Satele Shan vs. Obi Wan ROTS

Started by carthage3 pages

Satele Shan vs. Obi Wan ROTS

Both fighters are bloodlusted/morals off

Round 2 Satele gets Agen Kolar, Kenobi gets Darth Malgus

Satele ragdolls round 1 team 2 takes round 2

Round 1: Kenobi takes sabers but Satele takes all out.

Round 2: Team 2 wins.

Is it even within Satele's morals to ragdoll another Jedi?

Originally posted by Sinious
Round 1: Kenobi takes sabers but Satele takes all out.

Round 2: Team 2 wins.

👆

Originally posted by ILS
Is it even within Satele's morals to ragdoll another Jedi?

Does it matter?

Satele wins round one, Obi-Wan wins team.

Originally posted by ILS
Is it even within Satele's morals to ragdoll another Jedi?

Yeah, I know! It's almost as if morals were off in this fight.

Both fighters are bloodlusted/morals off

Originally posted by Sinious
Round 1: Kenobi takes sabers but Satele takes all out.

Round 2: Team 2 wins.


Agreed, Satele could take Kenobi in single combat. But if you give Kenobi Malgus and give Satele Kolar, the whole thing becomes incredibly lopsided in team two's favor.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Yeah, I know! It's almost as if morals were off in this fight.
I forgot carthage always has his threads set to bloodlusted. Sue me.

In-character Kenobi wins.

Kolar> Satele

Pretty much. Satele is in the same ballpark as Quinlan Vos, in terms of quality and fighting style, and we saw what Kolar did to him.

Except her force powers are on a completely different tier than Vos.

Which has nothing to do with her skill as a duelist 👆

Originally posted by carthage
Which has nothing to do with her skill as a duelist 👆
Yeah, I don't think he has quite been able to grasp that.

Unless I missed something, this is an all-out fight.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Unless I missed something, this is an all-out fight.
Based is developing a habit of leaping into debates about Force power when I'm talking about dueling skill.

Even accounting for Satele's Force power, if she engaged in a duel with Agen Kolar there isn't much to suggest that he couldn't dismember her in roughly the same time he could have done so to Quinlan Vos.

Originally posted by ILS
Based is developing a habit of leaping into debates about Force power when I'm talking about dueling skill.

Even accounting for Satele's Force power, if she engaged in a duel with Agen Kolar there isn't much to suggest that he couldn't dismember her in roughly the same time he could have done so to Quinlan Vos.


Carthage said Kolar>Satele in the context of an all-out fight, you agreed with him, and Based brought up her force powers. Not really seeing how his point is inapplicable to the argument.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Carthage said Kolar>Satele in the context of an all-out fight, you agreed with him, and Based brought up her force powers. Not really seeing how his point is inapplicable to the argument.
No, I referenced Satele's quality as a duelist and her use of Ataru in the context of putting her in Vos' place when Kolar thrashed him, which has nothing to do with Force power and everything to do with dueling ability.

First round, blood lusted.... = Go to force power (Like Luke skywalker in DE when he is so piss off....) And because she is a shan and have Revan blood, eeerr O.P power !! Remember against malgus....

Same for Kolar.. You defeat her in light saber duelling she still have her tutaminis, and O.P power. Kolar will surely cut her light saber staff...

Obiwan against Malgus... The isn't any of malgus force attack couldn't be counter by Obiwan. That's a bit bad said er wrote, but nevermind.
I mean obiwan can resist to all malgus force attacks...... But I don't know in light saber... Malgus is fast and strong obiwan is faster and is guard is more resistant.... Malgus have his armor....

Originally posted by ILS
Is it even within Satele's morals to ragdoll another Jedi?

Originally posted by ILS
I forgot carthage always has his threads set to bloodlusted. Sue me.

In-character Kenobi wins.

Originally posted by ILS
Pretty much. Satele is in the same ballpark as Quinlan Vos, in terms of quality and fighting style, and we saw what Kolar did to him.

I assumed you were talking about an all out fight as what the OP stated. Your previous posts mentioned nothing of only lightsaber combat and skill.

Your first post noted your lack of reading skills.
Your second post admitted a lack of reading skills.
Your third post states that "Satele is in the same ballpark as Quinlan Vos" which I assumed meant an all out battle per the OP. And while I do admit that you say that her "fighting style" was in terms of lightsaber combat I assumed that quality had that to do with force prowess rather than lightsaber skill because your previous posts had nothing to say about the topic and rather about your lack of reading skills.

So forgive my assumptions but there was a reason for them in the first place.

Carthage's post "Kolar> Satele" I assumed again was within his style of lowball trolling which he does in every thread. Since the OP again was an all out battle and not purely sabers I assumed he meant in totality Kolar> Satele.

I don't know y u so mad here, ILS.