Rebels Ashoka Tano vs Darth Vader season 2 prediction

Originally posted by DarthAnt66


Neither circumstances give Vader, who is easily among the most powerful Sith in history (top ten), a pass.

In other words: poor performance. 👆

[/b]
That changes the fact it was a poor performance? 😂

[/b]
This argument is so retarded I don't think a response is even in order. [/B]

His fight against Sha Koon was long before his prime, and while he was adapting to his suit (in fact, at the beginning of his career, his style was noted as being clumsy and consisting mostly of vertical strikes). And we know that he practiced his lightsaber skill during his decades as a Sith. As for his performance on Kessel, keep in mind that one of those Jedi was one of the best Morgukai warriors (which are "peerless" duelists to begin with), and was best known as a Jedi for his combat skill. I wouldn't call these poor performances, especially given the circumstances.

After reading TFU 2 My opinion of Vader has gone up as a duelist. It's implied he held back a little, and The clone was going all out and only was losing sabers and only won due to overloading an opening in his armor with lightning. Vader improved since the firs book and he legit outskilled the clone.

I'm not sure whose more skilled between Galen and SK though

Originally posted by redpill
wasn't dooku defeated by maul as well?

Nope. They never faced each other in combat.

So that's a strange rumour to try and spread.

Originally posted by carthage
After reading TFU 2 My opinion of Vader has gone up as a duelist. It's implied he held back a little, and The clone was going all out and only was losing sabers and only won due to overloading an opening in his armor with lightning. Vader improved since the firs book and he legit outskilled the clone.

I'm not sure whose more skilled between Galen and SK though

I think Galen and SK were pretty equal. Btw according to Sam Witwer, yes Vader was holding back. He wanted to be captured to find all the Rebels. This would have become apparent in the TFU3 which never happened.

Originally posted by Darth Thor

I think Galen and SK were pretty equal. Btw according to Sam Witwer, yes Vader was holding back. He wanted to be captured to find all the Rebels. This would have become apparent in the TFU3 which never happened.

Interesting, could you please post the source?

Originally posted by Nargaroth
Interesting, could you please post the source?

http://geeknation.com/podcasts/far-far-away-episode-viii-sam-witwer/

Starts from 1:20:40

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Nope. They never faced each other in combat.

So that's a strange rumour to try and spread.

I think Galen and SK were pretty equal. Btw according to Sam Witwer, yes Vader was holding back. He wanted to be captured to find all the Rebels. This would have become apparent in the TFU3 which never happened.

Well its impressive given how much SK improved during the course of TFU 1, he was beating council members and the clone admitted he improved in TFU 2. If Vader had improved as stated in the novel/and was driving him back it'd mean ANH Vader as a whole was pretty skilled, let alone how much better he would've been as of ROTJ.

For the meantime Legends Vader >> Canon Vader in lightsaber skill imo