Ahsoka Tano & Luke Skywalker vs. Darth Tyranus & Darth Maul

Started by AverageDebater4 pages

Ep6 Luke is on par with Vader by quotes about Ep6, and Vader is above Maul. The biggest thing Maul lifted was Eta shuttle, Vader lifted greater objects. He is also faster as seen by more afterimages in comic scans than Maul produced. Same goes with Dooku, although Dooku lifted objects Savage had problems with, and Savage was able to push a shuttle of the cliff, similiar to Savage.

Luke should be then > Dooku, and Dooku > Maul.

Ahsoka's fight against Maul was a stalemate in Rebels, so since Luke beats Dooku, Team 1 should win.

I am willing to debate this.

Originally posted by AverageDebater
Ep6 Luke is on par with Vader by quotes about Ep6, and Vader is above Maul. The biggest thing Maul lifted was Eta shuttle, Vader lifted greater objects. He is also faster as seen by more afterimages in comic scans than Maul produced. Same goes with Dooku, although Dooku lifted objects Savage had problems with, and Savage was able to push a shuttle of the cliff, similiar to Savage.

Luke should be then > Dooku, and Dooku > Maul.

Ahsoka's fight against Maul was a stalemate in Rebels, so since Luke beats Dooku, Team 1 should win.

I am willing to debate this.

You tried.

Originally posted by BestDebaterEver
You tried.
Thanks, I think it is more important to provide some arguments, not the best arguments, but solid ones, since most people won't change their mind either way, and longer tangents are not something authors would have in mind either way. It is all fiction after all and we shouldn't try too much, imo.

Originally posted by CactusJoe
carthage cleaned house here lol

You mean he got tooled, no logical person could legit believe he won that, he got dominated by Ell.

Originally posted by AverageDebater
Thanks, I think it is more important to provide some arguments, not the best arguments, but solid ones, since most people won't change their mind either way, and longer tangents are not something authors would have in mind either way. It is all fiction after all and we shouldn't try too much, imo.
At least your posts have some kind of merit and reasoning to them. I'm so happy my bed-wetting f*ggot son Timmy got banned. I'm ashamed of that little punk.

Originally posted by BestDebaterEver
At least your posts have some kind of merit and reasoning to them. I'm so happy my bed-wetting f*ggot son Timmy got banned. I'm ashamed of that little punk.

screw u

Originally posted by G-sus
screw u
Who the hell are you?

Originally posted by BestDebaterEver
Who the hell are you?

g-sus

Canon Only I definitely give this to the Sith team. Because in Canon it seems Luke is the weak link as of ROTJ.

I assume by Canon and Legends the OP mainly means Legends but has to include Canon because Rebels Ahsoka exists in canon only.

In that case team 1 wins the composite round, given in Legends Luke was =/> ROTJ Vader, and Rebels Vader was clearly > Ahsoka/Maul.

Either fight, I have Ahsoka and Maul approx on par, with the winner of Luke vs Dooku making the difference.

Either on Team 2 could potentially solo

I'm going with team 1, idk pretty ****ed rn