Best lightsaber fighter in Star Wars

Started by FrothByte6 pages

Best lightsaber fighter in Star Wars

For this thread, let's stick to ONLY the 7 movies of Star Wars. If the fighters weren't allowed to use the force and were restricted to purely sword fighting, how would the rankings go? Fighters are:

Darth Sidius
Darth Vader (as per Episode VI)
Darth Maul
Kylo Ren
Count Dooku
General Grevious
Anakin (Pre-Vader as per Episode III)
Obi Wan
Qui Gon
Yoda
Mace Windu
Rey

Please feel free to include anyone else I missed.

Mace or Yoda... If made to choose... yoda I suppose

iirc, Mace was touted as the most skilled Jedi with a sabre in the PT. Obi's comment to Anakin that if he had trained and focused more he'd rival Mace's sabre-skills and have Yoda's wisdom, can't recall it verbatim, but it was something to that effect. Was in epII.

Obi Wan.. he's got the best track record out of all of these guys...beat 2 Sith Lords and General Grievous

Windu is número uno.

1. Sidious/Yoda
2.Darth Vader
3. Dooku/Windu/Anakin
4.Obi Wan
5. maul
6. grevious
7. Qui Gon
8. Kylo Ren
9. Rey

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
Sidious or Yoda
Windu defeated Sidious. Yoda lost. Horrible list, sport.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
1. Sidious/Yoda
2.Darth Vader
3. Dooku/Windu/Anakin
4.Obi Wan
5. maul
6. grevious
7. Qui Gon
8. Kylo Ren
9. Rey

Curious why you'd put Obi Wan over Maul?

Originally posted by Robtard
iirc, Mace was touted as the most skilled Jedi with a sabre in the PT. Obi's comment to Anakin that if he had trained and focused more he'd rival Mace's sabre-skills and have Yoda's wisdom, can't recall it verbatim, but it was something to that effect. Was in epII.

https://youtu.be/IdSUKIFnYc8. 2:13-2:19

Originally posted by FrothByte
Curious why you'd put Obi Wan over Maul?

There really close TBH but I think Obi Wan with his defensive form and calmer mind and the fact he was able to take on an enraged Anakin however with circumstances backing him, I think he can take maul. Especially since as a Padawan he was able to hold his own without his amyser, he only got better as of ROTS.

What does your list look like?

Looks like the copy/paste broke the link

Originally posted by Robtard
Looks like the copy/paste broke the link

Darn, but Obi wan remarked if Anakin practiced more he would rival Yoda. Sorry for the Inconvenience.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
There really close TBH but I think Obi Wan with his defensive form and calmer mind and the fact he was able to take on an enraged Anakin however with circumstances backing him, I think he can take maul. Especially since as a Padawan he was able to hold his own without his amyser, he only got better as of ROTS.
Maul bested him in the clone wars series and was always portrayed as superior to Kenobi. Maul got overconfident in APM. That's all.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Maul bested him in the clone wars series and was always portrayed as superior to Kenobi. Maul got overconfident in APM. That's all.

In the OP he said let's stick with just the seven movies, but even with TCW Obi wan took on maul evenly and had him and his brother down at one time.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
In the OP he said let's stick with just the seven movies, but even with TCW Obi wan took on amul evenly and had him and his brother down at one time.
Maul skill wise bested him as well. It's in the film. Kenobi was bfrd beaten in that very scene by Maul.

😂

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
Darn, but Obi wan remarked if Anakin practiced more he would rival Yoda. Sorry for the Inconvenience.

No worries. Thought he mentioned both Yoda and Windu in that scene.

Originally posted by Robtard
No worries. Thought he mentioned both Yoda and Windu in that scene.
😂

Originally posted by Robtard
No worries. Thought he mentioned both Yoda and Windu in that scene.

In that one he mentioned Yoda only, but when Anakin was helping Padme pack for Naboo he said as wise as Master Yoda and as Powerful as master Windu.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
In that one he mentioned Yoda only, but when Anakin was helping Padme pack for Naboo he said as wise as Master Yoda and as Powerful as master Windu.

Probably what I was thinking of then, been some time since I've seen the PT.

Originally posted by Robtard
Probably what I was thinking of then, been some time since I've seen the PT.

Cool. I applaud you know on your constant and thorough spanking of Quan everytime. 👍👏👍👏👍👏👍