Originally posted by FreshestSlice
No, but for some odd reason highly suspect you are if you can't even read the thousands of posts Ush felt the need to make on the subject.
Except 99.1239467% of "everything outside the numbered titles" is Legends. But I don't actually expect you to make a reasonable response since it's been clear to me after 2 days here that your sole purpose is to shit on other users here.
Yeah, cz's questioning moderation publicly. Time for exterminatus.
Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Except 99.1239467% of "everything outside the numbered titles" is Legends. But I don't actually expect you to make a reasonable response since it's been clear to me after 2 days here that your sole purpose is to shit on other users here.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
To take that over other sources though is what I'm getting at. I'm not saying don't use legends, I just didn't think using TFU as something to decide Palptines motives was a good idea.
If we're talking Legends I don't count one source as more valid then another unless it's contradicting itself somehow or is obviously bad writing.
I didn't say that.
I just said I don't personally see it as valid.
Like Freshest trying to bring up Vader tripping over his own arm.
Another example in regards to contradiction would be Barriss Offee being changed from a healer Jedi Knight to a Dark Jedi. I take the newer more official source that being TCW's interpretation. However I don't discount Barriss's other feats from Legends unless its canon only specifically.
Originally posted by FreshestSlice
I like how I'm the one talking shit when I gave a pretty reasonable response, that was set by moderation I might add, to which you responded by asking if I was retarded.
>EmperorSidious2 wants to dismiss TFU because it's not canon in the EU forum in a thread with a Legends exclusive character
>I call out him on that BS
>You show up to say something totally irrelevant just pick a side
Originally posted by cs_zoltan
>EmperorSidious2 wants to dismiss TFU because it's not canon in the EU forum in a thread with a Legends exclusive character
>I call out him on that BS
>You show up to say something totally irrelevant just pick a side
Legends
1. Yoda
2. Palpatine
3. Mace Windu
4. Count Dooku / Anakin Skywalker
5. Obi-Wan Kenobi
6. Darth Maul / General Grievous
7. Sora Bulq / Asajj Ventress
8. Quinlan Vos
9. Cin Drallig
Canon
1. Yoda
2. Mace Windu / Palpatine
3. Count Dooku / Anakin Skywalker
4. Obi-Wan Kenobi / Darth Maul / Quinlan Vos
5. Asajj Ventress
6. General Grievous
7. Depa Billaba
8. Cin Drallig
9. Sora Bulq
Originally posted by Syndicate
If we're talking Legends I don't count one source as more valid then another unless it's contradicting itself somehow or is obviously bad writing.
Ok that's fine glad we are clear on that. Really, I see it in Sidious personality which is displayed through the movies and other novels, that he wants to be the most powerful, and he wants to rule for thousands of years. He would mean he would be the emperor for all that time, not have a successor, so when he says Vader will surpass both him and Yoda and you say he's happy about that, I think we must take into context, he's not happy as that his apprentice will be more powerful, he's happy he will have someone that powerful as his apprentice and he will through manipulation keep him under control, or attempt to keep him under control whatever the case maybe.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
Ok that's fine glad we are clear on that. Really, I see it in Sidious personality which is displayed through the movies and other novels, that he wants to be the most powerful, and he wants to rule for thousands of years. He would mean he would be the emperor for all that time, not have a successor, so when he says Vader will surpass both him and Yoda and you say he's happy about that, I think we must take into context, he's not happy as that his apprentice will be more powerful, he's happy he will have someone that powerful as his apprentice and he will through manipulation keep him under control, or attempt to keep him under control whatever the case maybe.
I didn't say he seemed happy. That was somebody else mate.
Originally posted by cs_zoltan
>EmperorSidious2 wants to dismiss TFU because it's not canon in the EU forum in a thread with a Legends exclusive character
>I call out him on that BS
>You show up to say something totally irrelevant just pick a side
I don't want to dismiss it, I just thought that since Sidious Persoanlity, in canon, would contradict what I thought syndicate was saying. His personality in canon and what I would presume to be in legends as well, would be he wants to be on top, and he wouldn't want Vader to surpass him, but happy that he could have someone that powerful under his control or what he would be pressume to be under his control.
Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
I don't want to dismiss it, I just thought that since Sidious Persoanlity, in canon, would contradict what I thought syndicate was saying. His personality in canon and what I would presume to be in legends as well, would be he wants to be on top, and he wouldn't want Vader to surpass him, but happy that he could have someone that powerful under his control or what he would be pressume to be under his control.
Like I said when discusing Legends/EU I don't count one source as more valid then another unless it's obviously bad writing or contradictory to other sources.
Originally posted by FreshestSlice
It's not irrelevant, despite your moving of the goal posts. Threads are canon by default, and aside from the featless canon Sora, the rest all have some exposure in canon.
Except it's obvious for anyone that's not retarded, such as yourself, that it's a Legends thread.