Most consistent Ligtsaber duelist

Started by Darth Thor3 pages

Good analysis.

You missed out Grievous and Maul, which also fit your theory.

Originally posted by McP
Hard to tell. Sora also pushed Mace onto wall.

The difference being that when Mace got Force-pushed he immediately bounced back. When Bulq was on the receiving end he was KO'd or at least stunned.

Big difference.

Originally posted by McP
Besides that, Mace agreed with Sora that a real battle was not between them both, so Bulq could be conscious. Not sure however, that's just one of many possibilities.

There is room for interpretation, granted, but I'm pretty sure that was just Mace thinking aloud. I find it hard to imagine that Bulq would just stand there and allow Mace to go off to save Jeisel and K'Kruhk (yes I know he boasted that whoever won Mace's mission would fail but that was just hot air), meaning that he was at least dazed for a few moments.

Originally posted by McP
Yeah, might be true. But on the other hand, hard to tell if she would be killed, if Dooku's body would be mortally wounded. If not, then she could assault Sidious without even trying to defend herself. Also, Sidious didn't want to kill Dooku in that fight, so she also had some advantages. There is so many things to analyse in that fight.

Very true.

Originally posted by McP

Perhaps. Or perhaps he didn't teach Grievous how to fight Makashi's user properly (that's unlikely since Grievous did well against Shaak Ti - however I consider it as opposite to canon since I prefer Luceno's version - more stable, consistent and in my opinion just much better then Tartakovky's CW).

I will note in the Tartakovky Grievous vs Shaak Ti fight, she'd been chasing him for like 10 minutes and took on over a dozen Magnadroids, sustaining a number of wounds in the process before he went to take her on.

If she was at even 60% of her full, I'd be surprised.

Kinda like how in SoD, he send four magnadroids to tire Maul before facing him, and that apparently had some effect even though it was a mere 4.

Originally posted by Q99
I will note in the Tartakovky Grievous vs Shaak Ti fight, she'd been chasing him for like 10 minutes and took on over a dozen Magnadroids, sustaining a number of wounds in the process before he went to take her on.

If she was at even 60% of her full, I'd be surprised.

Kinda like how in SoD, he send four magnadroids to tire Maul before facing him, and that apparently had some effect even though it was a mere 4.

Grievous himself comments "you're tired Jedi."

Vader's consistent in struggling against featless Jedi 🙂

Originally posted by SunRazer
Vader's consistent in struggling against featless Jedi 🙂

To be fair being "feat-less" doesn't necessarily make them inferior. It just means they haven't had the chance to show what they're capable of.

Originally posted by Q99
I will note in the Tartakovky Grievous vs Shaak Ti fight, she'd been chasing him for like 10 minutes and took on over a dozen Magnadroids, sustaining a number of wounds in the process before he went to take her on.

If she was at even 60% of her full, I'd be surprised.

Kinda like how in SoD, he send four magnadroids to tire Maul before facing him, and that apparently had some effect even though it was a mere 4.

👆

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
i feel like the most consistent duelist is probably Obi

That's a Bantha-level comment right there.

Originally posted by chilled monkey
To be fair being "feat-less" doesn't necessarily make them inferior. It just means they haven't had the chance to show what they're capable of.

One thing I do like in the new canon is it lacks the many, many 'unknown Jedi faces Vader puts up a good fight,' examples.

The only Jedi that Vader have faced outside the movies is Kanan.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Kenobi's certainly not the most consistent fighter.
It's Vader who was inconsistent.

Darth Sidious.