Originally posted by EmperorSidious2No, movies only. She is master of books not films.
Yet have to follow the guidelines of the books and the writers wishes. She has complete creative control and she made sure they stayed with her vision. So while not every detail on the book is in the movie not every detail can be in the movies as movies can only be so long.She says and I quote a muggle with a shotgun can defeat a wizard. That really is her saying that these wizards while powerful aren't immortal by birth and don't have any superhuman abilities. However if the two encountered one another that doesn't mean the muggle wins. What if the person disapparates or turns invisible or just turns the gun into something else or uses some other random spell. This location also helps snape as he knows it better than khan.
Khan is a futuristic superhuman with weaponry that would scare Snape. Khan wins, easily.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
Actually what she says is very relevenT as she is the creator of Harry Potter. Feats do matter but what she says is more important as she is the creator. The rest I agree with in this paragraph.
What she says matters, but not in any actual debate here. Feats matter..the author making a statement is not really a feat. If she says something and yet a feat contradicts it...the feat would be used here, not her statement.
Actually their are certain little clues she leaves in the books and the movies like how he dresses for instance.
Wizards in general dress very strangely in comparison to humans though. Dumbledore is *nowhere* near the only person said to be wearing a silly outfit. Hell Lun'a Dad wore ridiculous stuff too.
Also his relationship with grindlewald for him was a love relationship. He loved him. He felt they were more than besties.
Again, nothing confirmed this though. It makes every bit of sense they would form a strong friendship. Dumbledore was very talented and had a big future, but his mother dies so he ends up putting it on hold to take care of his sister. He probably resented that..and then here comes someone who is just as much a genius as Dumbledore..and also the same age. Of course they became close. It doesn't mean they had a gay relationship.
Knitting patterns and the way he dresses, what other wizard dresses that is a man dresses like that.
Knitting patterns don't prove anything. A variety of wizards show a fascination with aspects of human culture they do not understand.
Also unless I am mistaken..Dumbledore only really mentions this in the 6th book. Specifically as to the reason why he was in the bathroom so long at Slughorn's. But see..he had really stayed in the bathroom a long time because he wanted Harry's presence to convince Slughorn to come back to Hogwarts. So it's quite possible Dumbledore just made up an excuse on the fly based on stuff he saw on muggle magazines in the bathroom.
Lucius doesn't and he's rich. Arthur doesn't, Kingsley has his uniform but has a natural hat that covers his bald head and really wears blue with purple which matches. Harry doesn't. Ron doesnt. Neville Seamus dean, Fred, George, Dobby, Draco, moody, lupin, Sirius, snape, flitwick, don't. So really those are more hints as really toward the end of his life j would say he was asexual.
Okay except if you read the books you'd be quite aware of the strange way certain wizards have dressed. It has *never* just been Dumbledore that Harry notices is dressed all crazy.
No point in mentioning Dobby, he isn't even a wizard. Harry doesn't see Neville, Seamus, Draco, or even Snape outside of Hogwarts usually..where there is an actual dress code.
So since the knitting pattern thing was just an excuse as to why Dumbledore left Harry with Slughorn too long..and nothing specifically said about his relationship with Grindelwald implies they are gay..the only thing you really have is the way he dresses..and again: if you have read the books you will know that Dumbledore is not the only wizard Harry has seen dressed very strangely. You named some main characters and they might not dress like that, but plenty of no name background wizards Harry has seen..have been observed wearing strange things.
So even if you wanted to say yes he does dress stranger then anyone else..that is the only thing that potentially stands out that you could for sure say might suggest something, but that isn't enough. Since as I said, the knitting pattern thing is problematic and his having a close friendship with another male is no different then Harry and Ron's relationship or the Marauders relationship.
I'm not saying Dumbledore can't be gay..but that I just never once read anything he did and thought "yeah..he seems gay".
Originally posted by quanchi112
No, movies only. She is master of books not films.Khan is a futuristic superhuman with weaponry that would scare Snape. Khan wins, easily.
She is the master of Harry Potter. Including the movies. They follow what she wants. She holds complete creative control and hand picked the producers to stay within her guide lines.
Snape has faced scarier. His name is VOLDEMORT. Snape doesn't just get scarred. Also with the environment to help and his versatility, snape stomps.
Originally posted by Surtur
What she says matters, but not in any actual debate here. Feats matter..the author making a statement is not really a feat. If she says something and yet a feat contradicts it...the feat would be used here, not her statement.Wizards in general dress very strangely in comparison to humans though. Dumbledore is *nowhere* near the only person said to be wearing a silly outfit. Hell Lun'a Dad wore ridiculous stuff too.
