Vader vs. Revan--who is better in each category?

Started by psmith8199210 pages

That's so cute. S66 is still posting.

1. Vader
2. Revan
3. Revan
4. Vader
5. Vader
6. Revan
7. Debatable

Re: Vader vs. Revan--who is better in each category?


1. Strenght

Vader.

2. Speed

I'll give Revan the benefit of the doubt.

3. Stamina/Endurance

Either or, tbh. Vader's a cyborg and Revan's a zombie.

4. Lightsaber prowess

Vader's the more prolific of the two, I suppose.

5. TK

Vader.

6. Esoteric force powers

Revan.

7. Overall

Probably Revan.

1) Vader
2) Even, or Revan.
3) Revan
4) Vader
5) Vader
6) Revan
7) Vader

1. Strength - Vader
2. Speed - Revan
3. Stamina - Revan
4. Lightsaber prowess - Even
5. TK - Vader
6. Esoteric force powers - Revan
7. Overall - Revan

Re: Vader vs. Revan--who is better in each category?

Originally posted by Stigma
Decide who, between peak Vader and peak Revan, is better in each of the listed categories:

1. Strenght
2. Speed
3. Stamina
4. Lightsaber prowess
5. TK
6. Esoteric force powers
7. Overall

1. Vader
2. Revan
3. Vader
4. Vader
5. Vader
6. Revan
7. Undecided.

How the **** does Vader have better stamina than Revan?

The guy fought armies of Sith for over an hour, then Bastila, then an army bigger and tougher than the army that he fought for an hour, then Darth Malak on a nexus.

"the ability to sustain prolonged physical or mental effort."

Plus we can throw in his mental war with Vitiate, insane pain resistance, willing himself back from the dead, and continuing to fight on Yavin IV despite X, Y, and Z happening to him.

I really doubt 1 room of droids was bigger than the whole floors of Sith that proceeded it. No matter if they replicate or not.

Malak was quite certain those droids would beat Revan while the armies of Sith would fall. mmm

I'm willing to bet that's due to numbers than being better than dozens of mega amped dark side warriors.

Or he was just thick enough to not think that Revan could reprogram the consoles. Also theres more of a constant pressure with that room than just loads of droids.

Been awhile since I played KotOR, but didn't Malak realize that his armies wouldn't stop Revan? Wasn't it all to buy him time to prepare for the duel?

To me that looks like a game mechanic, tbh. Malak may be perceived as dumb but he's not going to let Revan take control of the Star Forge's best droids after preparing and counting on them throughout Revan's entire room to stop him. Plus I can't picture Revan canonically reprogramming them while others are shooting at him like shown in the game. That being said, even if there weren't more droids, he still fought through a respectable amount of them, the armies before him, Shan, and then Malak, so my point holds.

Originally posted by ares834
Been awhile since I played KotOR, but didn't Malak realize that his armies wouldn't stop Revan? Wasn't it all to buy him time to prepare for the duel?

Malak knew the armies wouldn't stop Revan, but he thought he could use them to buy time so he could set up the droids in the final room against Revan, IIRC.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
To me that looks like a game mechanic, tbh. Malak may be perceived as dumb but he's not going to let Revan take control of the Star Forge's best droids after preparing and counting on them throughout Revan's entire room to stop him. Plus I can't picture Revan canonically reprogramming them while others are shooting at him like shown in the game. That being said, even if there weren't more droids, he still fought through a respectable amount of them, the armies before him, Shan, and then Malak, so my point holds.

Buh-buh... BUT IT WAS SCRIPTED BRO! The game designers INTENTIONALLY put it there, so it must have been what happened.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Buh-buh... BUT IT WAS SCRIPTED BRO! The game designers INTENTIONALLY put it there, so it must have been what happened.

http://bottomlinehealth.com/help-my-mouth-tastes-salty-all-the-time/

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
http://bottomlinehealth.com/help-my-mouth-tastes-salty-all-the-time/

Concession accepted.

Vader is the Chosen One, so he's better in all categories. Trufax

TBH, I have no problem logically breaking apart the Star Forge event after re-reading the prima.

Malak established an infinite line of droids, so clearly at one point Revan would have to disable them.

That doesn't change Revan's multitasking or battling through multiple waves of them or what I said in the thread.

Their firepower alone is capable of utterly destroying massive Rakata doors that stood for countless centuries.

Originally posted by WildBantha88
Vader in all

Mfw I read KMC this early in the morning and see shit like this:

Depressing isn't it?