Originally posted by quanchi112
So you don't know hence destroying your own point.Ridiculous. Sidious gets wrecked.
I said no one knows how much. My point was she would be weaker than she was in SOD which she would be. She was powerful enough to contend with Sidious by herself. That means she won't be at that power here seeing as she isn't on Dathomir. So really Maul isn't even an issue. He will be ragdolled, or blitzed by Sidious, or if it goes Dooku and Talzin vs Sidious with Maul fighting Grevious, who either wins, Dooku would take down Grevious, and Dooku woudl take down maul. So it will be a Dooku and Talzin vs Sidious. They aren't on Dathomir, so it all comes down to do you think Dooku can make up the gap of power between Sidious and Talzin. It's to close and there's a possibility that Maul woudl give his energy to Talzin, so it's that vs Sidious. It would be close but the team would takeit after a hard fought battle.
Uhh no. By ROTJ he became much more powerful than his ROTS incarnation, which could stalemate or push(depending on how you take the comic)Talzin , he's much more powerful than he was then. He would defintily take maul out quickly. Dooku seeing the importance of winning wouldn't waste time and would take Grevious out with force. So now once again it's Sidious vs Talzin and Dooku. Not being on Dathomir it's entirely possible Sidious could steamroll Dooku, possibly, but even then he could still take down the team, by seperating them, as he's much more powerful now.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2So you don't have any proof and just speculate. Maul was a rival stated by Sheev. She was weakened and still took him on.
I said no one knows how much. My point was she would be weaker than she was in SOD which she would be. She was powerful enough to contend with Sidious by herself. That means she won't be at that power here seeing as she isn't on Dathomir. So really Maul isn't even an issue. He will be ragdolled, or blitzed by Sidious, or if it goes Dooku and Talzin vs Sidious with Maul fighting Grevious, who either wins, Dooku would take down Grevious, and Dooku woudl take down maul. So it will be a Dooku and Talzin vs Sidious. They aren't on Dathomir, so it all comes down to do you think Dooku can make up the gap of power between Sidious and Talzin. It's to close and there's a possibility that Maul woudl give his energy to Talzin, so it's that vs Sidious. It would be close but the team would takeit after a hard fought battle.Uhh no. By ROTJ he became much more powerful than his ROTS incarnation, which could stalemate or push(depending on how you take the comic)Talzin , he's much more powerful than he was then. He would defintily take maul out quickly. Dooku seeing the importance of winning wouldn't waste time and would take Grevious out with force. So now once again it's Sidious vs Talzin and Dooku. Not being on Dathomir it's entirely possible Sidious could steamroll Dooku, possibly, but even then he could still take down the team, by seperating them, as he's much more powerful now.
In rotj he was unable to defend himself from a one armed cyborg tossing him to his death. 😂
Team Maul wins.
Originally posted by quanchi112
So you don't have any proof and just speculate. Maul was a rival stated by Sheev. She was weakened and still took him on.In rotj he was unable to defend himself from a one armed cyborg tossing him to his death. 😂
Team Maul wins.
Of how much. It's factually proven she would be weaker, just the amount is unknown. Prove she was weakened post exactly where it says she was weakened.
Irrelevant. He gained more power as of ROTJ
They take round 1, but not round 2
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2She was weaker when she faced Sheev. Was she in dathomir when she faced Windu ?
Of how much. It's factually proven she would be weaker, just the amount is unknown. Prove she was weakened post exactly where it says she was weakened.Irrelevant. He gained more power as of ROTJ
They take round 1, but not round 2
Based on what ? He looked bad in the film. Luke walked away like nothing.
Nah.
Originally posted by quanchi112
She was weaker when she faced Sheev. Was she in dathomir when she faced Windu ?Based on what ? He looked bad in the film. Luke walked away like nothing.
Nah.
You would have to prove she was weaker. I've read the comic and it says it was possible she was weakened. It never says she was in fact weakened, only the possibility. No they were not on Dathomir when Windu and Talzin fought.
Again inconsistent. Sidious will take down the team in round 1 since now he's going for kill. You yourself admitted ROTJ is a stronger form. Also Vader is confirmed to be more powerful than Dooku who had trouble with ROTS Sidious. Vader needed help to beat ROTJ Sidious. Sidious grew in power.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2So at no point was she mentioned as being amped. So outside of her nexus she stalemated the guy who bested Windu in sabers.
You would have to prove she was weaker. I've read the comic and it says it was possible she was weakened. It never says she was in fact weakened, only the possibility. No they were not on Dathomir when Windu and Talzin fought.Again inconsistent. Sidious will take down the team in round 1 since now he's going for kill. You yourself admitted ROTJ is a stronger form. Also Vader is confirmed to be more powerful than Dooku who had trouble with ROTS Sidious. Vader needed help to beat ROTJ Sidious. Sidious grew in power.
Nah. That's your logic and his fl in that movie is laughable. Dooku never fought Sidious. Vader turned on him and ended him with one hand and no saber.
Windu owns Palps all day long. Anakin isn't here to save him.