(Rematch) The Hulk (MCU) VS Thor (MCU) · Movie Versus Forum

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Difference is Thor was just getting started unleashing his actual true power here.
Hulk only recovered after GM zapped Thor which doesn't count.

So Hulk withstood his true power. I always told you he could but now we have definitive proof.

Hulk recovered prior to this watch the film again. With both men ready he zapped Thor. He's corrupt.

No the fight ended with Thor unleashing his true power which was clearly above Hulk.[/B]

No, your interpretation isn't a fact it's just bias. Hulk was hurt and he recovered. Pre fight you stated the reason we haven't seen lightning hit the Hulk is because he can't withstand it. You were proven wrong.

There's nothing anywhere to indicate Hulk could have turned the tables so stop pretending there was.
You're using double standards as well. For years you argued Hulk kicked Thor's butt in the first Avengers because the fight got interrupted when Hulk was winning. Now you're claiming this fight ending with Thor winning means nothing and could have been overturned, with nothing suggesting that anywhere.
[/B]

There definitely is since the fight saw momentum swing multiple times. Just because Thor hit him with two attacks isn't proof thus would continue. Hulk was shown superior in their first fight as well. I have always maintained the same position. You argued without Mjolnir this fight doesn't count now it does count. You were scared and didn't have faith in Thor and wanted to protect yourself. I tried telling you. Thor wasn't depowered at all.

Moot point given Hulk wasn't zapped by GM.
Thor also took Everything Hulk had, whereas Hulk only got a taste of Thor's power. [/B]

Thor had clear bruising not from the zaps of the obedience discs. Thor was sore from the beating and he also admitted Hulk could have killed him when he threw the projectile at him.

Darth Thor Senior Member

Originally posted by quanchi112
So Hulk withstood his true power. I always told you he could but now we have definitive proof.

No he didn't. He was on the ropes. Just like RULK admitted Thor had him on the ropes in the comics before Green Hulk interrupted that fight.

Being on the ropes means you're Losing, and any interference is saving your skin.

There's no reason to think otherwise.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Hulk recovered prior to this watch the film again. With both men ready he zapped Thor. He's corrupt.

Hulk NEEDED Time to Recover after EACH Lightning Punch.

Compare that to Thor who recovered instantly after Repeated punches to the face from Hulk. Thor took everything Hulk had. Whereas Hulk only began to taste Thor's true power and was already losing.

Originally posted by quanchi112
No, your interpretation isn't a fact it's just bias.

Nah it's fact, that's why you're the only one left here arguing Hulk is superior. For the rest of the world it's clear Thor =/> Hulk.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Pre fight you stated the reason we haven't seen lightning hit the Hulk is because he can't withstand it. You were proven wrong.

Lightning Thor was clearly Superior to Hulk. So I was proven right.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Hulk was shown superior in their first fight as well.

Your double standards at work again.

You say Hulk looked superior simply because he was winning when the fight was interrupted. But you won't admit Thor looked superior when he was winning at the end of the fight.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I have always maintained the same position. You argued without Mjolnir this fight doesn't count now it does count. You were scared and didn't have faith in Thor and wanted to protect yourself. I tried telling you. Thor wasn't depowered at all.

Nah you argued that Mjolnir and Lightning wouldn't make a difference. You were scared at the idea of Thor showing his true power, and proving himself the Avenger's true powerhouse.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thor had clear bruising not from the zaps of the obedience discs. Thor was sore from the beating and he also admitted Hulk could have killed him when he threw the projectile at him.

That's because Hulk gave him everything he had instead of singing him lullabys. And Thor took it all. He only went down to GM's disc. And Hulk carried on pounding on Thor after the disc already put him down. So of course Thor was gonna have more bruises LOL

So there's no argument left for Hulk being superior, because we already know Thor can take everything Hulk has.

FrothByte Nailcutter Massacre

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yes, he hit him with a ranged attack. I've already responded to the facts. Your speculation is desperate at best.

When did he hit him with a ranged attack? Specify the exact scene because I'm pretty sure there isn't any.

There is no speculation in what I'm saying. I said Thor never hit Hulk with a lightning bolt. That's fact, not speculation. Do you disagree?

Josh_Alexander Keeper of Cosmic Balance

Originally posted by Silent Master
You're free to be wrong.
Name Hulk's best durability feats and I'll name ones from Thor that are better.

Hahaha. Wanna play that card?

Hulk engaging a mountain size superhot behemoth(Surtur) skin bare without suffering no damage.

Hulk getting shot by Chitauri ship class weapons with no damage.

Hulk being used to demolish an entire buliding by HulkBuster armor suffering 0 damage.

Want more?

Your turn now.

P.D. I removed you from my ignore list, dont make me regret it 😉

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Darth Thor
No he didn't. He was on the ropes. Just like RULK admitted Thor had him on the ropes in the comics before Green Hulk interrupted that fight.
Being on the ropes means you're Losing, and any interference is saving your skin.
There's no reason to think otherwise.

