Ahsoka Tano vs (Early) Galen Marek

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
'I don't know why I'm even bothering with you' honestly seems like it goes beyond that statement. I've never treated you badly tbh.

And not idiotic. Whenever Vader and Galen fight during TFU and TFUII, Vader never actually attempts to kill him and in the novel is described as not going all out, etc. And Galen, even then, is hard-pressed against him all the time. So, that's why.

The novel STATES that BEFORE that point Vader had either not been giving it his all or Galen himself had acquiesced so Vader at the time also had the advantage of Galen not knowing his full capabilities.

"The apprentice understood that, until this moment, they had never truly fought as equals. His master had either held back or he himself had capitulated."

And Galen still defeats him both in lightsaber combat and in the Force. This is after he's fought through the Imperials standing between him and the Rebel leaders on the Death Star. And even still he retains enough energy to fight Sidious afterwards.

Thus my seemingly "aggressive" response is really me being frustrated with the lack of thought that went into your post.

Originally posted by |King Joker|
[b]YOU HEARD IT HERE, FOLKS: SPARRING MATCHES WITH VADER > HOLDING YOUR OWN AGAINST A SERIOUS VADER WHO IS ACTUALLY TRYING TO MURDER YOU! [/B]

A 6 hour sparring match vs a fight that lasted a few minutes where Vader's main goal is retrieving a Sith Holocron.

Alright now. I have to go to school. Keep pumping out your cancer so I can nuke this thread when I return.

Originally posted by Syndicate
A 6 hour sparring match vs a fight that lasted a few minutes where Vader's main goal is retrieving a Sith Holocron.

Sparring with your master isn't the same as fighting him in a battle to the death, you ****ing moron.

Galen wrecks her in force.

Loses sabers.

All out is really up there.

Harder, Syn. Try harder. 🙂

I will only address this supposedly "idiotic" idea that Vader > Marek.

Marek defeated Vader in TFU, but that was in part a by-product of Vader becoming unbalanced by his application of Dun Moch.

On the other hand in their second confrontation with Marek's more powerful clone it's stated that:

He may have defeated Vader before, but Vader had learned from that mistake. He knew the measure of his former apprentice now.

And with Marek failing to apply any kind of Dun Moch he is decisively beaten. Hence Vader's superiority.

Originally posted by |King Joker|

Tbf I'm only saying all out is out there because idk which Galen this is.

Early Galen can range from the one who fought Ti, to the very earliest one.

The crazy thing is that galen is really young when he's performing all these feats, I'm pretty sure he was like 19
So imagine a living weapon trained by birth only in his prime
He would've been crazy
But because it's early galen I think ahsoka just about takes it (6/10)

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
Tbf I'm only saying all out is out there because idk which Galen this is.

Early Galen can range from the one who fought Ti, to the very earliest one.

Hm?

OP says it's Galen as of his fight with Kota.

Its not close when you consider how much more powerful Galen is.

I didn't read OP, sorry.

I guess the only thing that changes is that Ahsoka takes all out.

Although Force Powers would make a difference so meh.

Logically Ahsoka should be Maul-tier in the Force.

Regardless, she's a massively superior duelist to Galen at this point.

Is she really though?

Yes.

Originally posted by |King Joker|
Sparring with your master isn't the same as fighting him in a battle to the death, you ****ing moron.

What is it, Fresh? 🙂

You become more Freshest by the day. I'm proud of you.

Originally posted by Beniboybling

I will only address this supposedly "idiotic" idea that Vader > Marek.

Marek defeated Vader in TFU, but that was in part a by-product of Vader becoming unbalanced by his application of Dun Moch.

On the other hand in their second confrontation with Marek's more powerful clone it's stated that:

He may have defeated Vader before, but Vader had learned from that mistake. He knew the measure of his former apprentice now.

And with Marek failing to apply any kind of Dun Moch he is decisively beaten. Hence Vader's superiority.

Pretty much what I was referring to.

Anyway, what is for sure, tho, is that Galen is Ahsoka's superior in the Force by a significant margin. If this is all-out, I'm not sure the fight would end. If it's pure sabers, I think Ahsoka would win in a close fight.

Galen as of his fight with Kota is getting molested, not close at all.

Originally posted by FreshestSlice
You become more Freshest by the day. I'm proud of you.