

- Are you referring to the Revan vs Zannah debate? If so, I think quite a few people believe it. I'm sure you wouldn't have that issue though. You said that I join debates I know are slaughters to big up my favorite characters. But the truth is that I'm 100% confident in my assessment of the match-up and truly believe that Zannah is better. If you disagree, you're welcome to put your money where your mouth is. As is anyone (with the obvious exceptions) . I'm happy to defend my position.

- Please, you're way more biased than I am. You've openly admitted you're a huge Traya/Exile fangirl. I don't even like Zannah and the Hero of Tython doesn't have a personality to like. I just think they're better than you do. I have a different opinion than you, get over it. And I'm not that hot, you don't need to say it twice.

- No I'm just talking smack cuz you talked smack at me. I can bust your chops without being mad. In the old days of KMC, typically half of someone's reply was taunts and put downs. It's not a big deal.

- Of course. You can't lose if you don't try, right? 😉

- I'm not taking his opinions at all. Merely stating a fact, that you made a claim and he disproved you. And then another fact, that Legend presents valid sources and has occasionally made arguments I found merit in. And then made the implicit suggestion that I can't say the same about you. That's all.

Thanks, you're so helpful. 😍

Nephthys is mad as ****.

Socks were messing up the poll on both sides. But it doesn't matter. In the end it came down to who the OP felt had made the better argument, and that was me. It didn't help that you and others kept going on about Jaina resisting Abeloth, which was revealed to be false.

Nah, Jaina was winner in that. Me and Fated counted up the votes in the comments and Jaina won by a nice distance. Great job, Sel. 👆

I shouldn't have said that I disliked people falsely accusing me of being mad. Now you're just doing it to get under my skin. Luckily I don't give a shit today.

Nah.

Well, I'm replying to your above post to Selenial, so we will just have to see.

Uh, yes we did. Final was like 11 votes to 7 votes IIRC.