Hulk recovered completely. Saying he was on the verge of losing is being dishonest. Having someone on the ropes doesn't mean you're going to lose it just means the other guy has the momentum. Hulk recovered just as he recovered from the initial hammer shot from Avengers 1.

Hulk NEEDED Time to Recover after EACH Lightning Punch.
Compare that to Thor who recovered instantly after Repeated punches to the face from Hulk. Thor took everything Hulk had. Whereas Hulk only began to taste Thor's true power and was already losing.
[/B]

It was a jump and lightning amped punch. There is more force to that than a close quarter punch. When Hulk did his jump punch thing he ko'd Thor.

That wasn't everything Hulk had. Look at Hulkbuster armor firing rapid jabs right to the fact and we see Hulk recover. Your bias is nauseating. Thor can hurt the Hulk but hulk can withstand a lot more punishment than Thor can. That's always been my point.

Nah it's fact, that's why you're the only one left here arguing Hulk is superior. For the rest of the world it's clear Thor =/> Hulk.
[/B]

Opinions vary and the evidence supports my claims. Hulk withstood what you said he couldn't. Factual. I told you he could take the lightning you said it would change the result while Thor still didn't win. You're left with coulda, woulda, shouldas.

Lightning Thor was clearly Superior to Hulk. So I was proven right.
[/B]

False, he just hurt the Hulk but he already did without lightning.

Your double standards at work again.
You say Hulk looked superior simply because he was winning when the fight was interrupted. But you won't admit Thor looked superior when he was winning at the end of the fight.
[/B]

Hulk looked physically superior since he was fine and Thor wasn't on top of him. Both men stood their ground so the circumstances aren't exactly the same. You're upset Thor didn't win in his own film. Kinda sad, sport.

Nah you argued that Mjolnir and Lightning wouldn't make a difference. You were scared at the idea of Thor showing his true power, and proving himself the Avenger's true powerhouse.[/B]

I said they wouldn't change the outcome and they didn't. Thor didn't win you said Hulk couldn't withstand it. That's why it hasn't been written in. I can requote you but you purposely avoided your post. The Quinjet proved it literally.

That's because Hulk gave him everything he had instead of singing him lullabys. And Thor took it all. He only went down to GM's disc. And Hulk carried on pounding on Thor after the disc already put him down. So of course Thor was gonna have more bruises LOL
So there's no argument left for Hulk being superior, because we already know Thor can take everything Hulk has. [/B]

No, he didn't. He wasn't falling over due to fatigue Thor countered. Hulk ko'd him. Thor woke up sore and wincing in pain. Hulk wasn't ko'd.

His face wasn't bruised and that's what Hulk punched after the disc so the bruises had already occurred to his stomach area iirc.

Hulk is superior as the film clearly shows as the true powerhouse. Thor is the skilled warrior as the film proves. Thor didn't win when he used lighting as I claimed.

🙂

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by FrothByte
When did he hit him with a ranged attack? Specify the exact scene because I'm pretty sure there isn't any.
There is no speculation in what I'm saying. I said Thor never hit Hulk with a lightning bolt. That's fact, not speculation. Do you disagree?

Tbor shot lightning out of his hands to knock him back.m it wasn't the lightning amped punch. The first attack wasn't a punch he shot it out. That's the second lightning attack Thor hit him with.

You're now saying since he didn't use a lightning bolt from the sky that's what would have done what ? It didn't do anything to Hela and it was the biggest one ever.

Silent Master Senior Member

Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Hahaha. Wanna play that card?
Hulk engaging a mountain size superhot behemoth(Surtur) skin bare without suffering no damage.
Hulk getting shot by Chitauri ship class weapons with no damage.
Hulk being used to demolish an entire buliding by HulkBuster armor suffering 0 damage.
Want more?
Your turn now.
P.D. I removed you from my ignore list, dont make me regret it 😉

Surtur treated him like a bug and threw him away in seconds, it's not like the Hulk took a extended beating from him.

Only the Hulk did suffer damage, he was ko'd and bleeding. remember the scene of him rising from the rumble with a bloody nose?

An entire building, wow.

Thor has the Bi-Frost explosion and the Jotunheim buster, those beat everything you listed and I only had to use his first movie.

Dayman Member

Lol

Dayman Member

Originally posted by quanchi112
Tbor shot lightning out of his hands to knock him back.m it wasn't the lightning amped punch. The first attack wasn't a punch he shot it out. That's the second lightning attack Thor hit him with.
You're now saying since he didn't use a lightning bolt from the sky that's what would have done what ? It didn't do anything to Hela and it was the biggest one ever.

Quan, again, Thor was previously KO'd from the obedience disk, Hulks super jump punch didnt Ko Thor.

The obedience disk AND super Hulks punch KO'd Thor.

Ive watched this fight 30 times, both were punches.

So all 100 people who agree Thor wins are WRONG and you and that Josh clown are the only two right?

Dayman Member

Originally posted by quanchi112
I am sick of Thor fans saying if the fight continued or Thor did this or that would have happened. It's speculation. That's similar to Skip Bayless explaining a cowboys loss. It's delusional and ignoring objective reality and what did occur.

