Dooku, Maul, Talzin vs Sidious and Grievous

in SoD, Maul convinces Dooku to join him and Talzin to defeat their former master.

Fight takes place in a hanger bay somewhere; not on Dathomir

Round 1: everyone's stats is as of SoD
Round 2: RotJ Sidious

Team Maul stomps.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Team Maul stomps.

If it's not on datomir, then it's harder to judge. Talzin was really only able to take him on due to her being amped by the planet. However it all depends on what Dooku can make up for in the force. Not being on Dathomir Sidious can defeat anyone here, by themselves. Hard to say but,

Round 1. Team with extreme difficulty.

Round 2. Sidious. His power grew after ROTS.

Talzin holds off Sidious whilst Dooku and Maul annihilate Grievous so badly that Bane smiles from the depths of my waste container.

Team Talzin

Team Talzin.

This isn't close. Talzin alone can take Sidious on.

so badly that Bane smiles from the depths of my waste container.

Originally posted by quanchi112
This isn't close. Talzin alone can take Sidious on.

Uh, no she can't.

Team 1 wins though.

Originally posted by ares834
Uh, no she can't.

Team 1 wins though.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Team Talzin

Originally posted by quanchi112
Her appearances say otherwise. She took on Sidious and Dooku. He also took on Windu alone. Windu is the same guy who defeated Sidious.

Nope. She was losing to Sidious... We see him push forward while she falls back. It’s only after that that Dooku begins to help.

Sidious is superior to Talzin.

Originally posted by ares834
Nope. She was losing to Sidious... We see him push forward while she falls back. It’s only after that that Dooku begins to help.

Sidious is superior to Talzin.

Based on nothing. Sidious lost to Windu. Who defeated Talzin one on one ?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Her appearances say otherwise. She took on Sidious and Dooku. He also took on Windu alone. Windu is the same guy who defeated Sidious.

It was on Dathomir, the place that is called "the hearth of Mother Talzin's powers" or smth like that. She was amped, which enabled hed to fight Sidious equally. On neutral ground she's inferior to him.

Anyway, Grievous is inferior to any combatant on the battlefield, and I doubt that Sidious will be able to protect him all the time. The only one here that wont stomp Grievous here is Maul (still, Maul will comfortable beat him).
If Grievous fall, before Sidious will eliminate anyone from team 1, Sidious will be stomped.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Completely false. If he was pushing her back then Dooku's aid would have spelled instant doom. They also needed Grievous to kill her which confirms she isn't someone Sheev can handle alone.

Nope.

And nope.

If you actually read the comic you would have seen Talzin getting pushed back and Sidious moving forward.

No, not really.

Yes, really.

Third and fourth panel.

Indicate nothing. It's just perspective. I can't see anything indicating Sidious is moving forward and Talzin back. In fact a few panels later and she's leaning really far forward.

No, it’s not perspective. Look at the top panel. It’s from virtually the same perspective as the fourth. Talzin is forced back and Sidious appears to be almost lunging forward.