Originally posted by SSJGGogeta
Yes. [B]I SAID VEGETTO WINS. Because he would, in cannon. In the anime, the only reason Gogeta would win is because of dubbing errors. 👆Vegetto wins SOLIDLY in base, because not ONLY were the potara "vastly superior to that silly dance", as per ELDER KAI'S OWN WORDS, but Vegetto ALSO got ANOTHER boost, from Goku and Vegeta being rivals. To the point where SSJ1 Vegetto COULD HAVE KILLED BUUHAN WITH A KIAI. Which is JUST A WAVE. Literally. 👆
SSJ3 Goku TEAMED UP with SSJ2 Gohan, WOULD HAVE HAD NO CHANCE AGAINST REGULAR SUPER BUU. This was stated BY GOKU HIMSELF. SSJ3 Goku fought on par with Super Janemba. Super Gogeta beat Super Janemba pretty handily, but didn't take him out with ANYTHING LESS than his strongest attack. Meaning that Super Gogeta wasn't MUCH stronger than SSJ3 Goku, even though he definitely was stronger. SSJ1 Vegetto was strong enough to kill an enemy that was FOUR SSJ'S ABOVE someone that SSJ3 Goku AND SSJ2 Vegeta teamed up, would have had no chance against... WITH A WAVE. SSJ1 Vegetto >>>>> Buuhan >>> Buutenks >>> Buucolo >> Super Buu >> SSJ3 Goku/SSJ2 Vegeta teamed up >>> SSJ3 Goku.
Super Janemba > SSJ3 Goku.
Do you not understand this? Vegetto in BASE FORM would have EATEN Super Janemba. Probably as badly as Super Vegetto would have stomped Buuhan. Meaning that BASE Vegetto would have DEFINITELY been able to put Super Gogeta down, especially considering that base Vegetto is permanent, and Super Gogeta stays fused for less than 30 minutes. 👆 [/B]
Couple of things here:
1. It was SSJ2 Vegeta not Gohan.
2. SSJ3 Goku was not "on par" with Janemba. Janemba was clearly superior.
3. You have no idea if that was Gogeta's "strongest attck". It was his "ONLY" attack that we saw. Unless you have actual proof it was his strongest attack, that's a baseless claim.
4. There are many reasons the earrings can be considered "vastly superior to that silly dance" without it creating a stronger fighter:
a) The dance is more time consuming
b) The dance can be interrupted much more easily
c) The dance can be performed incorrectly resulting in a poor fighter
d) The users of the earrings don't have to have an even PL
e) The earrings don't have a time limit.
And 5. That "rivialry boost" could occur with the dance as well, but even if not, there is no indication it boosts them over the SSJ multipliers.