Again, nothing confirmed this though. It makes every bit of sense they would form a strong friendship. Dumbledore was very talented and had a big future, but his mother dies so he ends up putting it on hold to take care of his sister. He probably resented that..and then here comes someone who is just as much a genius as Dumbledore..and also the same age. Of course they became close. It doesn't mean they had a gay relationship.
Knitting patterns don't prove anything. A variety of wizards show a fascination with aspects of human culture they do not understand.
Also unless I am mistaken..Dumbledore only really mentions this in the 6th book. Specifically as to the reason why he was in the bathroom so long at Slughorn's. But see..he had really stayed in the bathroom a long time because he wanted Harry's presence to convince Slughorn to come back to Hogwarts. So it's quite possible Dumbledore just made up an excuse on the fly based on stuff he saw on muggle magazines in the bathroom.
Okay except if you read the books you'd be quite aware of the strange way certain wizards have dressed. It has *never* just been Dumbledore that Harry notices is dressed all crazy.
No point in mentioning Dobby, he isn't even a wizard. Harry doesn't see Neville, Seamus, Draco, or even Snape outside of Hogwarts usually..where there is an actual dress code.
So since the knitting pattern thing was just an excuse as to why Dumbledore left Harry with Slughorn too long..and nothing specifically said about his relationship with Grindelwald implies they are gay..the only thing you really have is the way he dresses..and again: if you have read the books you will know that Dumbledore is not the only wizard Harry has seen dressed very strangely. You named some main characters and they might not dress like that, but plenty of no name background wizards Harry has seen..have been observed wearing strange things.
So even if you wanted to say yes he does dress stranger then anyone else..that is the only thing that potentially stands out that you could for sure say might suggest something, but that isn't enough. Since as I said, the knitting pattern thing is problematic and his having a close friendship with another male is no different then Harry and Ron's relationship or the Marauders relationship.
I'm not saying Dumbledore can't be gay..but that I just never once read anything he did and thought "yeah..he seems gay".
The relationship dumbledore and grindlewald had wasn't physical. It was however dumbledore had massive emotional feelings for grindlewald. However these feelings weren't shared by grindlewald at least not at that point due to wanting power. Research Dumbledore and grindlewald. Then look at the link where it says jk Rowling elaborates on grindlewald and dumbledore relationship and you will find questions she has answered showing the confirmation dumbledore felt that way for grindlewald.
Ok one thing I want you to realize. We are both human. They are wizards. The two have completely different style of dress and fashion sense. Luna's dad is Luna's dad. Luna has the nickname lunny lovegood. He's the father so yea he's going to wear certain clothing. However again I reserve that he's asexual and he just likes the colors that he wears.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2She isn't the director and the films are only based off the books. No, the director has ultimate say so regarding the films.
She is the master of Harry Potter. Including the movies. They follow what she wants. She holds complete creative control and hand picked the producers to stay within her guide lines.Snape has faced scarier. His name is VOLDEMORT. Snape doesn't just get scarred. Also with the environment to help and his versatility, snape stomps.
Snape was scared of voldemort as well. Snape would be scared of Khan as well. Khan shoots him and he dies. You ignore your own writer proving you're a hypocrite. Awesome.
Originally posted by quanchi112
She isn't the director and the films are only based off the books. No, the director has ultimate say so regarding the films.Snape was scared of voldemort as well. Snape would be scared of Khan as well. Khan shoots him and he dies. You ignore your own writer proving you're a hypocrite. Awesome.
The director follows her wishes. Based off the books. Glad you admit it. Thus you agree that she has the ultimate say due to the films being based off the books.
He never showed his fear. He was able to conceal it to the point he was able to use occlumency so well he was able to basically be in VOLDEMORTs face and VOLDEMORTs never knew he was spying for the other team. I'm not ignoring her.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2Books only her opinion counts for her work but not in the films.
The director follows her wishes. Based off the books. Glad you admit it. Thus you agree that she has the ultimate say due to the films being based off the books.He never showed his fear. He was able to conceal it to the point he was able to use occlumency so well he was able to basically be in VOLDEMORTs face and VOLDEMORTs never knew he was spying for the other team. I'm not ignoring her.
He was scared shitless of him. We see it in multiple scenes. Voldemort never found out but he also killed him.
Khan wins.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Books only her opinion counts for her work but not in the films.He was scared shitless of him. We see it in multiple scenes. Voldemort never found out but he also killed him.
