Originally posted by Bentley
Yeah, but every Death Star has been pwned by ships that are incredibly inferior to the fleets Startrek has to offer. They are powerful but they are sitting ducks. The fact that they keep rebuilding the Death Star everytime should tell you how above average it is compared to conventional weaponry.Can you even shield against teleporting in the SW universe?
But does Star Trek even have ships capable of pulling off the shots needed to blow up the Death Star? They don't use smaller ships like X-Wings.
Originally posted by quanchi112
See what I mean. A few posters act like Star Trek has this in the bag then you saying Trek probably won't win. Darth Thor continues to be absent like some Luke Skywalker coward.
Sheer scale issue. The battle of coruscant has more ships and firepower than anything shown in ST so far which is why I say the new movie needs a large scale battle to even things up.
Should be said that ST would totally annihilate SW in an all out.
^ Huh? I have no interest in this kind of battle. Star Trek can win this one, I'm really not bothered. And contrary to what you(Quan) might think, I actually am a fan of Abrams Star Trek. More so than Abrams Star Wars tbh.
I just argue against your lowballing of the elite Jedi/Sith, and your overstating of NuKhan.
If you want to do a Khan vs Ahsoka battlezone (or something similar) then you can PM me, as I don't see most your posts. In terms of a Ship to Ship battles I'll take on Vader in his Tie Fighter vs pretty much anyone else in any ship, as long as it's one on one and within reason (Like not Q, or some random Trek episode where someone's controlling a completely Invincible Ship).
Originally posted by jaden101
Sheer scale issue. The battle of coruscant has more ships and firepower than anything shown in ST so far which is why I say the new movie needs a large scale battle to even things up.Should be said that ST would totally annihilate SW in an all out.
I grew up and Star Trek has a very 1960s sensibility of who has the bigger ship usually wins, right? And if you look at it, the attack, these ships are 40 feet long. And but there’s like 4,000 of them. And so I think even in the way they’re being encountered and how people are coming is it’s you can’t help but, I mean, we live in a world that is ever evolving. And I think that that’s always made Star Trek sci-fi great is when you’re able to at least acknowledge what’s happening today.
Taken from an interview online. We can see from the preview they attack earth as well. This will more than likely give trek the scale you believe has been missing.