Satele Shan vs. General Grievous

Started by |King Joker|3 pages
|King Joker| Your Excellency

Satele Shan vs. General Grievous

Both in their prime. Battle takes place in an open field. Who wins?

Fated Xtasy Kami

I'd guess Grevious would have the edge in sabers and Satele would probably wreck with the Force.

ILS Restricted

I think Satele is smart enough to win with the Force.

Emperordmb LSDMB

Grievous definitely has the edge as a duelist, but Satele wins via the force.

carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

Grievous imo

Kosmos Supreme Senior Member

Satele Shan wins, any version past Hope trailer would be enough.

Q99 Senior Member

Yea, Satele's grand master for good reason, she should win.

ILS Restricted

Grievous winning is probably debatable, I just see Satele coming out on top due to having the Hero-force on her side, as well as the actual Force.

Q99 Senior Member

Aside from force, where she's known to dismantle droids with a gesture, it's not like she's bad with saber either! Holding her own vs Malgus, beating Mekhis...

Jmanghan Senior Member

Didn't H.O.T., Satele, and a few others get shit-stomped by Revan 3.0 after they showed up to take down his evil side?

Jmanghan Senior Member

Grievous has almost defeated Obi-Wan Kenobi.

ILS Restricted

Originally posted by Q99
Aside from force, where she's known to dismantle droids with a gesture, it's not like she's bad with saber either! Holding her own vs Malgus, beating Mekhis...
Nobody said she's bad, but Grievous is clearly on another level entirely.

S_W_LeGenD Senior Member

Satele Shan comfortably

Jinsoku Takai CIT Network Technician
Originally posted by ILS
Nobody said she's bad, but Grievous is clearly on another level entirely.

🤨 So are you implying that Fisto is on another level as well, as compared to Shan?

Jinsoku Takai CIT Network Technician

I'd wager that Malgus would out-duel Grievous as well. Satele Shan is by no means on a lower level than Grievous in sabers.

ILS Restricted

Originally posted by Jinsoku Takai
🤨 So are you implying that Fisto is on another level as well, as compared to Shan?
Why would he be?

Edit: He probably isn't as far ahead of her as Grievous, but I'd still put him ahead as a swordsman, for sure.

Trocity Undefeated and Undisputed

I honestly don't see her hitting him with anything he won't be prepared for. Grievous is faster and more skilled than her. Yes, she was strong enough to compete with Malgus' physical power, but Grievous has 3 more lightsabers than Malgus and is more skilled than him with them to boot. I don't think Satele will have much time to hit him with some TK crushing bull**** cuz he's going to be swarming her and giving her no opportunities.

Nephthys The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

Satele through the Force.

GG really isn't that much faster than her, she could still blitz Sith Warriors and shit. And GM Satele is faster.

S_W_LeGenD Senior Member

Originally posted by Trocity
I honestly don't see her hitting him with anything he won't be prepared for. Grievous is faster and more skilled than her. Yes, she was strong enough to compete with Malgus' physical power, but Grievous has 3 more lightsabers than Malgus and is more skilled than him with them to boot. I don't think Satele will have much time to hit him with some TK crushing bull**** cuz he's going to be swarming her and giving her no opportunities.

Grievous is faster based on what?

Satele Shan is immensely fast.

Also, Grievous cannot defend against Shan's Force powers.

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

http://www.comicvine.com/profile/darthant66/blog/satele-shan-respect-thread/103104/.