Most consistent Ligtsaber duelist

Started by carthage3 pages

Most consistent Ligtsaber duelist

In canon or Legends some Lightsaber wielders perform well under any set of circumstances. What duelist in your opinion has the least amount of inconsistent feats, or seems to have no low showings altogether. How have they managed to maintain their record, whether by skill, physical advantages, or being unrivaled by others?

Yoda, I guess.

Probably Yoda, yeah.

Yea Yoda

Mace Windu

Originally posted by Darth Abonis
Mace Windu

It's possible, but most would disagree. His performances are generally a mixed bag, varying from dueling Sidious to struggling with underlings like Sora Bulq or Assaj Ventress. How much of that can be attributed to holding back is anybody's guess.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
It's possible, but most would disagree. His performances are generally a mixed bag, varying from dueling Sidious to struggling with underlings like Sora Bulq or Assaj Ventress. How much of that can be attributed to holding back is anybody's guess.

Mace standing as an equal to Sidious was through his Vaapad amp.

Originally posted by TheNuisanceBird
Mace standing as an equal to Sidious was through his Vaapad amp.

An amp that he would theoretically receive in any of the aforementioned duels. Even assuming that it's mechanics are related to the force strength of the opponent, chalking an entire duel up to the unquantifiable advantages of his form is kinda amateurish.

Not that it really impedes my point either way, given that regardless of physical augmentation, he still matched Palpatine's skill.

Agreed, Mace is not the most consistent.

Darth Krayt/A'Sharad Hett is pretty consistent, he didn't have any just crappy days that I can think of.

Sidious?

Originally posted by NewGuy01
An amp that he would theoretically receive in any of the aforementioned duels. Even assuming that it's mechanics are related to the force strength of the opponent, chalking an entire duel up to the unquantifiable advantages of his form is kinda amateurish.
Mace's emotional state led him to become far more deeply immersed in Vaapad that seemingly before as well.

Pretty much, if you gotta discuss someone's amps vs non amps? They aren't the most consistent.

Mace never lost a duel though afaik.

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Mace never lost a duel though afaik.

That doesn't make him consistent. He gets stalemated by some relatively minor duelists, and then he almost beats Sidious.

Originally posted by Q99
That doesn't make him consistent. He gets stalemated by some relatively minor duelists, and then he almost beats Sidious.

Sora minor? 😕

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Sora minor? 😕

Compared to everyone else yes.

Sora Bulq is one the greatest lightsaber instructors in the Jedi Order's history, and was one of the few individuals capable of "mastering" Vaapad (which he also helped to create.)

He is pretty high profile.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Sora Bulq is one the greatest lightsaber instructors in the Jedi Order's history, and was one of the few individuals capable of "mastering" Vaapad (which he also helped to create.)

He is pretty high profile.

That's a rather vague terms since several masters are given that title. Still notable accolade though.


Darth Krayt/A'Sharad Hett is pretty consistent, he didn't have any just crappy days that I can think of.

Sidious?

Well, he did, but there were reasons for it.

I might say Sidious too, but undoubtedly someone's going to either bring up Luke in DE or Mace in RotS, and I really don't have the patience for another one of those debates.

Dooku.

Originally posted by Syndicate
Dooku.

I was going to say him but then I thought he lost to quin Lin Vos.