Beyonder vs LT

Started by StiltmanFTW16 pages

Bada is even worse than Raz sometimes...

😆

my favorite are the ban notes of smoki and unknowable. "sock of mr master" lmao.

pretty sure eaebiekuya is also a mr master sock btw.

Professor was onto him right away lol.

Wasn't it stated back in the day that the Beyonder was below the LT?

Originally posted by Stoic
Wasn't it stated back in the day that the Beyonder was below the LT?

Yes and no. Remember this scene from SWII? Where Beyonder is threatening to destroy Death and all the powers of the multiverse can't stop him and are begging him not to do it :

The LT was there and he could stop Beyonder or bring back Death once he destroyed her.

Even after the Beyonder retcon, this scene is STILL valid. Mentioned in the Handbook entries of the Beyonder, Death, and the LT. To cement the fact that it's still a valid feat, it was shown in panel in an a later issue of Quasar :

Beyonder wins.

Originally posted by zopzop
Yes and no. Remember this scene from SWII? Where Beyonder is threatening to destroy Death and all the powers of the multiverse can't stop him and are begging him not to do it :

The LT was there and he could stop Beyonder or bring back Death once he destroyed her.

Even after the Beyonder retcon, this scene is STILL valid. Mentioned in the Handbook entries of the Beyonder, Death, and the LT. To cement the fact that it's still a valid feat, it was shown in panel in an a later issue of Quasar :

Beyonder wins.


Not to rain on your parade but Beyonder was outright shown inferior in GOTG to LT and even Eternity.

Wasn't it revealed somewhere (can't remember the source) that SW-II Beyonder couldn't even have beaten the planet of Celestials. Like, it was all an illusion they put in his mind or something?

Also like abhi said- in GOTG LT confined Beyonder to his own universe with a gesture. He was clearly beyond him postretcon.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Not to rain on your parade but Beyonder was outright shown inferior in GOTG to LT and even Eternity.

Seriously? That was an alternate timeline. There are versions of Beyonder from other realities that got killed by a bullet. We're talking about 616 Beyonder and the feats I mentioned are still canon to him.

I give this thread my continued blessing.

Originally posted by zopzop
Seriously? That was an alternate timeline. There are versions of Beyonder from other realities that got killed by a bullet. We're talking about 616 Beyonder and the feats I mentioned are still canon to him.

That wasn't 691 Beyonder. That was 616 Beyonder.

Originally posted by abhilegend
That wasn't 691 Beyonder. That was 616 Beyonder.

You can't be referring to the Beyonder from the GOTG issue involving the Protege. That's definitely an alternate timeline.

Originally posted by zopzop
You can't be referring to the Beyonder from the GOTG issue involving the Protege. That's definitely an alternate timeline.

Beyonder was actually from outside the multiverse, from his own universe.

How does that make him an alternate universe Beyonder?

👆

Mainstream Beyonder essentially just introduced himself into the GotG timeline.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Beyonder was actually from outside the multiverse, from his own universe.

How does that make him an alternate universe Beyonder?

Originally posted by Galan007
👆

Mainstream Beyonder essentially just introduced himself into the GotG timeline.


Explain why the most recent handbook entry for Beyonder (and his alternate forms) fails to mention this fact?

It has everything from Secret Wars all the way up to his last appearance before Annihilation.

I mean... Since when is canonicity dictated by whether or not an event is referenced in a bio?

Is there any legitimate info that actually proves the Beyonder in question was an alternate..? Because the page abhi posted seems pretty definitive, imo.

Originally posted by LordGod
Wasn't it revealed somewhere (can't remember the source) that SW-II Beyonder couldn't even have beaten the planet of Celestials. Like, it was all an illusion they put in his mind or something?

Also like abhi said- in GOTG LT confined Beyonder to his own universe with a gesture. He was clearly beyond him postretcon.

Yeah, in Fantastic Four Annual #26:

https://imgur.com/D2k308i

But according to the most recent handbook, the fight really happened.

Originally posted by Galan007
I mean... Since when is canonicity dictated by whether or not an event is referenced in a bio?

Is there any legitimate info that actually proves the Beyonder in question was an alternate..? Because the page abhi posted seems pretty definitive, imo.


It's an ALTERNATE future for Chrissake. The Beyonder handbook entry was thorough as phuck and the GOTG timeline wasn't mentioned at all.

The Marvel Appendix guys (Marvel defers to these guys for information for their Handbooks) agree with the Official Handbook Entry :
http://www.marvunapp.com/Appendix4/beyondersw.htm

Again, the GOTG timeline isn't' mentioned AT ALL.

See a pattern?

Easy now... No reason to go full Mr Master here.

The question is: how does any of what you posted preclude the notion that mainstream Beyonder was able to introduce himself into the GotG timeline? Because it seems like that's exactly what he did to me:

I say again: canonicity has never been dictated exclusively by whether or not an event is referenced in a bio. Have you any better evidence to counter with?

Originally posted by Galan007
Easy now... No reason to go full Mr Master here.

The question is: how does any of what you posted preclude the notion that mainstream Beyonder was able to introduce himself into the GotG timeline? Because it seems like that's exactly what he did to me:

I say again: canonicity has never been dictated exclusively by whether or not an event is referenced in a bio. Have you any better evidence to counter with?


My proof is the official bio backed up by the people that edit them for Marvel itself. The GOTG event took place in an alternate future. That was an alternate reality Beyonder. The fact that the GOTG appearance isn't mentioned in his handbook entries is my proof. Just like all his dozen other alt reality appearances do not appear in his 616 handbook entry (Mutant X universe, Wild West Universe Beyonder, etc...).

C'mon zop, even is mentioned that Beyonder passing throught the Scar of Eternity:

https://imgur.com/Vrqyy0c