Khan wins.
Films based off her work and she retains complete creative control and was a producer for the last few films.
So someone who can walk into his presence and no show any sign of emotion. He walks in there and sits a seat away and talks to him like he would anyone else you call that shared shitless. Yea he killed him becuSe he was stupid thinking that by killing snape he got the elder wand. Snape lied to him.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2Producer doesn't mean director and movie feats only so it doesn't matter. He looked scared like they all did. Snape didn't even try to fight back and just went to his death like a coward.
Films based off her work and she retains complete creative control and was a producer for the last few films.So someone who can walk into his presence and no show any sign of emotion. He walks in there and sits a seat away and talks to him like he would anyone else you call that shared shitless. Yea he killed him becuSe he was stupid thinking that by killing snape he got the elder wand. Snape lied to him.
Voldemort owned Snape.
😂
Originally posted by quanchi112
Producer doesn't mean director and movie feats only so it doesn't matter. He looked scared like they all did. Snape didn't even try to fight back and just went to his death like a coward.Voldemort owned Snape.
😂
Producer still big part of movie. Also having creative control 100% is also important. Her opinion and her staement and everything is worth more than you. He had the same face he and at hogwarts. He was keeping his cover he wdidnt want to blow it. Then what would have been the point. Voldmert woudl have beaten him. Also changed your mind ever since the Yoda vs dumbledore debate huh 😂
Snape lied and deceived voldemrt so bad. Snape was the best of the death eaters besides voldemrt.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2Director is the one with power over the scenes. No, movie feats only. Snape was so scared he didn't even do something natural; self defense.
Producer still big part of movie. Also having creative control 100% is also important. Her opinion and her staement and everything is worth more than you. He had the same face he and at hogwarts. He was keeping his cover he wdidnt want to blow it. Then what would have been the point. Voldmert woudl have beaten him. Also changed your mind ever since the Yoda vs dumbledore debate huh 😂Snape lied and deceived voldemrt so bad. Snape was the best of the death eaters besides voldemrt.
Voldemort still killed him. 😂
Albus was already dead, too.
😂
Originally posted by quanchi112
Director is the one with power over the scenes. No, movie feats only. Snape was so scared he didn't even do something natural; self defense.Voldemort still killed him. 😂
Albus was already dead, too.
😂
Director listens to her. She decides what happens or not. Just like in the last movie, she changed an entire scene so it woudl match the books.
He was stupid for doing so? Just like he is about everything else. Why he lost to a baby.
Now Voldemrt is dead. Albums is better than voldemrt. Better feats, better approval, better legacy and better everything else.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2Prove it but movies feats only. Mother protected the Baby. You know nothing about Harry Potter since you don't know the context. 😂
Director listens to her. She decides what happens or not. Just like in the last movie, she changed an entire scene so it woudl match the books.He was stupid for doing so? Just like he is about everything else. Why he lost to a baby.
Now Voldemrt is dead. Albums is better than voldemrt. Better feats, better approval, better legacy and better everything else.
Voldemort out lived Albus. 😂
Voldemort had far greater feats than Albus. Loser.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Prove it but movies feats only. Mother protected the Baby. You know nothing about Harry Potter since you don't know the context. 😂Voldemort out lived Albus. 😂
Voldemort had far greater feats than Albus. Loser.
Look at the battle between mcgonagall and Snape. The director wanted it to be a battle for Harry for another emotional barrier for him. However Rowling said no, it would be a battle with mcginall and Snape. I know way more about Harry Potter than you do. You haven't even read the books.
Who lived longer and who went missing first? 😂
Nah dumbledore and much better feats.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2That isn't proving it. You're just ranting without evidence. You said a baby beat Voldemort. You're a noob.
Look at the battle between mcgonagall and Snape. The director wanted it to be a battle for Harry for another emotional barrier for him. However Rowling said no, it would be a battle with mcginall and Snape. I know way more about Harry Potter than you do. You haven't even read the books.Who lived longer and who went missing first? 😂
Nah dumbledore and much better feats.
Voldemort lived longer.
Nah, Voldemort does. 💃
Originally posted by quanchi112
That isn't proving it. You're just ranting without evidence. You said a baby beat Voldemort. You're a noob.Voldemort lived longer.
Nah, Voldemort does. 💃
https://youtu.be/Lnb-XIZwbY0 I believe this is what you were looking for. Starting at 6:40 mark and got to 7:48 mark
71 years is less than 115 year
No proof and really it's all opinion. So it comes down to popular opinion. Popular opinion goes with dumbledore.