(Rematch) The Hulk (MCU) VS Thor (MCU)

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Grandmaster cheated for Hulk; Thor had Hulk dead to rights...

Hell, Thor was even trying to reason with Hulk and still had the upperhand...

Thor's 1st real attack against Hulk did more to Hulk than any of Hulks attacks did to Thor...

Your bias and fanboyish nature knows no limits...

Hulk loses to Thor 10/10 in a Forum Fight...

Read em and weep loser...

💃

So what ? Thor did not have the upper hand. Speculation. Thor woke up sore Hulk wasn't sore.

Hulk wins. He ko'd Thor. Reality is fantastic.

😂

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Grandmaster cheated for Hulk; Thor had Hulk dead to rights...

Hell, Thor was even trying to reason with Hulk and still had the upperhand...

Thor's 1st real attack against Hulk did more to Hulk than any of Hulks attacks did to Thor...

Your bias and fanboyish nature knows no limits...

Hulk loses to Thor 10/10 in a Forum Fight...

Read em and weep loser...

💃

👆

I'd like to thank quan for proving my point.

After Thor:Rag. It's clear that ungimped Thor would eventually take down the Hulk after a long brutal/bloody fight.

Of course this narrative could change after Infinity Wars with new showings, but as of right now. Thor > Hulk, only if slightly.

Originally posted by Silent Master
I'd like to thank quan for proving my point.

Thank you.

Originally posted by Robtard
After Thor:Rag. It's clear that ungimped Thor would eventually take down the Hulk after a long brutal/bloody fight.

Of course this narrative could change after Infinity Wars with new showings, but as of right now. Thor > Hulk, only if slightly.

Thor was ko'd, woke up sore, etc.

We take the totality of their history not just one film. They all support the same narrative Hulk is the powerhouse of the team. Thor relies on his skill to compete.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Thank you.

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
👆

Originally posted by quanchi112
Your opinion on what could have happened doesn't change what did actually take place.

Thor was ko'd, woke up sore, etc.

We take the totality of their history not just one film. They all support the same narrative Hulk is the powerhouse of the team. Thor relies on his skill to compete.

My "opinion" is based on the fact that Thor showed himself to be superior overall. Brute strength isn't the only thing in a fight. Thor was even gimped going in.

LoL. This film has the two fighting in an arena and Thor is lacking standard gear, yet still manages to pull ahead a tad. That's as clear as it gets in a Vs Match. Tells me Thor > Hulk, when it comes to a fight and most things, in fact all things except a pure strength contest. Hulk has strength over Thor, nothing else. Not fighting prowess, not durability, not range of powers. Ragnarok proved this; it's now a film franchise fact until it's changed (if) in future films.

Originally posted by Robtard
My "opinion" is based on the fact that Thor showed himself to be superior overall. Brute strength isn't the only thing in a fight. Thor was even gimped going in.

LoL. This film has the two fighting in an arena and Thor is lacking standard gear, yet still manages to pull ahead a tad. Tells me Thor > Hulk, when it comes to a fight and most things, in fact all things except a pure strength contest. Hulk has strength over Thor, nothing else. Not fighting prowess, not durability, not range of powers. Ragnarok proved this; it's now a film franchise fact until it's changed (if) in future films.

It should also be noted that Thor didn't even use lightning strikes against Hulk in this fight.

Originally posted by FrothByte
It should also be noted that Thor didn't even use lightning strikes against Hulk in this fight.

He used one, a minor one when he charged his fist and sent Hulk flying with a lighting-punch. Just one in their match, unleashed now he could make every punch charged.

Originally posted by Robtard
My "opinion" is based on the fact that Thor showed himself to be superior overall. Brute strength isn't the only thing in a fight. Thor was even gimped going in.

This film has the two fighting in an area and Thor is lacking standard gear, yet still manages to pull ahead a tad. Tells me Thor > Hulk, when it comes to a fight and most things, in fact all things except a pure strength contest. Hulk has strength over Thor, nothing else. Not fighting prowess, not durability, not range or powers. Ragnarok proved this; it's now a film franchise fact until it's changed (if) in future films.

Thor had gear and his power is inherent. Thor didn't pull ahead he hurt the Hulk. Hulk hurt Thor so since the fight was stopped at that point you're trying to claim a false victory. It's the same as had their first fight had stopped right after the hammer shot to Hulk. Hulk recovered and the fight continued.

Durability in spades over Thor. How does it make any sense Thor is as durable as the Hulk ? We see the bruises Thor recovered and soreness from their battle proved hulks superior durability. You also believe Thor is more powerful but somehow don't see the issue with no soreness from Thor's attacks while at the same time ignore Thor's soreness from Hulk's weaker attacks according to you.

Hulk took his best and was ready for more. He can handle more punishment than Thor hence why Thor is more skilled and Hulk is the powerhouse of the two.

Originally posted by FrothByte
It should also be noted that Thor didn't even use lightning strikes against Hulk in this fight.

Originally posted by FrothByte
It should also be noted that Thor didn't even use lightning strikes against Hulk in this fight.

I assume when you say lightning strikes, you mean ranged attacks. if so, I agree.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thor was never gimped. I also never said brute strength is the only component in a fight. I said Hulk's superior physicality wins out in a prolonged fight with Thor's superior skill level.

Thor had gear and his power is inherent. Thor didn't pull ahead he hurt the Hulk. Hulk hurt Thor so since the fight was stopped at that point you're trying to claim a false victory. It's the same as had their first fight had stopped right after the hammer shot to Hulk. Hulk recovered and the fight continued.

Durability in spades over Thor. How does it make any sense Thor is as durable as the Hulk ? We see the bruises Thor recovered and soreness from their battle proved hulks superior durability. You also believe Thor is more powerful but somehow don't see the issue with no soreness from Thor's attacks while at the same time ignore Thor's soreness from Hulk's weaker attacks according to you.

