Originally posted by ares834
But there are plenty of depressing Suprman stories. Hell, perhaps the most famous Superman comic (Death of Superman) is depressing. Now I agree, I wish the film was far more optimistic and upbeat and I think accusing it of being too dark and too dreary is a very fair criticism. But simply saying "dat ain't Superman" based solely on preconceived (and often flawed) notions of what the character is is not a valid one.
Death of Superman had a vibrant color palette and showcased Superman being the inspirational icon he was meant to be, despite the comic itself being depressing.
In fact, the reason the comic was depressing is because Superman is this beacon of hope. Seeing that hope dashed is sad as ****.
The problem with Man of Steel is that there is no hope to be found. The washed out, shitgrey color palette and the overall depressing atmosphere and tone do nothing to make you care if Superman fails. I feel no reason to give a **** about Pa Kent being killed because of how insanely shitdark and morbid the character and context is.
Also, if the movie isn't even going to try to capture the tone of the character being adapted, why is it a Superman movie? When you attach the name onto something, there needs to be something of the source material there. The only moment in Man of Steel that is Supermanly (other than the admittedly awesome fight sequences) is the first flying scene.