As you say Thor hit Hulk with a lightning blast and not a punch? Ive seen the fight like 30 times, it was online for a bit, it was a punch. His hand is in a fist. Quan you are an ansolute freakin idiot, you know that?

To quote the great Bill Walton, you are an insult to people who think.

You are far from objective. The fight was a tie. Thor looked better. Thats it. Go rub one out to and Thanos, after that, when your libido has calmed, you can maybe be more objective

Josh_Alexander Keeper of Cosmic Balance

Originally posted by Silent Master
Surtur treated him like a bug and threw him away in seconds, it's not like the Hulk took a extended beating from him.
Only the Hulk did suffer damage, he was ko'd and bleeding. remember the scene of him rising from the rumble with a bloody nose?
An entire building, wow.
Thor has the Bi-Frost explosion and the Jotunheim buster, those beat everything you listed and I only had to use his first movie.

Is not like Thor could replicate that! Lol.

https://youtu.be/z6KYhfC9hhU

Minute 3. Nothing serious.

Lol. Nothing of that exceeds what Hulk has withstood. Thor hasnt recieved the sttacks Hulk has.

Silent Master Senior Member

Nothing you listed even comes close to no-selling the Bi-Frost.

Josh_Alexander Keeper of Cosmic Balance

Originally posted by Silent Master
Nothing you listed even comes close to no-selling the Bi-Frost.

Thor wasnt near the explosion!

Thor broke the bridge which shattered and sent them flying away. By the time the Bifrost collapsed and exploted they were at a distance where the blast wasnt that harming.

Direct contact with Surtur surely opposes the Bi Frost scene.

I dont see Thor taking direct hits from Chitauri Ships and do as well as Hulk did.

Hulk》Thor durabilitywise.

Silent Master Senior Member

Thor was at the epicenter of the explosion. but thanks for proving you don't know what you're talking about.

Josh_Alexander Keeper of Cosmic Balance

Originally posted by Silent Master
Thor was at the epicenter of the explosion. but thanks for proving you don't know what you're talking about.

Reviewed the scene, it was the bridge that exploded, not the bifrost. The bifrost collapsed. But thanks for proving you dont know what you are talking about.

Either way, what makes you think that an explosion of the Bifrost Bridge is that deadly?

Reviewing the scene it just looks like a shock wave followed by Rainbowish light.

https://youtu.be/Fn8w30rsVUE

Isnt like you can say that is comparable to getting swarmed by chitauri blasters...

Silent Master Senior Member

The bridge is what was powering the Bi-Frost, that is why I called it the Bi-Frost explosion. That is what everyone calls it. your little attempt at word games is rather pathetic.

Of course not, it's far superior to the chitauri that defeated the Hulk.

Josh_Alexander Keeper of Cosmic Balance

Originally posted by Silent Master
The bridge is what was powering the Bi-Frost, that is why I called it the Bi-Frost explosion. That is what everyone calls it. your little attempt at word games is rather pathetic.
Of course not, it's far superior to the chitauri that defeated the Hulk.

Your excuses are pathetic. Know how to differenciate!

Where is the evidence?

It just looks like a shock wave. The light it releases seems harmless. Since it is the same fuel that the Bifrost uses then it is harmless.

Else Thor and other beings would melt when being transported via the Bifrost.

Point being, Bifrost Explosion is harmless.

Silent Master Senior Member

I get it, you know that it's far superior to anything the Hulk withstood, so all you're left with is low-balling.

Josh_Alexander Keeper of Cosmic Balance

Originally posted by Silent Master
I get it, you know that it's far superior to anything the Hulk withstood, so all you're left with is low-balling.

Hahaha if you knew what you were talking about youd know that the Bifrost isnt a weapon but a transportation machine.

The energy it releases (That rainbow beam you see everytime it is used) isnt harmful!.

Evidence: https://youtu.be/XlbhuOdMOQw

If such beam would be harmful then Jane wouldnt have been able to travel to Asgard.

The Fuel that triggers the Bifrost is that same energy. When the bifrost bridge exploded it was that energy the one being released.

The Bifrost Bride explosion isnt as harmful it seems. It was just a release of such energy along with a shockwave!

Doesnt mean Thor can withstand a Chitauri bomb.

But dont worry! Isnt like am gonna judge you for not being informed.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Dayman
Quan, again, Thor was previously KO'd from the obedience disk, Hulks super jump punch didnt Ko Thor.
The obedience disk AND super Hulks punch KO'd Thor.
Ive watched this fight 30 times, both were punches.
So all 100 people who agree Thor wins are WRONG and you and that Josh clown are the only two right?

The scene clearly shows the disc didn't ko him it was the jump punch. The disc didn't ko Loki either. The disc immobilized him. Loki had it left on for quite a considerable time.

I've seen it twice so I haven't illegally watched it. I'm going to watch it a third time.

Thor doesn't win nor has he won so just because the majority of posters on this site feel one way has no bearing on the evidence. Hulk wins. Physically a beast and he can take what Thor can dish out.