Quinlan Vos (Dark Disciple) vs. TCW Darth Maul

Battle takes place on neutral ground

Who wins?

Darth Maul.

If it's the Vos that defeated Dooku, he wins, in my opinion.

Originally posted by |King Joker|
If it's the Vos that defeated Dooku, he wins, in my opinion.

No, he isn't.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Abc logic and Maul is greater than Dooku anyways.

Yeah, Maul.

Vos wins, imo. I think he's stronger in sabers and, while maul could be better in the force, i think the tha gap between the two in sabers is wider than the gap between the two in the force, thus quinlan Vos should win a majority here

So you're suggesting that Vos can do the sabers-equivalent of ragdolling to Maul? lol

Nope, i just think Vos is fast/durable enough to dodge/tank most of maul's force attacks and strong enough with a lightsaber to defeat the sith in a duel. If Vos could do it during his fight with dooku, i don't see why he can't do the same to a opponent who should be weaker than tyranus,imo.

How does he dodge being gripped?

Kind of a false equivalent given that we haven't seen Maul, enhanced by Force Rage, taking it to Dooku. But given that it was both that enhancement and Vos' unpredictability (one of the core traits involved in using Juyo), I'd be comfortable suggesting Maul could do the same. Which isn't to say either would take a majority over Dooku but it wouldn't be impossible for either to win, either.

Maul > Dooku in close combat.

In some ways. Dooku boasts his own advantages as well.

Originally posted by ILS
Yeah, Maul.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Maul > Dooku in close combat.

Possibly But Dooku's the superior fencer. Plus given his superior Tk, he should take Maul for a large majority.

Not sure about Maul vs Vos yet. Have to finish Dark Disciple first.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Possibly But Dooku's the superior fencer. Plus given his superior Tk, he should take Maul for a large majority.

Originally posted by ILS
The gap in their saber skill is about as noticeable as their gap in telekinesis,

Which is pretty noticeable if we use Kenobi as the measuring stick. Unless you go by the whole Juyo > Djem So > Makashi > Soresu = Juyo/Djem So.

Wait. People have Maul>DD Vos now?

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Wait. People have Maul>DD Vos now?

Always have, here.

The people that didn't were mostly those who didn't read the novel, or were trolling.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Always have, here.

The people that didn't were mostly those who didn't read the novel, or were trolling.