Alan Scott Vs Beta Ray Bill

vs

Normal Alan FTW 8-9/10

Earth 2 Alan BRB takes it

Even DCNU Alan takes it.

Alan had that crazy earth feat.

Going with Alan Scott.

Originally posted by Golgo13
Alan had that crazy earth feat.

The taking on hundreds of parademons is just fodder and he got his ass handed him by a clone of E2 Supes who was also fighting everyone else (and who honestly was featless since his fighting enexperienced featless heroes is his sole claim to fame ) also doesn't speak well.

Nothing IMO BRB couldn't deal with.

Originally posted by beatboks
Holding the earth against the device that Sloane and Holt made to move it is the only really notable feat. Let's also consider his power comes from the planet he was holding, so I don't think it's that good a feat when all it shows is him holding his power source.

The taking on hundreds of parademons is just fodder and he got his ass handed him by a clone of E2 Supes who was also fighting everyone else (and who honestly was featless since his fighting enexperienced featless heroes is his sole claim to fame ) also doesn't speak well.

Nothing IMO BRB couldn't deal with.

^ @beatboks Wrong. Steppen wolf and Brutaal surprised him and started to beat him senseless and knocked him out.

Then again Alan died in Wolf's death explosion.

Horses Face smashes that faget.

I'm not completely up to date on Alan yet, but from what I read he wasn't quite there yet.

He stopped earth from getting moved for two issues straight. I don't think you need anything better to gauge his power.

Whilst Earth-2 was dying. With forum rules, he'd be at full power.

Originally posted by abhilegend
He stopped earth from getting moved for two issues straight. I don't think you need anything better to gauge his power.

That's very impressive.

But it's not above something I would expect from someone who's going to fight BRB.

Do I need to read anything outside the main title or does it include everything?

Originally posted by krisblaze
That's very impressive.

But it's not above something I would expect from someone who's going to fight BRB.

Do I need to read anything outside the main title or does it include everything?

It's all in E2, and E2: World's End.

Lol...that ft isn't enough to pull a win against Bill. Space Cheese. Really? Guess he is going to pull Bill for the win.

Originally posted by krisblaze
That's very impressive.

But it's not above something I would expect from someone who's going to fight BRB.

Do I need to read anything outside the main title or does it include everything?

Originally posted by Galan007
^ it's worth noting, abhi, that the entirety of brainiac's mothership still hadn't surfaced from the portal--so it was even larger than what we were shown. craycray.

anyway, i posted alan's planetary feat from the last issue, but it was confirmed again this issue:

note that he held the earth for roughly half of the issue. insane.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I don't think bill is powerful enough to stop earth from moving by a giant mother box.

I don't see how Bill would do it.

His powerset isn't very well suited for holding things in place.

Or are you saying there's not enough power in Stormbreaker? 🙂

Originally posted by krisblaze
I don't see how Bill would do it.

His powerset isn't very well suited for holding things in place.

Or are you saying there's not enough power in Stormbreaker? 🙂

Originally posted by abhilegend
You can say both. The two times bill has been pitted against moving celestial bodies, in star masters and annihilators he either failed miserably or needed help from silver surfer.

Star masters had a different BRB, and he still stopped a black hole didn't he? And it certainly seemed like star masters had a different take on the power of black holes.

I'm not sure what instance you're referring to in annihilators. I might not have read it.

Bill doesn't have the powerset to duplicate Alan's feat, but I'm certain he has the raw power. I have no doubt that he'd be able to break through whatever Alan creates 🙂