Hulk took his best and was ready for more. He can handle more punishment than Thor hence why Thor is more skilled and Hulk is the powerhouse of the two.

Not having standard gear is being gimped. Thor used Mjolnir to control his powers, when he lost it he didn't have full access to his lightning powers too much; that was a key point of the film.

By the end of the film, Thor no longer needed the hammer to call/control lighting. But he still could not fly.

Thor still has the better durability all films combined. He tanked the Bifrost and Sokovia explosions. Now Hulk's durability has gone down due to bleeding profusely from a giant wolf 🙁

Thor would win in the end; this film proved it. Time to deal with this reality. I'm Team Hulk and I've dealt with it, Thor is superior, even is slightly.

Originally posted by Robtard
Not having standard gear is gimped. Thor used Mjolnir to control his powers, when he lost it he at the time he didn't have full access to his lightning powers too much. That was a key point of the film.

By the end of the film, Thor no longer needed the hammer to call/control lighting. But he still could not fly.

Thor still has the better durability all films combined. He tanked the Bifrost and Sokovia explosions. Now Hulk's durability has gone down due to bleeding profusely from a giant wolf 🙁

Thor would win in the end, this film proved it. Time to deal with this reality. I'm Team Hulk and I've dealt with it, Thor is superior, even is slightly.

Thor is the source of his own powers. Odin explains this in the film. He isn't the god of hammers. Thor is the source of his own powers which I predicted prior to the film. I read comics unlike most of the movie vs. debaters. They also already previously fought when he held the hammer. Did Thor win or was he winning when they stopped fighting ?

Whose fault was it his hammer was destroyed ? Was it Thor's or Hulk's ?

So you believe exclusive feats are more of an indicator than direct comparisons between the characters.

Nah, Thor hasn't won nor did he win. Objective reality saw Hulk win. Thor woke up sore and he was called baby arms by Hulk.

Hulk was fine. 🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thor is the source of his own powers. Odin explains this in the film. He isn't the god of hammers. Thor is the source of his own powers which I predicted prior to the film. I read comics unlike most of the movie vs. debaters.

They also already previously fought when he held the hammer. Did Thor win or was he winning when they stopped fighting ?

Whose fault was it his hammer was destroyed ? Was it Thor's or Hulk's ?

So you believe exclusive feats are more of an indicator than direct comparisons between the characters.

Nah, Thor hasn't won nor did he win. Objective reality saw Hulk win. Thor woke up sore and he was called baby arms by Hulk.

Hulk was fine. 🙂

Yeah, exactly what I just explained as per the film, Thor used the hammer to control his powers; meaning Mjolnir wasn't the source, just the tool to control. Now he's free of that, except for flying.

Carrier fight, Thor was holding back as to not destroy the ship. Already covered that long ago. Now we have an arena fight and Thor styled all over the place.

Who cares? The hammer being destroyed was a plot line for Thor discovering his inner abilities. It was a growth arch.

We have exclusive feats and direct comparisons. Thor comes up ahead in everything except brute strength, as shown over and over.

Thor has, time to accept and move on. Team Hulk lost for now and that's a fact unless Infinity Wars films change that narrative.

Hulk was fine, it's still a ding in his durability though now, which is the point. Thor >>>>>> Hulk in durability, all films combined.

Originally posted by Robtard
Yeah, exactly what I just explained as per the film, Thor used the hammer to control his powers; meaning Mjolnir wasn't the source, just the tool to control. Now he's free of that, except for flying.

Carrier fight, Thor was holding back as to not destroy the ship. Already covered that long ago. Now we have an arena fight and Thor styled all over the place.

Who cares? The hammer being destroyed was a plot line for Thor discovering his inner abilities. It was a growth arch.

We have exclusive feats and direct comparisons. Thor comes up ahead in everything except brute strength, as shown over and over.

Thor has, time to accept and move on. Team Hulk lost for now and that's a fact unless Infinity Wars films change that narrative.

Hulk was fine, it's still a ding in his durability though now, which is the point. Thor >>>>>> Hulk in durability, all films combined.

I disagree.

Hulk>>>>>>>>>>Thor durability wise.

Thor's powers and combat skills put him ahead i would agree.

Originally posted by Robtard
Yeah, exactly what I just explained as per the film, Thor used the hammer to control his powers; meaning Mjolnir wasn't the source, just the tool to control. Now he's free of that, except for flying.

Carrier fight, Thor was holding back as to not destroy the ship. Already covered that long ago. Now we have an arena fight and Thor styled all over the place.

Who cares? The hammer being destroyed was a plot line for Thor discovering his inner abilities. It was a growth arch.

We have exclusive feats and direct comparisons. Thor comes up ahead in everything except brute strength, as shown over and over.

Thor has, time to accept and move on. Team Hulk lost for now and that's a fact unless Infinity Wars films change that narrative.

Hulk was fine, it's still a ding in his durability though now, which is the point. Thor >>>>>> Hulk in durability, all films combined.

Who said he held back when he struck Hulk with the hammer. Did he ko the Hulk with the hammer ? No, he didn't. Hulk recovered and asserted his dominance.

I called it. I understand the character and he unleashed his lightning on the Hulk. He recovered just like he did against the initial hammer blow from the first film.

Hulk won. That's an objective fact. Thor fans pretend he was going to win. That didn't occur. Reality also showed us Thor woke up feeling hurt.

No, in a direct comparison Hulk is clearly more durable. Thor admitted one projectile thrown from Hulk could have killed him. We have in universe same situations to gauge a direct comparison between the two and Hulk is clearly superior.

Quit ignoring comparisons and objective reality. Hulk won. Deal with it.

🙂